Does GTA 4 deserve a 10

Dont get me wrong the game is good but its not perfect. The only games that deserve a 10 have to be 100% perfect. I can only think of a few games that deserve a 10, like OoT FF7 starcraft. I know you will disagree with me on this but i like the driving on the other GTAs i rather turn on 100 and have it bing fake rather then slowing all the way down like in real life. Also i use to like the millitary and a few other things that were all fake. I would of given it a 8

what surprised me was that the reviewer that gave it a 10 said in his review that "the game isnt perfect." so, if it isn't perfect, why give it a ten?atomsmasher1313

Gamespots review means it's prime. They don't use perfect as a 10. 10 means prime.

Dont get me wrong the game is good but its not perfect. The only games that deserve a 10 have to be 100% perfect. I can only think of a few games that deserve a 10, like OoT FF7 starcraft. I know you will disagree with me on this but i like the driving on the other GTAs i rather turn on 100 and have it bing fake rather then slowing all the way down like in real life. Also i use to like the millitary and a few other things that were all fake. I would of given it a 8

EmperorZeruel

Let's all start topics and rate the game. Then something might change.

it got a ten bc its the biggest most detailed game in the last ten years. and its a blast to play.

honestly i think it does deserve a ten i mean all the big sites gave it tens, which doesnt happen often, so y not?

it got a ten bc its the biggest most detailed game in the last ten years. and its a blast to play.

honestly i think it does deserve a ten i mean all the big sites gave it tens, which doesnt happen often, so y not?

nahmean187

I think oblivion was bigger and more detailed than gta

A 10 doesnt have to be perfect.

And no this gmae does not deserve a 10

10 doesn't mean perfect for the last time, it just means it sets the bar higher and gives other games a bar of achievement to strive for. Toriko42

There you go, what makes you think something can even be perfect? Nothing is. 10/10 or 5/5 etc. from a reviewer means exactly what Toriko42 said.

I would personally give it a 9.5, its a really good game but its not perfect.RenegadePatriot

Gahh stop using that word already.:P

10 doesn't mean perfect for the last time, it just means it sets the bar higher and gives other games a bar of achievement to strive for. Toriko42

Many people don't understand this concept.

what surprised me was that the reviewer that gave it a 10 said in his review that "the game isnt perfect." so, if it isn't perfect, why give it a ten?atomsmasher1313

Its deffinetly not worth a 10! I'm just thinking they gave it a 10 because of the hype, and as its already said, the gave it a 10 and says the game isn't perfect...0_o. I will give GTAIV about a 9.0

what surprised me was that the reviewer that gave it a 10 said in his review that "the game isnt perfect." so, if it isn't perfect, why give it a ten?atomsmasher1313

this has been established in IGN that the reason it should get a 10 is that even though there are flaws, the game has so many good qualities that it makes up for those flaws, or something like that

what surprised me was that the reviewer that gave it a 10 said in his review that "the game isnt perfect." so, if it isn't perfect, why give it a ten?atomsmasher1313

A 10 isnt perfect.No game will ever be"perfect".

[QUOTE="nahmean187"]

it got a ten bc its the biggest most detailed game in the last ten years. and its a blast to play.

honestly i think it does deserve a ten i mean all the big sites gave it tens, which doesnt happen often, so y not?

Coffee_Blade

I think oblivion was bigger and more detailed than gta

Oblivion is definatly bigger than GTA especially with all the DLC but in no way it it more detailed

what surprised me was that the reviewer that gave it a 10 said in his review that "the game isnt perfect." so, if it isn't perfect, why give it a ten?atomsmasher1313

In my opinion. This game was overhyped and overrated. I personally would've given an 8.5. Right now its collecting dust. Once you beat the game there isn't much to do and the multiplayer is no fun at all. Sub-ZeroJoe

Im with you on this one. I beat the game, and now there really isnt much left to do except the "hang out with friends" missions and the occasional odd job.

Now that I got through the main story mission I don't think GTA4 deserve a 10. Its just missing little things. But it is still a fun and a must buy game. I give it a 9!

yes it does....think about it: not many games offer what GTA offers to a casual gamer. We all here are gamers but let's take a step back and observe many of the casual gamers who may have not beaten the campaign. You can't say that the campaign was terrible. It made you think about what you chose to do in situations and the results actually may have affected you (in my case anyway). The multiplayer isn't my favorite. I have absolutely no idea why but it may have to do with the incredibly large maps and the unfocused objectives you must complete throughout the entire multiplayer game. I absolutely love the city by the way. Not many of you actually consider what it must have taken to detail every single tree, building, and alleyway throughout the game. I mean SERIOUSLY consider it. It's tedious work but look at it, you are not complaining about that. Compare it to Saints Row, which had the same building model in multiple streets and highways. Every street in GTA is different. Every SINGLE car in the game handles differently. The physics system is just absolutely insane. Try jumping out of a moving helicopter and tell me that isn't realistic. The game took a step back in gameplay for realism and for me, that was worth it. Granted, I've never played any other GTA games. I'm just going off of what I heard.

In conclusion, ask yourself this question:

Would you rather play a game where you play as some random character with no feelings or thoughts and beat the bad guys with a limited amount of cutscenes and personal emotions (personal= your emotions). A.K.A. Saints Row.

Or...

Would you rather play as Niko Bellic. A man with nothing as he steps into one of the most violent and intense cities in the world as he battles alongside his cousin's friends and his friends' friends against mobs, citizens and the like.

Personally, you are being too hard. And when it comes down to it, I GUARANTEE you would've chastised Rockstar for not making the game more realistic if the gave you an incredible amount of stuff to do.

Thank you and goodbye.

i realy do not like the driving, and there are a lot of guns mising as well as a lot of other things that were in san adresses