Faulty guitar in my bundle, medicore set list but still decent to play
The song list is pretty medicore. I don't really understand putting songs that are not popular on the main set list. I would think you would want to put the best songs from a band that everyone would know on the game. I am no stranger to music as I have 10.5+ days worth of music on my itunes from all genres yet I don't know some of these songs. I'd say the song list is about half good songs and half lame songs.
Hopefully the create a song and mixer mode will make up for this. Hopefully some skilled users w/ time on their hands will create some kick ass songs for us to play.
The game is really fun to play as a band with friends on the songs that everyone knows except for singing which usually somebody doesn't want to do. It is pretty hard to get the right pitch when singing but maybe that's because I don't use the mic much.
Overall I give the game a 7.5 because it is guitar hero which is always fun to play but me getting a crappy guitar and some of the horrible songs on here. I even asked my friends who have different musical tastes if the set list was good and they said no.