Some of mine:
Metroid Prime 3 is better than Metroid Prime 1 (never played 2). Granted, I haven't gotten to the fetch quest at the end yet, but I prefer its gameplay and pacing.
God of War is mind-numbingly boring. Hack and slash games need great combat to work IMO, and God of War is very lacking in this area. Light puzzle/platforming sequences don't make up for this whatsoever.
Animal Crossing sucks. Outside of constructing your crib, there is nothing remotely interesting about the game. Harvest Moon sh!ts all over it as far as life simulators go.
A Link To the Past is not even close to being the best Zelda. The dungeon design is pretty barebones compared to later games in the series.
Uncharted characters are very cookie cutter even in spite of the superb voice acting. They seem like the kind of vanilla characters that come out of a B action movie or a made for TV action movie IMO. I think the idea that they are best gaming has to offer is ridiculous.
Resident Evil 5 is not that bad. Granted, I played the whole thing in co-op so that undoubtedly improved the experience, but it was a pretty good action game IMO. Yes, RE4 sh!ts on it from a great height, but that doesn't mean it's not a decent game on its own merits.
Klonoa sucks. Bought it on Wii, got bored of its unimaginative level designs and its general tedium and returned it. Seems like it was made purely for kids.