The last of the great space-combat-fighter games
You need a joystick to play this game, and I wouldn't want to play without one. Games of this type are just not the same with a mouse or gamepad. My Microsoft Sidewinder was great, and there are others. If you don't have a joystick, well I'd suggest you either get one or stay away from this game. If anyone gave this game a negative review, my guess is they tried playing it without a joystick.
I think the joystick issue is one reason why this genre lost popularity. For some reason, game publishers decided that gamers didn't have joysticks any more, so they stopped publishing games which utilized joysticks. After all, you can't port joystick games to consoles--the two don't mix. That's a shame because I miss games of this type. I wish they would let PC games be PC games and stop insisting that things work cross-platform just because it's an action-oriented game.