I have used both, the ds4 is much better than the ds3, but the cheese thumbsticks hurt it. its a 8/10, the thumbsticks take away 1 point, and the thumbstick placement takes a point away. Xbox is a 10/10. I used it 5 times, and I just purchased one that is sitting on my fireplace. I charged it last night from the 360, its sleek, it feels unreal in your hands, the rumble effect in triggers is absolutely a home run. NBA2K14 when you dribble the ball in the right or left hand the triggers respond with a rumble. Its extremely well done. Also The thumbsticks have a grip texture around it and its very tactile to the touch, and guard against whats happening to the DS4 thumbsticks where it gets all scratched up to shit and looks like you put it in a blender, I played Forza and again this feature shined Day 1 edition, thank god I didn't cancel. Cast your vote
1 for xbox one
4 for ds4
and describe why I am wrong and or why you agree with me.