Sign on Options
Theme: [Light Selected] To Dark»
ForumsSony PlayStation 3 › Biased Gamespot reviews

This forum is considered a sanctuary for Playstation 3 owners. Anti-PS3 discussions will be considered a forum invasion.

- Follow the Terms of Use.
- Cross-platform discussions belong in System Wars.
- Illegal activities not allowed.

Biased Gamespot reviews

Forum Actions
Thread locked
  • Level 34
    Paramecium
    Posts: 5110
    User is Online
    Feb 12, 2007 6:08 am GMT
    Well, I have finally come to realization that gamespot is full of Xbox 360 fanboys.  Fight Nights Round 3 got a score of 8.3 on 360 and 8.2 on the PS3.  Now the difference is the one point in graphics were the PS3 got 8 while the 360 got a 9.  I believe this point difference is in the lighting in the background, which is only more of, of bright wall spots nothing really special.  Both should have gotten a 9.  But here is the kicker, the PS3 version has first person perceptive boxing.  Hmm, to me this should have given the PS3 version 1 or 2 points making it equal or higher rated then the 360 version.  The graphics deduction is strickely fanboyism because the game looks fantastic on the PS3.  Your thoughts?

    Gaming setup: PS3 120 Gb, Xbox 360 250 Gb, Wii,Onkyo HT-S9400 THX 7.1 Ch Network Home Theater Receiver/Speaker (ONKHTS9400), Vizio 47 1080P 3D HDTV, Turtle Beach X12.

    Well, I have finally come to realization that gamespot is full of Xbox 360 fanboys.  Fight Nights Round 3 got a score of 8.3 on 360 and 8.2 on the PS3.  Now the difference is the one point in graphics were the PS3 got 8 while the 360 got a 9.  I believe this point difference is in the lighting in the background, which is only more of, of bright wall spots nothing really special.  Both should have gotten a 9.  But here is the kicker, the PS3 version has first person perceptive boxing.  Hmm, to me this should have given the PS3 version 1 or 2 points making it equal or higher rated then the 360 version.  The graphics deduction is strickely fanboyism because the game looks fantastic on the PS3.  Your thoughts?
    • Locked thread
  • Level 35
    Stitches
    Posts: 496
    Feb 12, 2007 6:13 am GMT
    I think the same

    I think the same :evil:
    • Locked thread
  • Level 22
    Blaster Master
    Posts: 2782
    Feb 12, 2007 6:15 am GMT
    pixel crowds....

     

     

     

    pixel crowds....
    • Locked thread
  • Level 15
    Nobunaga's Ambition
    Posts: 272
    Feb 12, 2007 6:15 am GMT
    caseypayne69 wrote:
    Well, I have finally come to realization that gamespot is full of Xbox 360 fanboys.  Fight Nights Round 3 got a score of 8.3 on 360 and 8.2 on the PS3.  Now the difference is the one point in graphics were the PS3 got 8 while the 360 got a 9.  I believe this point difference is in the lighting in the background, which is only more of, of bright wall spots nothing really special.  Both should have gotten a 9.  But here is the kicker, the PS3 version has first person perceptive boxing.  Hmm, to me this should have given the PS3 version 1 or 2 points making it equal or higher rated then the 360 version.  The graphics deduction is strickely fanboyism because the game looks fantastic on the PS3.  Your thoughts?


    It does look fantastic on the PS3, but the other version does looks better. Not only is the lighting better, and not just on the walls, but the crowd looks a ton better on 360 too. Sure, the first person mode is a nice add on, but they were still reviewing a game that already came out way back in march. Same reason why oblivion will probably score around the 9.1-9.3 range.
    [QUOTE="caseypayne69"]Well, I have finally come to realization that gamespot is full of Xbox 360 fanboys.  Fight Nights Round 3 got a score of 8.3 on 360 and 8.2 on the PS3.  Now the difference is the one point in graphics were the PS3 got 8 while the 360 got a 9.  I believe this point difference is in the lighting in the background, which is only more of, of bright wall spots nothing really special.  Both should have gotten a 9.  But here is the kicker, the PS3 version has first person perceptive boxing.  Hmm, to me this should have given the PS3 version 1 or 2 points making it equal or higher rated then the 360 version.  The graphics deduction is strickely fanboyism because the game looks fantastic on the PS3.  Your thoughts?[/QUOTE] It does look fantastic on the PS3, but the other version does looks better. Not only is the lighting better, and not just on the walls, but the crowd looks a ton better on 360 too. Sure, the first person mode is a nice add on, but they were still reviewing a game that already came out way back in march. Same reason why oblivion will probably score around the 9.1-9.3 range.
    • Locked thread
  • Level 29
    Radiant Silvergun
    Posts: 4094
    Feb 12, 2007 6:18 am GMT
    y does it matter really what score any game gets as long as its good to you, and especially by a .1,it dont bother me. i think people on here totally over react over a score between 360 and ps3 games, you do have the option to give your own review but if your a ps3 fanboy obviously you will find a way to always make ps3 games better and vice versa if your a 360 fan. so its hard to judge i dont pay attention to all the biased crap if you dont like nothing says you have to listen to GS reveiws see what other sites gave it. Actually if you go to IGN.com they gave the ps3 version 8.3 and the xbox 360 version 8.5 so are they more biased now thats 2 sites that have it better. i think you need to check other sites as well if then GS is the only one that does the score that way ok they could be biased but in this case and to the point who cares as long as the game is good to you and your having fun
    y does it matter really what score any game gets as long as its good to you, and especially by a .1,it dont bother me. i think people on here totally over react over a score between 360 and ps3 games, you do have the option to give your own review but if your a ps3 fanboy obviously you will find a way to always make ps3 games better and vice versa if your a 360 fan. so its hard to judge i dont pay attention to all the biased crap if you dont like nothing says you have to listen to GS reveiws see what other sites gave it. Actually if you go to IGN.com they gave the ps3 version 8.3 and the xbox 360 version 8.5 so are they more biased now thats 2 sites that have it better. i think you need to check other sites as well if then GS is the only one that does the score that way ok they could be biased but in this case and to the point who cares as long as the game is good to you and your having fun
    • Locked thread
Forum Actions
ForumsSony PlayStation 3 › Biased Gamespot reviews