Search
Search
Sign on Options
Theme: [Light Selected] To Dark»
Forums › Sony PlayStation 3 › New F1 review!

This forum is considered a sanctuary for Playstation 3 owners. Anti-PS3 discussions will be considered a forum invasion.

- Follow the Terms of Use.
- Cross-platform discussions belong in System Wars.
- Illegal activities not allowed.

New F1 review!

« prev
Page:
Forum Actions
New Message
  • Bleach_is_basic
     
    Level 26
    Cyber-Lip
    Posts: 3023
    Feb 15, 2007 2:42 pm GMT
    http://www.computerandvideogames.com/article.php?id=158214

    4.8 / 10

    Ouch!

    This is a first party game made exclusively for the PS3. What do you think they should have done better? Apparently the graphics do look really good. Anyone a fan of these F1 games?

    Discuss.
    [URL]http://www.computerandvideogames.com/article.php?id=158214[/URL] 4.8 / 10 Ouch! This is a first party game made exclusively for the PS3. What do you think they should have done better? Apparently the graphics do look really good. Anyone a fan of these F1 games? Discuss.
    Report Abuse
  • Crazy87
     
    Level 35
    Stitches
    Posts: 2904
    Feb 15, 2007 2:45 pm GMT
    wow they must be a bad site to get reviews from or fanboys they gave motorstorm a 8/10 wow and they put one of the downers on it No mutiplayer that seals the deal they dont know what there doing

    wth all so i found the F1 game on the site and they gave it a 7/10 they have like 2 of each games stop bashing the ps3 please thanks http://www.computerandvideogames.com/article.php?id=157863
    Edited on Feb 15, 2007 2:46 pm GMT

    PS3 ID UkCobra

    XBL Crazy UkCobra

    http://folding.extremeoverclocking.com/sigs/sigimage.php?un=Crazy87&t=32721

    wow they must be a bad site to get reviews from or fanboys they gave motorstorm a 8/10 wow and they put one of the downers on it No mutiplayer that seals the deal they dont know what there doing

    wth all so i found the F1 game on the site and they gave it a 7/10 they have like 2 of each games stop bashing the ps3 please thanks http://www.computerandvideogames.com/article.php?id=157863
    Report Abuse
  • Viper_GTS-R
     
    Level 38
    DJ Boy
    Posts: 4501
    Feb 15, 2007 2:45 pm GMT
    The demo of the game was awesome but i felt something was missing from the demo :s

    Viper GTS PR -Xbox Live (^_^) Viper_PR -PSN

    Founder of The Everything Baseball Union..Still alive since 2005 (link below)

    The demo of the game was awesome but i felt something was missing from the demo :s
    Report Abuse
  • caseystryker
     
    Level 51
    Alien Hominid
    Posts: 5326
    User is Online
    Feb 15, 2007 2:47 pm GMT
    I wouldn't put much faith into that review.

    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~

    Friends may come and go, but enemies accumulate.

    - Thomas Jones


    I wouldn't put much faith into that review.
    Report Abuse
  • g-shocker
     
    Level 20
    Metal Slime
    Posts: 117
    Feb 15, 2007 2:48 pm GMT
    Wow.. that is a harsh review.. I had fun playing the demo and can't wait for the full version. I am guessing that this will not be a huge title in the states as the sport in general is not that big here.

    --------------------------------------------------------------------------



    IStillPlayGames.com - Check out our new podcast

    Wow.. that is a harsh review.. I had fun playing the demo and can't wait for the full version. I am guessing that this will not be a huge title in the states as the sport in general is not that big here.
    Report Abuse
  • Bleach_is_basic
     
    Level 26
    Cyber-Lip
    Posts: 3023
    Feb 15, 2007 2:50 pm GMT
    Crazy87 wrote:
    wow they must be a bad site to get reviews from or fanboys they gave motorstorm a 8/10 wow and they put one of the downers on it No mutiplayer that seals the deal they dont know what there doing

    wth all so i found the F1 game on the site and they gave it a 7/10 they have like 2 of each games stop bashing the ps3 please thanks http://www.computerandvideogames.com/article.php?id=157863


    They were reviewing the Japanese version. It says so in the review.

    Also at the end it says "No multiplayer just yet" so they are aware of the fact that multiplayer will be included in later versions.
    [QUOTE="Crazy87"]wow they must be a bad site to get reviews from or fanboys they gave motorstorm a 8/10 wow and they put one of the downers on it No mutiplayer that seals the deal they dont know what there doing

    wth all so i found the F1 game on the site and they gave it a 7/10 they have like 2 of each games stop bashing the ps3 please thanks http://www.computerandvideogames.com/article.php?id=157863
    [/QUOTE] They were reviewing the Japanese version. It says so in the review. Also at the end it says "No multiplayer just yet" so they are aware of the fact that multiplayer will be included in later versions.
    Report Abuse
  • Crazy87
     
    Level 35
    Stitches
    Posts: 2904
    Feb 15, 2007 2:51 pm GMT
    i see that review of a 4 was one guys opinon his name is Steve Williams  he gave it a 4 his opinon and the PSW staff gave it a 7/10 so that closes that

    PS3 ID UkCobra

    XBL Crazy UkCobra

    http://folding.extremeoverclocking.com/sigs/sigimage.php?un=Crazy87&t=32721

    i see that review of a 4 was one guys opinon his name is Steve Williams  he gave it a 4 his opinon and the PSW staff gave it a 7/10 so that closes that
    Report Abuse
  • Bleach_is_basic
     
    Level 26
    Cyber-Lip
    Posts: 3023
    Feb 15, 2007 2:51 pm GMT
    caseystryker wrote:
    I wouldn't put much faith into that review.


    Why not? Do they have a poor history of reviews or something?
    [QUOTE="caseystryker"]I wouldn't put much faith into that review.[/QUOTE] Why not? Do they have a poor history of reviews or something?
    Report Abuse
  • steve_89
     
    Level 22
    Blaster Master
    Posts: 793
    Feb 15, 2007 2:54 pm GMT
    hmmmm it kinda looked like they had a bone to pick with the game. i found the demo really fun. and the steering is great on the demo. unless they changed everything at the last minute i dont thing this reveiw is credable

    LoG-Sacrament wrote:

    Jesus-Halo-God wrote:
    LoG-Sacrament wrote:
    chocolate always makes up for domestic abuse.


    It wasn't domestic abuse. It was by mistake.

    OJ made a few mistakes too.

    hmmmm it kinda looked like they had a bone to pick with the game. i found the demo really fun. and the steering is great on the demo. unless they changed everything at the last minute i dont thing this reveiw is credable
    Report Abuse
  • mmirza23
     
    Level 28
    Bionic Commando
    Posts: 3456
    Feb 15, 2007 2:58 pm GMT
    I'd wait for an IGN review.


    Get your Portable ID!

    I'd wait for an IGN review.
    Report Abuse
  • rahzel54
     
    Level 25
    Defias Brotherhood
    Posts: 1732
    Feb 15, 2007 2:59 pm GMT
    i wasn't expecting much from this game anyway, but 4.8 is lower than i thought.

    but as others have said, i wouldn't put too much faith into 1 review.
    i wasn't expecting much from this game anyway, but 4.8 is lower than i thought. but as others have said, i wouldn't put too much faith into 1 review.
    Report Abuse
  • caseystryker
     
    Level 51
    Alien Hominid
    Posts: 5326
    User is Online
    Feb 15, 2007 3:00 pm GMT
    Bleach_is_basic wrote:
    caseystryker wrote:
    I wouldn't put much faith into that review.


    Why not? Do they have a poor history of reviews or something?

    Not that I know of, but the review was pretty harsh. And I've never even heard of that site before. The guy had absolutely nothing positive to say about it whatsoever. I've played the demo and I thought it was the best F1 game I've ever played. The reviewer just sounded way too biased and didn't try to review it from an objective angle. He even started off by saying how boring he though Formula 1 racing was. He lost all credibility after I read the first paragraph.

    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~

    Friends may come and go, but enemies accumulate.

    - Thomas Jones


    [QUOTE="Bleach_is_basic"][QUOTE="caseystryker"]I wouldn't put much faith into that review.[/QUOTE] Why not? Do they have a poor history of reviews or something?[/QUOTE] Not that I know of, but the review was pretty harsh. And I've never even heard of that site before. The guy had absolutely nothing positive to say about it whatsoever. I've played the demo and I thought it was the best F1 game I've ever played. The reviewer just sounded way too biased and didn't try to review it from an objective angle. He even started off by saying how boring he though Formula 1 racing was. He lost all credibility after I read the first paragraph.
    Report Abuse
  • jdt532
     
    Level 49
    Kidd Thunder !!
    Posts: 4214
    User is Online
    Feb 15, 2007 3:02 pm GMT
    If the demo is any indication of how the full game is I find it hard to believe that this game is that bad...

    If the demo is any indication of how the full game is I find it hard to believe that this game is that bad...
    Report Abuse
  • ScreamDream
     
    Level 71
    Castle Crasher
    Posts: 4396
    User is Online
    Feb 15, 2007 3:02 pm GMT

    He said EA's game has poor handling too. I know some F1 fans that would differ. Seems like he wants the game the way he thinks it should be or he will fail it.

    He said EA's game has poor handling too. I know some F1 fans that would differ. Seems like he wants the game the way he thinks it should be or he will fail it.

    Report Abuse
  • Bleach_is_basic
     
    Level 26
    Cyber-Lip
    Posts: 3023
    Feb 15, 2007 3:07 pm GMT
    caseystryker wrote:
    Bleach_is_basic wrote:
    caseystryker wrote:
    I wouldn't put much faith into that review.


    Why not? Do they have a poor history of reviews or something?

    Not that I know of, but the review was pretty harsh. And I've never even heard of that site before. The guy had absolutely nothing positive to say about it whatsoever. I've played the demo and I thought it was the best F1 game I've ever played. The reviewer just sounded way too biased and didn't try to review it from an objective angle. He even started off by saying how boring he though Formula 1 racing was. He lost all credibility after I read the first paragraph.


    Well then maybe you should have read on to the 2nd paragraph where he says he's a "helpless fan of the real sport..."
    [QUOTE="caseystryker"][QUOTE="Bleach_is_basic"][QUOTE="caseystryker"]I wouldn't put much faith into that review.[/QUOTE] Why not? Do they have a poor history of reviews or something?[/QUOTE] Not that I know of, but the review was pretty harsh. And I've never even heard of that site before. The guy had absolutely nothing positive to say about it whatsoever. I've played the demo and I thought it was the best F1 game I've ever played. The reviewer just sounded way too biased and didn't try to review it from an objective angle. He even started off by saying how boring he though Formula 1 racing was. He lost all credibility after I read the first paragraph.[/QUOTE] Well then maybe you should have read on to the 2nd paragraph where he says he's a "helpless fan of the real sport..."
    Report Abuse
  • mohammad112388
     
    Level 21
    Rescue Ranger
    Posts: 609
    Feb 15, 2007 3:15 pm GMT
    Im realy not surprised. The demo was painfully awful. The graphics are great though.
    Im realy not surprised. The demo was painfully awful. The graphics are great though.
    Report Abuse
  • longhorn7
     
    Level 23
    Super Bagman
    Posts: 4649
    Feb 15, 2007 3:19 pm GMT
    the guy spelled tire wrong throughout the whole review...was he trying to be cool or is he just illiterate? Also, the steering in that game was nowhere near difficult, i think maybe he should release the gas pedal in his turns so he doenst go into the wall everytime...i thought you had to be able to play games at a certain level of ability to be able to review them...i guess not

    NOW PLAYING

    PS3- Dead Space, MGS4, Motorstorm 2

    Wii- Twilight Princess, Smash Bros, Mario Kart

    PC- Left 4 Dead, UT2k4, Crysis, Red Alert 3, Audiosurf

    the guy spelled tire wrong throughout the whole review...was he trying to be cool or is he just illiterate? Also, the steering in that game was nowhere near difficult, i think maybe he should release the gas pedal in his turns so he doenst go into the wall everytime...i thought you had to be able to play games at a certain level of ability to be able to review them...i guess not
    Report Abuse
  • davez82
     
    Level 22
    Blaster Master
    Posts: 1860
    Feb 15, 2007 3:22 pm GMT
    dood its f1.. how exciting can something based on F1 get.. not at all

    ____________________________________________



    psnid : davez82

    dood its f1.. how exciting can something based on F1 get.. not at all
    Report Abuse
  • Krigon
     
    Level 29
    Radiant Silvergun
    Posts: 5593
    Feb 15, 2007 3:24 pm GMT
    Bleach_is_basic wrote:
    caseystryker wrote:
    Bleach_is_basic wrote:
    caseystryker wrote:
    I wouldn't put much faith into that review.


    Why not? Do they have a poor history of reviews or something?

    Not that I know of, but the review was pretty harsh. And I've never even heard of that site before. The guy had absolutely nothing positive to say about it whatsoever. I've played the demo and I thought it was the best F1 game I've ever played. The reviewer just sounded way too biased and didn't try to review it from an objective angle. He even started off by saying how boring he though Formula 1 racing was. He lost all credibility after I read the first paragraph.


    Well then maybe you should have read on to the 2nd paragraph where he says he's a "helpless fan of the real sport..."
    How is a guy suppose to be objective, when he opens with "Find F1 just too boring to watch? Don't worry - if this simulation is anything like authentic, then the people taking part aren't having any fun either. Perhaps that's why they all drive so fast - they're just desperate to get it over with. Whatever, this really very attractive game is hand-wringingly dull."

    If i find baseball boring, i wouldn't review a baseball game.
    Edited on Feb 15, 2007 3:25 pm GMT


    [QUOTE="Bleach_is_basic"][QUOTE="caseystryker"][QUOTE="Bleach_is_basic"][QUOTE="caseystryker"]I wouldn't put much faith into that review.[/QUOTE] Why not? Do they have a poor history of reviews or something?[/QUOTE] Not that I know of, but the review was pretty harsh. And I've never even heard of that site before. The guy had absolutely nothing positive to say about it whatsoever. I've played the demo and I thought it was the best F1 game I've ever played. The reviewer just sounded way too biased and didn't try to review it from an objective angle. He even started off by saying how boring he though Formula 1 racing was. He lost all credibility after I read the first paragraph.[/QUOTE] Well then maybe you should have read on to the 2nd paragraph where he says he's a "helpless fan of the real sport..."[/QUOTE] How is a guy suppose to be objective, when he opens with "Find F1 just too boring to watch? Don't worry - if this simulation is anything like authentic, then the people taking part aren't having any fun either. Perhaps that's why they all drive so fast - they're just desperate to get it over with. Whatever, this really very attractive game is hand-wringingly dull."

    If i find baseball boring, i wouldn't review a baseball game.
    Report Abuse
  • chubear700
     
    Level 28
    Bionic Commando
    Posts: 1981
    Feb 15, 2007 3:39 pm GMT
    bleach_is_basic, you just roam the entire web searching for any piece of dirt you can find on the PS3 and it's games. lol I don't get it, if you really don't like the system why do you even bother with a system you obviously don't like?
    Edited on Feb 15, 2007 3:40 pm GMT
    GastaS wrote:Oblivion even coming after xbox360 version will get poorly 8... I dont belive that the poor Cell can render nice graphics.
    :lol: bleach_is_basic, you just roam the entire web searching for any piece of dirt you can find on the PS3 and it's games. lol I don't get it, if you really don't like the system why do you even bother with a system you obviously don't like? :lol:
    Report Abuse
Forum Actions
New Message
« prev
Page:
Forums › Sony PlayStation 3 › New F1 review!