Season 4 Episode 18: Maud Pie

#1 Posted by Celldrax (14607 posts) -

Yeah, it was alright.

They might've been trying a bit too much with Maud's characterisation, but I think pinkie is definitely written better when the episode is more focused on her.

Had some funnies as well.

#2 Edited by n33d2skate (5069 posts) -

@Celldrax said:

Yeah, it was alright.

They might've been trying a bit too much with Maud's characterisation, but I think pinkie is definitely written better when the episode is more focused on her.

Had some funnies as well.

I absolutely loved Maud.

#3 Posted by meetroid8 (21139 posts) -

I think I laughed more during this episode than I have during any other. Maud was perfect. Her pet rock, her poetry, her "I threw it." She was hilarious. This might be my favorite episode. This is the first time in a very long time when I've wanted to actually rewatch an episode right away.

#4 Posted by n33d2skate (5069 posts) -

@meetroid8 said:

I think I laughed more during this episode than I have during any other. Maud was perfect. Her pet rock, her poetry, her "I threw it." She was hilarious. This might be my favorite episode. This is the first time in a very long time when I've wanted to actually rewatch an episode right away.

Yeah, I really, really enjoyed this one and it was all because of Maude. Everything she said was incredible.

#5 Posted by kierwinyoung (3147 posts) -

WOOOHHOOOO!!! Maud ROCKS!

Even though she's (beside Pinkie) got the main focus. plus she's a Background pony right? anyway. Her emotions and sense of expressions are really good. almost all of her part is funny, poem. looking at the Rock rather than the spider, and the Rock Nuke. Somehow when she grabbed her costume when she's saving Pinkie. The helmet somehow Reminds me of...... I don't know. Nazi?

#6 Posted by Celldrax (14607 posts) -

@kierwinyoung said:

WOOOHHOOOO!!! Maud ROCKS!

Even though she's (beside Pinkie) got the main focus. plus she's a Background pony right? anyway. Her emotions and sense of expressions are really good. almost all of her part is funny, poem. looking at the Rock rather than the spider, and the Rock Nuke. Somehow when she grabbed her costume when she's saving Pinkie. The helmet somehow Reminds me of...... I don't know. Nazi?

Sieg heil!

I'm still not entirely sure about Maud though. I can appreciate what they were trying to do with her character, but I guess she just didn't click with me as much as she has with others.

#7 Posted by kierwinyoung (3147 posts) -

@Celldrax: See! That's Exactly what I'm talking about!

And about not being sure about her. Just give 'em a chance again or two when she shows up again in later episodes.

#8 Posted by Watershiprabbit (46 posts) -

I hope Maud Pie returns in S5.

#9 Posted by Watershiprabbit (46 posts) -

I hope that Maud Pie returns in S5.

#10 Posted by n33d2skate (5069 posts) -

@Watershiprabbit: Me too, she was hilarious