Sig/Avy Discussion ('Rate My Sig' Thread)

#1 Posted by Cloud_765 (111391 posts) -

You saw the title. Here you can discuss, rate, critique, etc.

I has a new one, made it today. =D

#2 Posted by julian_jr (83416 posts) -
Oh rate mine! RATE IT!!! :x
#3 Posted by Cloud_765 (111391 posts) -
Oh rate mine! RATE IT!!! :xjulian_jr
I'd say 8.5/10. It's way too simple for my liking, but the simplicity really works in its favor. I like the coffee-like feel of it.
#4 Posted by lancelot200 (61977 posts) -
@Cloud: I think the stock image is poor quality. So...
#5 Posted by Cloud_765 (111391 posts) -
@Cloud: I think the stock image is poor quality. So...lancelot200
Stock image? I don't use stocks...
#6 Posted by lancelot200 (61977 posts) -
[QUOTE="lancelot200"]@Cloud: I think the stock image is poor quality. So...Cloud_765
Stock image? I don't use stocks...

I might have the wrong terminology. The Yugioh image could look better.
#7 Posted by MasonLovak (787 posts) -

[QUOTE="Cloud_765"][QUOTE="lancelot200"]@Cloud: I think the stock image is poor quality. So...lancelot200
Stock image? I don't use stocks...

I might have the wrong terminology. The Yugioh image could look better.

I agree. Though it is a nice sig/avy combo I think. 8/10 from me.

#8 Posted by Cloud_765 (111391 posts) -
[QUOTE="Cloud_765"][QUOTE="lancelot200"]@Cloud: I think the stock image is poor quality. So...lancelot200
Stock image? I don't use stocks...

I might have the wrong terminology. The Yugioh image could look better.

It's a lot sharper than the original I saved onto my computer... Besides, your image isn't the prettiest to look at either. :P Looks kinda grainy.
#9 Posted by julian_jr (83416 posts) -
[QUOTE="julian_jr"]Oh rate mine! RATE IT!!! :xCloud_765
I'd say 8.5/10. It's way too simple for my liking, but the simplicity really works in its favor. I like the coffee-like feel of it.

Coffee like feel? :? It's just supposed to be something abstract, which barely any GS designers nowadays can create.
#10 Posted by jediknight52501 (69715 posts) -
i could care less what kind of rating i get.
#11 Posted by MasonLovak (787 posts) -

i could care less what kind of rating i get.jediknight52501

You get a 0/10 from me then :lol:

#12 Posted by lancelot200 (61977 posts) -
@Cloud: I don't know what grainy means in terms of image, but I know my sig is dark.
#13 Posted by noxboxlive (5856 posts) -
Rate mine!
#14 Posted by jediknight52501 (69715 posts) -

[QUOTE="jediknight52501"]i could care less what kind of rating i get.MasonLovak

You get a 0/10 from me then :lol:

i don't care.
Rate mine!noxboxlive
10/10.
#15 Posted by TopStarRacer (5732 posts) -

I don't care what people rate my avatar because I'm gonna use it no matter what. :P I don't think I'll ever change it (or at least in a long time).

Signature though, is something I'm more likely to change every now and then.

#16 Posted by jediknight52501 (69715 posts) -

I don't care what people rate my avatar because I'm gonna use it no matter what. :P I don't think I'll ever change it (or at least in a long time).

Signature though, is something I'm more likely to change every now and then.

TopStarRacer
i will change mine again someday.
#17 Posted by Sandulf29 (14151 posts) -

@Cloud: I will give it 8.5/10. It could use some depth tho still nice

Rate mine 

#18 Posted by Nightmare-_- (17415 posts) -

9.5/10

fonts could use some work kinda hard to read and loving layer of brush. ;)

#19 Posted by PolskaKing (39592 posts) -
I'm not even gonna bother asking. :P
#20 Posted by julian_jr (83416 posts) -
I'm not even gonna bother asking. :PPolskaKing
Your sig sucks! :x It's not even a sig, just some links and a tag! :x :P
#21 Posted by PolskaKing (39592 posts) -
[QUOTE="PolskaKing"]I'm not even gonna bother asking. :Pjulian_jr
Your sig sucks! :x It's not even a sig, just some links and a tag! :x :P

:cry: I'm too lazy to get a good sig! :cry:
#22 Posted by julian_jr (83416 posts) -
:cry: I'm too lazy to get a good sig! :cry:PolskaKing
You should have asked NFS while he was around! Actually you could probably request someone somewhere, however there's not as many good designers in GS nowadays
#23 Posted by PolskaKing (39592 posts) -
[QUOTE="PolskaKing"]:cry: I'm too lazy to get a good sig! :cry:julian_jr
You should have asked NFS while he was around! Actually you could probably request someone somewhere, however there's not as many good designers in GS nowadays

I barely had a sig back then as well! Yeah...but since they're not as good anymore, there's no point. :P
#24 Posted by Sandulf29 (14151 posts) -

you peeps don't like my skills. fine I am fulfilling no requests for you guys :x

:P 

#25 Posted by julian_jr (83416 posts) -
Something's better than nothing lol. Most designers can still make most things out there just don't request an abstract sig like mine since that's one of the toughest things to make for a designer and I doubt many people in GS today could make a good one
#26 Posted by PolskaKing (39592 posts) -
Something's better than nothing lol. Most designers can still make most things out there just don't request an abstract sig like mine since that's one of the toughest things to make for a designer and I doubt many people in GS today could make a good onejulian_jr
But those are the best kind! :cry: :P

you peeps don't like my skills. fine I am fulfilling no requests for you guys :x

:P 

Sandulf29
No, their horrible. GTFO. :P
#27 Posted by julian_jr (83416 posts) -
You're not getting an abstract sig in GS! :x You'd need someone like -masterchef- to come back and make one. Not even NFS could do abstract very well, hence my blog header he made for me. :P
#28 Posted by julian_jr (83416 posts) -

you peeps don't like my skills. fine I am fulfilling no requests for you guys :x

:P 

Sandulf29
You never offered it in the first place! :x
#29 Posted by PolskaKing (39592 posts) -
You're not getting an abstract sig in GS! :x You'd need someone like -masterchef- to come back and make one. Not even NFS could do abstract very well, hence my blog header he made for me. :Pjulian_jr
:( Damn...It's either I wait for that, or learn myself. I'm way too lazy to learn myself. :P
#30 Posted by julian_jr (83416 posts) -
[QUOTE="julian_jr"]You're not getting an abstract sig in GS! :x You'd need someone like -masterchef- to come back and make one. Not even NFS could do abstract very well, hence my blog header he made for me. :PPolskaKing
:( Damn...It's either I wait for that, or learn myself. I'm way too lazy to learn myself. :P

NFS couldn't do it after a year of designing soooo.... :| You should go to a designing union and request they make something similar to my sig. :P Then see how they react and if they can come close to what masterchef did. :P
#31 Posted by PolskaKing (39592 posts) -
[QUOTE="julian_jr"] NFS couldn't do it after a year of designing soooo.... :| You should go to a designing union and request they make something similar to my sig. :P Then see how they react and if they can come close to what masterchef did. :P

But he was using GIMP. :P :lol: Maybe I should. :P
#32 Posted by Sandulf29 (14151 posts) -

Something's better than nothing lol. Most designers can still make most things out there just don't request an abstract sig like mine since that's one of the toughest things to make for a designer and I doubt many people in GS today could make a good onejulian_jr
I yhink you mean vector sigs. That takes too much time like weeks. Most of time goes in making vector. We designers are moody, if we hae time and mood we would do it. I have seen Boba make couple of such many times.
You never offered it in the first place! :xjulian_jr
keep saying mean things and I won't :P

It depends on my mood if I take a request or not 

#33 Posted by julian_jr (83416 posts) -
[QUOTE="PolskaKing"][QUOTE="julian_jr"] NFS couldn't do it after a year of designing soooo.... :| You should go to a designing union and request they make something similar to my sig. :P Then see how they react and if they can come close to what masterchef did. :P

But he was using GIMP. :P :lol: Maybe I should. :P

You should, that way I can see their reactions as well. :P
#34 Posted by julian_jr (83416 posts) -

[QUOTE="julian_jr"]Something's better than nothing lol. Most designers can still make most things out there just don't request an abstract sig like mine since that's one of the toughest things to make for a designer and I doubt many people in GS today could make a good oneSandulf29

I yhink you mean vector sigs. That takes too much time like weeks. Most of time goes in making vector. We designers are moody, if we hae time and mood we would do it. I have seen Boba make couple of such many times.
You never offered it in the first place! :xjulian_jr
keep saying mean things and I won't :P

It depends on my mood if I take a request or not 

The person I requested to make my sig made this in a single day. He was one of the best in all of GS before he left, and could make anything easily.
#35 Posted by PolskaKing (39592 posts) -
[QUOTE="julian_jr"] You should, that way I can see their reactions as well. :P

One day J...one day. :P
#36 Posted by julian_jr (83416 posts) -
[QUOTE="PolskaKing"][QUOTE="julian_jr"] You should, that way I can see their reactions as well. :P

One day J...one day. :P

I'll give you some vodka if you do it! :P
#37 Posted by Sandulf29 (14151 posts) -

I could try and make something like that. It doesn't look tough. In fact simpler compared to Boba's work.

This is some of good Boba's abstract work I have been talking about

 

#38 Posted by PolskaKing (39592 posts) -
[QUOTE="julian_jr"] I'll give you some vodka if you do it! :P

:o That's an offer I shouldn't refuse.
#39 Posted by julian_jr (83416 posts) -

I could try and make something like that. It doesn't look tough. In fact simpler compared to Boba's work.

This is some of good Boba's abstract work I have been talking about

 

Sandulf29
That's a pretty nice sig! He spent much more time on it than this person did on my sig (I still love my sig tho! :x)
#40 Posted by julian_jr (83416 posts) -
[QUOTE="PolskaKing"][QUOTE="julian_jr"] I'll give you some vodka if you do it! :P

:o That's an offer I shouldn't refuse.

Then do it! :twisted:
#41 Posted by MasonLovak (787 posts) -

[QUOTE="julian_jr"][QUOTE="PolskaKing"]I'm not even gonna bother asking. :PPolskaKing
Your sig sucks! :x It's not even a sig, just some links and a tag! :x :P

:cry: I'm too lazy to get a good sig! :cry:

Well, I could make one for you if you want

#42 Posted by PolskaKing (39592 posts) -
[QUOTE="julian_jr"] Then do it! :twisted:

Not now! :x
Well, I could make one for you if you wantMasonLovak
Thank you for the offer, but as you can see, J and I have a funny idea to get someone try to create something similar to his. :P
#43 Posted by Sandulf29 (14151 posts) -
That's a pretty nice sig! He spent much more time on it than this person did on my sig (I still love my sig tho! :x) julian_jr
Your sig seems simple to me. Avy is smashing. Sig could use something more
#44 Posted by julian_jr (83416 posts) -

Well, I could make one for you if you want

MasonLovak
Polska here's your chance. 8)
#45 Posted by julian_jr (83416 posts) -
[QUOTE="julian_jr"]That's a pretty nice sig! He spent much more time on it than this person did on my sig (I still love my sig tho! :x) Sandulf29
Your sig seems simple to me. Avy is smashing. Sig could use something more

I enjoy the simplicity of the sig. It's bright enough to grab attention and at the same time is something simple and elegant. 8)
#46 Posted by PolskaKing (39592 posts) -
[QUOTE="MasonLovak"]

Well, I could make one for you if you want

julian_jr
Polska here's your chance. 8)

...>_>
Well, I could make one for you if you want MasonLovak
Disregard the post directed to you, I accept! Make one similar to J's except in white and red.
#47 Posted by julian_jr (83416 posts) -
Hey mine is not just two colors! :x It's a blend of many. 8)
#48 Posted by Overlord93 (12602 posts) -
I like Julian's sig the best since it's so recognisable :o
#49 Posted by PolskaKing (39592 posts) -
Hey mine is not just two colors! :x It's a blend of many. 8)julian_jr
I see Purple/Pink with Orange. I thinks that's two colors. :P
#50 Posted by julian_jr (83416 posts) -
I like Julian's sig the best since it's so recognisable :oOverlord93
That's what 3 years of having the same sig and avy does to ya. 8) :P