Sign on Options
Theme: [Light Selected] To Dark»
ForumsOff-Topic Discussion › Israeli Airstrike in Gaza Kills Top Hama ...

The Classic Off-Topic forum is a place where games or platforms discussions are taboo. Here, you can talk about just about anything outside of games, just make sure to stay classy and follow the rules.

Forum Rules:
- Follow the Terms of Use and read the FAQ.
- Keep your discussions friendly and respectful of others.
- Keep the discussions work friendly. More details in the FAQ (For something more laid back go to Off Topic: After Hours
- Game and platform discussions NOT allowed (For that go to the Primary Games Board or System Wars.
- Do NOT post or bump extremely abusive discussions.
- Hate speech not permitted.

Israeli Airstrike in Gaza Kills Top Hamas Military Commander

Forum Actions
  • Level 52
    Spoony Bard
    Posts: 14201
    User is Online
    Nov 14, 2012 9:28 am GMT

    cslayer211 wrote:
    It seems the drone/airstrike version of a counter-insurgency has been the most effective way to get rid of terrorists.

    That is something of an oxymoron. COIN primarily involves a recognized government (in this case Israel, but since you made reference to bin Laden the US as well) trying to establish their authority over that of the insurgents, this is theoretically accomplished by containing the insurgency and then supplanting the insurgents authority.

    Simply flying over and bombing a target doesn't accomplish this. Insurgents can still operate between bombings, killing a top commander is nice, but the insurgents in question will just martyr the target and move on. Since it is difficult to distinguish and insurgent from a member of the general populace, we run into situations where we end up bombing civilians, we diminish our own authority while giving legitimacy to the insurgents.

    COIN calls for a large military force to enforce containment and by extension, casualties, drone strikes cannot do this.

    The entire premise of COIN is suspect anyway, there is no example of it actually working on this large of a scale.

    [QUOTE="cslayer211"]It seems the drone/airstrike version of a counter-insurgency has been the most effective way to get rid of terrorists.[/QUOTE]

    That is something of an oxymoron. COIN primarily involves a recognized government (in this case Israel, but since you made reference to bin Laden the US as well) trying to establish their authority over that of the insurgents, this is theoretically accomplished by containing the insurgency and then supplanting the insurgents authority.

    Simply flying over and bombing a target doesn't accomplish this. Insurgents can still operate between bombings, killing a top commander is nice, but the insurgents in question will just martyr the target and move on. Since it is difficult to distinguish and insurgent from a member of the general populace, we run into situations where we end up bombing civilians, we diminish our own authority while giving legitimacy to the insurgents.

    COIN calls for a large military force to enforce containment and by extension, casualties, drone strikes cannot do this.

    The entire premise of COIN is suspect anyway, there is no example of it actually working on this large of a scale.

  • Level 63
    Big Smoke
    Posts: 17240
    Site Greeter
    User is Online
    Nov 14, 2012 9:29 am GMT
    And likewise, dangamit, there will be Israeli people who will suffer by the actions of violence that will wish the same thing on Palestinian people.

    Remember: an eye for an eye will make the whole world blind - Gandhi.
    And likewise, dangamit, there will be Israeli people who will suffer by the actions of violence that will wish the same thing on Palestinian people. Remember: an eye for an eye will make the whole world blind - Gandhi.
  • Level 35
    Stitches
    Posts: 2554
    User is Online
    Nov 14, 2012 9:29 am GMT
    dangamit wrote:
    michaelP4 wrote:
    dangamit wrote:

    RIP. It's time for Hamas to retaliate.



    How is that going to improve the situation though? Hamas retaliates, Israel retaliates and it will go on and on and on. Both sides must totally renounce the use of violence and commit themselves to resolving this peacefully and democratically. If they don't, there is no end to this conflict.

    I live in Northern Ireland, so I know what it is like living in a deeply divided society - the only way to move forward is for both sides to get talking to each other and compromising.
    It was an Israeli aggression. A truce was sponsored by Egypt and both sides agreed to it, but Israel was the one who violated it with such a cowardly act. Not only did they kill the Hamas leader, they also managed to kill 3 children so far in air strikes on civilian areas. I hope Israel will pay dearly for both killing those children and ruining my day

    ok
    the next step is having the IDF flatten Gaza for the second time in 4 years. I think you people need to reconsider your retaliation mentality.
    [QUOTE="dangamit"][QUOTE="michaelP4"][QUOTE="dangamit"]

    RIP. It's time for Hamas to retaliate.

    [/QUOTE] How is that going to improve the situation though? Hamas retaliates, Israel retaliates and it will go on and on and on. Both sides must totally renounce the use of violence and commit themselves to resolving this peacefully and democratically. If they don't, there is no end to this conflict. I live in Northern Ireland, so I know what it is like living in a deeply divided society - the only way to move forward is for both sides to get talking to each other and compromising.[/QUOTE] It was an Israeli aggression. A truce was sponsored by Egypt and both sides agreed to it, but Israel was the one who violated it with such a cowardly act. Not only did they kill the Hamas leader, they also managed to kill 3 children so far in air strikes on civilian areas. I hope Israel will pay dearly for both killing those children and ruining my day [/QUOTE] ok the next step is having the IDF flatten Gaza for the second time in 4 years. I think you people need to reconsider your retaliation mentality.
  • Level 41
    Thunder Force
    Posts: 19738
    Nov 14, 2012 9:31 am GMT
    pie-junior wrote:
    GazaAli wrote:
    pie-junior wrote:

    behind you nate silver


    I see you are getting your orgasm already.
    This is gonna ruin an already post-apocalyptic Gaza...

    I'm saving your life gaza.
    Help me help you

    Like it was hard to figure that out by myself...

    married to the one and only kawaii Lebanese FMAB-GTOstolenlol~17-02-2012
    meconate the bra
    sss

    [QUOTE="pie-junior"][QUOTE="GazaAli"][QUOTE="pie-junior"]

    behind you nate silver

    [/QUOTE] I see you are getting your orgasm already. This is gonna ruin an already post-apocalyptic Gaza...[/QUOTE] I'm saving your life gaza. Help me help you[/QUOTE] Like it was hard to figure that out by myself...
  • Level 33
    Goombella
    Posts: 6015
    Nov 14, 2012 9:36 am GMT
    GazaAli wrote:
    pie-junior wrote:
    GazaAli wrote:

    I see you are getting your orgasm already.
    This is gonna ruin an already post-apocalyptic Gaza...

    I'm saving your life gaza.
    Help me help you

    Like it was hard to figure that out by myself...

    OT but where's your avatar from?

    Join the Dynasty Warriors Union if you like anything from Koei!

    Watch Anime Online

    [QUOTE="GazaAli"][QUOTE="pie-junior"][QUOTE="GazaAli"] I see you are getting your orgasm already. This is gonna ruin an already post-apocalyptic Gaza...[/QUOTE] I'm saving your life gaza. Help me help you[/QUOTE] Like it was hard to figure that out by myself...[/QUOTE] OT but where's your avatar from?
  • Level 35
    Stitches
    Posts: 2554
    User is Online
    Nov 14, 2012 9:41 am GMT
    GazaAli wrote:
    pie-junior wrote:
    GazaAli wrote:

    I see you are getting your orgasm already.
    This is gonna ruin an already post-apocalyptic Gaza...

    I'm saving your life gaza.
    Help me help you

    Like it was hard to figure that out by myself...

    and this is the thanks I get
    [QUOTE="GazaAli"][QUOTE="pie-junior"][QUOTE="GazaAli"] I see you are getting your orgasm already. This is gonna ruin an already post-apocalyptic Gaza...[/QUOTE] I'm saving your life gaza. Help me help you[/QUOTE] Like it was hard to figure that out by myself...[/QUOTE] and this is the thanks I get
  • Level 34
    Paramecium
    Posts: 4550
    User is Online
    Nov 14, 2012 9:44 am GMT
    This is so unsurprising its tragic. Israel breaks the truce to assassinate a general. I wonder how they expect anyone to trust them under any circumstances. This beyond anything shows that Israel doesn't hold its word for crap.
    justsayin117 wrote:
    alfredooo wrote:
    You obviously haven't played on forge world... way bigger than anything on Killzone. But Killzone does look better than Reach.
    Forge World is 5 maps combined into one, so technically, it doesnt count
    I don't even.....
    This is so unsurprising its tragic. Israel breaks the truce to assassinate a general. I wonder how they expect anyone to trust them under any circumstances. This beyond anything shows that Israel doesn't hold its word for crap.
  • Level 41
    Thunder Force
    Posts: 19738
    Nov 14, 2012 9:49 am GMT
    Victorious_Fize wrote:
    GazaAli wrote:
    pie-junior wrote:

    I'm saving your life gaza.
    Help me help you

    Like it was hard to figure that out by myself...

    OT but where's your avatar from?

    I have no idea to be honest.

    married to the one and only kawaii Lebanese FMAB-GTOstolenlol~17-02-2012
    meconate the bra
    sss

    [QUOTE="Victorious_Fize"][QUOTE="GazaAli"][QUOTE="pie-junior"] I'm saving your life gaza. Help me help you[/QUOTE] Like it was hard to figure that out by myself...[/QUOTE] OT but where's your avatar from?[/QUOTE] I have no idea to be honest.
  • Level 35
    Stitches
    Posts: 2554
    User is Online
    Nov 14, 2012 9:49 am GMT
    mayceV wrote:
    This is so unsurprising its tragic. Israel breaks the truce to assassinate a general. I wonder how they expect anyone to trust them under any circumstances. This beyond anything shows that Israel doesn't hold its word for crap.

    You know Israeli officials kept parroting 'There is no cease fire' over and over through the course of the 'truce'?
    [QUOTE="mayceV"]This is so unsurprising its tragic. Israel breaks the truce to assassinate a general. I wonder how they expect anyone to trust them under any circumstances. This beyond anything shows that Israel doesn't hold its word for crap. [/QUOTE] You know Israeli officials kept parroting 'There is no cease fire' over and over through the course of the 'truce'?
  • Level 63
    Big Smoke
    Posts: 20237
    Site Greeter
    User is Online
    Nov 14, 2012 9:49 am GMT
    mayceV wrote:
    This is so unsurprising its tragic. Israel breaks the truce to assassinate a general. I wonder how they expect anyone to trust them under any circumstances. This beyond anything shows that Israel doesn't hold its word for crap.


    the truce was broken for over a week.

    [QUOTE="mayceV"]This is so unsurprising its tragic. Israel breaks the truce to assassinate a general. I wonder how they expect anyone to trust them under any circumstances. This beyond anything shows that Israel doesn't hold its word for crap. [/QUOTE] the truce was broken for over a week.
  • Level 33
    Goombella
    Posts: 6015
    Nov 14, 2012 9:57 am GMT
    GazaAli wrote:
    Victorious_Fize wrote:
    GazaAli wrote:

    Like it was hard to figure that out by myself...

    OT but where's your avatar from?

    I have no idea to be honest.

    yoursig.jpg

    Join the Dynasty Warriors Union if you like anything from Koei!

    Watch Anime Online

    [QUOTE="GazaAli"][QUOTE="Victorious_Fize"][QUOTE="GazaAli"] Like it was hard to figure that out by myself...[/QUOTE] OT but where's your avatar from?[/QUOTE] I have no idea to be honest.[/QUOTE] yoursig.jpg
  • Level 34
    Paramecium
    Posts: 4550
    User is Online
    Nov 14, 2012 10:01 am GMT
    Darkman2007 wrote:
    mayceV wrote:
    This is so unsurprising its tragic. Israel breaks the truce to assassinate a general. I wonder how they expect anyone to trust them under any circumstances. This beyond anything shows that Israel doesn't hold its word for crap.


    the truce was broken for over a week.

    I am referring to the one that was..supposedly, brokered by Egypt just yesterday. Reading over it again though it seems as though it wasn't fully official though.
    justsayin117 wrote:
    alfredooo wrote:
    You obviously haven't played on forge world... way bigger than anything on Killzone. But Killzone does look better than Reach.
    Forge World is 5 maps combined into one, so technically, it doesnt count
    I don't even.....
    [QUOTE="Darkman2007"][QUOTE="mayceV"]This is so unsurprising its tragic. Israel breaks the truce to assassinate a general. I wonder how they expect anyone to trust them under any circumstances. This beyond anything shows that Israel doesn't hold its word for crap. [/QUOTE] the truce was broken for over a week.[/QUOTE] I am referring to the one that was..supposedly, brokered by Egypt just yesterday. Reading over it again though it seems as though it wasn't fully official though.
  • Level 63
    Big Smoke
    Posts: 20237
    Site Greeter
    User is Online
    Nov 14, 2012 10:08 am GMT
    mayceV wrote:
    Darkman2007 wrote:
    mayceV wrote:
    This is so unsurprising its tragic. Israel breaks the truce to assassinate a general. I wonder how they expect anyone to trust them under any circumstances. This beyond anything shows that Israel doesn't hold its word for crap.


    the truce was broken for over a week.

    I am referring to the one that was..supposedly, brokered by Egypt just yesterday. Reading over it again though it seems as though it wasn't fully official though.



    I haven't heard about that one tbh, could be something wasn't agreed on.

    though even the previous ceasefire was more of a lessfire

    [QUOTE="mayceV"][QUOTE="Darkman2007"][QUOTE="mayceV"]This is so unsurprising its tragic. Israel breaks the truce to assassinate a general. I wonder how they expect anyone to trust them under any circumstances. This beyond anything shows that Israel doesn't hold its word for crap. [/QUOTE] the truce was broken for over a week.[/QUOTE] I am referring to the one that was..supposedly, brokered by Egypt just yesterday. Reading over it again though it seems as though it wasn't fully official though. [/QUOTE] I haven't heard about that one tbh, could be something wasn't agreed on. though even the previous ceasefire was more of a lessfire
  • Level 45
    Mishima Zaibatsu
    Posts: 5491
    User is Online
    Nov 14, 2012 10:18 am GMT

    Just remember guys,they're the "Israeli Defence Force".

    SNIPER4321 wrote:
    AussieePet wrote:
    SNIPER4321 wrote:

    AussieePet wrote:
    Are you calling me a barbie doll?

    barbie, dora, hello kitty, hanna montana or any other crap why it matter?


    I assume you have all that inside your room

    what? Im Hardcore PC gamer and cant put these casual/girly/animish/pink stuff.

    Just remember guys,they're the "Israeli Defence Force".

  • Level 63
    Big Smoke
    Posts: 8446
    User is Online
    Nov 14, 2012 10:24 am GMT
    Hamas fired, like what 100+ rockets into Southern Israel and they expected no retaliation? Such a braindead move on their part. Hamas is still the main obstacle to Israeli-Palestinian peace. That's not to say that Israel isn't at fault either (they are also a big problem why this conflict is still ongoing) but when one says they are committed to the destruction of the other, how do you achieve peace then?

    ------------------------------------------------------

    Hamas fired, like what 100+ rockets into Southern Israel and they expected no retaliation? Such a braindead move on their part. Hamas is still the main obstacle to Israeli-Palestinian peace. That's not to say that Israel isn't at fault either (they are also a big problem why this conflict is still ongoing) but when one says they are committed to the destruction of the other, how do you achieve peace then?
  • Level 35
    Stitches
    Posts: 2554
    User is Online
    Nov 14, 2012 10:30 am GMT

    the_ChEeSe_mAn2 wrote:
    Hamas fired, like what 100+ rockets into Southern Israel

    IIRC, it was a 100 in a single day.

    That's pretty fvcking impressive, all considering.

    [QUOTE="the_ChEeSe_mAn2"]Hamas fired, like what 100+ rockets into Southern Israel[/QUOTE]

    IIRC, it was a 100 in a single day.

    That's pretty fvcking impressive, all considering.

  • Level 36
    Radical Ninja
    Posts: 3847
    User is Online
    Nov 14, 2012 11:04 am GMT

    RIP

    ______________________________________________
    Now Playing:
    Xbox 360 - BLOPS2, Sleeping Dogs
    PS3 - Spiderman Shattered Dimensions

    RIP

  • Level 30
    Wicked Sick!
    Posts: 23524
    User is Online
    Nov 14, 2012 11:11 am GMT
    th3warr1or wrote:
    Borukh Hashem!
    [QUOTE="th3warr1or"]Borukh Hashem! [/QUOTE]
  • Level 24
    I Feel Asleep!!
    Posts: 3170
    User is Online
    Nov 14, 2012 11:19 am GMT

    michaelP4 wrote:
    And likewise, dangamit, there will be Israeli people who will suffer by the actions of violence that will wish the same thing on Palestinian people. Remember: an eye for an eye will make the whole world blind - Gandhi.
    Palestine belongs to the Arabs - Ghandi

    [QUOTE="michaelP4"]And likewise, dangamit, there will be Israeli people who will suffer by the actions of violence that will wish the same thing on Palestinian people. Remember: an eye for an eye will make the whole world blind - Gandhi.[/QUOTE] Palestine belongs to the Arabs - Ghandi

Forum Actions
ForumsOff-Topic Discussion › Israeli Airstrike in Gaza Kills Top Hama ...