While definitely not the best game for the Wii, it is fun and that's all that really matters for Wii games in my opinion
User Rating: 7 | Iron Chef America: Supreme Cuisine WII
I do not know why everybody hates this game, granted, its not the best, but it is fun, especially to play with others! I've only played it a few times and some of the tasks are a bit tedious but overall it is a pretty solid game. I got this as a gift, and it was a mistake really since I watch Top Chef and the person who bought it for me thought I watched Iron Chef, which I've only seen once or twice and don't really care for. So I really didn't compare this to the show or expect much but I was actually surprised at how fun this game is, although it really has no depth. The basic idea is that you get given a chef to compete against and must make around 3-4 dishes using one main ingredient (i.e. zucchini or beef, etc.) and some of the tasks are actually quite a lot of fun, like chopping! I thought this was actually better than Cooking Mama, with the cartoonish graphics working a lot better than Cooking Mama's iPhonish quality graphics. Don't expect much from this game, which is safe to say with a lot of Wii titles actually, and just play to have fun really.
Graphics: 7.0 The graphics were pretty good for Wii and I thought the cartoonish aesthetic worked better than if they had attempted a more 3D look (considering Wii graphics capabilities)
Gameplay: 7.0 The gameplay while certainly not revolutionary is pretty fun and keeps your interest for a good amount of time.
Replayability 7.0 Although I certainly don't rush to play this game I think it is fun to play from time to time especially when friends are around.
Overall (Not an average of above scores): 7.0 This game is not the greatest, but it certainly is not terrible like they make it out to be and if you just play it for fun it will be fun.
