The question of which game will be Game of the Year for 2013 on Gamespot is particularly exciting this year since Gamespot hasn't actually given us their final nominations and runners up for the overall category yet. What they have given us is lots of tangential hints, such as platform specific winners, and the editors' top ten of the year.
Because I have way too much time on my hands after finishing my finals yesterday, I decided to compile a leaderboard for how many times a game figures on an editor's top ten of the year list. Since we already know the platform specific winners, this should help us figure out which game will nail GotY this year.
- Grand Theft Auto V (360/PS3): 11
- The Legend of Zelda: A Link Between Worlds (3DS): 10
- The Last of Us (PS3): 9
- Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons (360): 7
- Path of Exile (PC): 7
- Bioshock Infinite (360/PS3/PC): 7
- The Stanley Parable (PC): 7
- Gone Home (PC): 7
- Super Mario 3D World (Wii U): 6
- Fire Emblem Awakening (3DS): 5
- Pokemon X/Y (3DS): 5
- Tomb Raider (360/PS3/PC): 5
- Rogue Legacy (PC): 4
- State of Decay (360): 4
- DOTA 2 (PC): 4
- Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag (360/PS3/Wii U/XONE/PS4/PC): 4
- Battlefield 4 (360/PS3/XONE/PS4/PC): 4
- Spelunky (PC/PSV): 4
- Beyond: Two Souls (PS3): 4
- Animal Crossing: New Leaf (3DS): 3
- Papers, Please (PC): 3
- Guacamelee! (PS3/PSV/PC): 3
- Tearaway (PSV): 3
- DmC: Devil May Cry (PS3/360/PC): 3
- Ni No Kuni: Wrath of the White Witch (PS3): 3
- Resogun (PS4): 2
- Forza Motorsport 5 (XONE): 2
- Luigi's Mansion Dark Moon (3DS): 2
- Depression Quest (PC): 2
- XCOM: Enemy Within (PC/360/PS3): 2
- Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell Blacklist (360/PS3/Wii U/PC): 2
- Rayman Legends (Wii U/360/PS3/PSV/PC): 2
- Payday 2 (PC/PS3/360): 2
- Metro: Last Light (PC/PS3/360): 2
- Outlast (PC): 2
- Diablo III (PS3): 1
- Strike Suit Infinity (PC): 1
- FIFA 14 (360/PS3/Wii/XONE/PS4/3DS/PSV/PC): 1
- Thomas Was Alone (PC/PS3/PSV): 1
- The Dream Machine (PC): 1
- The Last Door: Chapter One: The Letter (PC/iOS): 1
- Ridiculous Fishing: A Tale of Adventure (iOS): 1
- Gears of War Judgement (360): 1
- The Wolf Among Us (PC/360/PS3): 1
- The Swapper (PC): 1
- Sid Meier's Civilization V: Brave New World (PC): 1
- Reus (PC): 1
- Dead Rising 3 (XONE): 1
- Divekick (PS3/PSV): 1
- NBA 2K14 (360/PS3/XONE/PS4): 1
- Don't Starve (PC/PS4): 1
- Surgeon Simulator 2013 (PC): 1
- Kentucky Route Zero (PC): 1
- Device 6 (iOS): 1
- Defiance (360/PS3/PC): 1
- Receiver (PC): 1
- Killzone: Shadow Fall (PS4): 1
- EVE: Valkyrie (PC): 1
- Starcraft II: Heart of the Swarm (PC): 1
- Persona 4 Arena (PS3/360): 1
- Far Cry 3: Blood Dragon (360/PS3/PC): 1
- Antichamber (PC): 1
- Puppeteer (PS3): 1
- Bit.Trip Presents Runner 2 (PC/Wii U/PS3/360): 1
So, from this list, I deduce:
-> PC spanks everything else
-> In terms of dedicated platforms, 3DS dominated everything else
-> GTA 5 is a clear frontrunner for GotY
-> So is The Legend of Zelda: A Link Between Worlds. In fact, it is the highest placed exclusive on that list, and second overall
Oh, and by the way, re-releases and expansions won't count for GotY, so stuff like Spelunky, Diablo III, and so on, are all out of the running.
Log in to comment