The best fantasy WRPG of this gen!

Like the title says, which fantasy game has been your favorite so far?

Oblivion

Demon Souls

Dragon Age

Fighting Fantasy: The Warlock of Firetop Mountain looks like one of the best this generation.

Not a huge fan of Oblivion.

Demons Souls was fantastic.

Hardly even played Dragon Age (5 minutes of my friends game).

So Demons Souls.

The Witcher. Haven't played enough of Dragon Age to honestly rate it. I can say i was totally wrong about it looking lame as hell, because so far it's really really good, aside from the cliches. AAllxxjjnn

witcher is still my fav.

No Fable?Shafftehr

Eww?

[QUOTE="Shafftehr"]No Fable?treedoor

Eww?

No Witcher? Poll = epic fail. Also, why is Neverwinter Nights 2 not up there? That game is better than all three of those others up there. And one of them isn't even a WRPG!

Dragon Age

Out of the poll options Dragon Age without a doubt. Including everything it's a toss up between The Witcher and Dragon Age, but since I haven't finished DA I can't give an answer yet. Both are fantastic in different ways.

I haven't played Demon's Souls or Dragon Age... but Oblivion with Oscuro's Oblivion Overhaul and the Shivering Isles expansion is quite fantastic.

Uncharted 2, obviously.

Dragon Age by a mile.Espada12

The Witcher

Dragon age, Hands down, until Mass Effect 2 comes out in january. either way, bioware is king of the hill.

between Oblivion and Dragon age, prob oblivion for me tho, for the exac reason listed in that poll too :P

No Fable?Shafftehr

Eww?

[QUOTE="Shafftehr"]No Fable?treedoor

Eww?

[QUOTE="hiphops_savior"][QUOTE="treedoor"]

Eww?

MJ4040

Besides, "JRPG" is the term WRPG is opposed to, and that's "Japense RPG" - obviously meant to be tied to Japan. Why wouldn't western RPGs be similarly tied to the west?

I haven't played Dragon Age yet, but from the looks of it, it doesn't really compare the other two. I chose Oblivion. I own both Oblivion and Demon's Souls. I'll be purchasing Dragon Age next friday most likely.

The Witcher, Fallout 3, and Fable 2

Etrian Odyssey 2 is the best fantasy WRPG this gen.

Demon's Soul isn't even a WRPG, this list fails epically.hiphops_savior

Yes it is.

Neverwinter Nights 2 actually.

But I haven't played DAO yet, or Risen, I expect those to be high.

[QUOTE="treedoor"]

[QUOTE="Shafftehr"]No Fable?hiphops_savior

Eww?

Don't you understand that the genre of a game is not effect at all by where a game is actually developed?

You screwed up big time in the poll. Have you ever heard of The Witcher?

I guarantee you, most people who played it would choose The Witcher.

Lame post, you put Oblivion which is hardly a RPG, same with Demon's Souls, yet you neglected The Witcher...Anyway, even though I didn't play Dragon Age, my vote goes to The Witcher and I'm very doubtful if Dragon Age could even match it, let alone surpass it.Salt_The_Fries

DA:O is on the same level as the Witcher IMO, but in a different way...

Oblivion. Its still one of my favourite games this gen

Dragon age, I just completed it, very awesome game.

1. Dragon Age: Origins (PC - 2009)

2. The Witcher (2007)

3. Ultima V: Lazarus (Ultima V: Warriors of Destiny Remake/Dungeon Siege Mod - 2006)

4. Drakensang: The Dark Eye (2009)

5. Risen (PC - 2009)

Didn't like Oblivion, so that's out.

I've only played a small bit of Demon's Souls and Dragon Age: Origins, but so far I'll give the advantage to DA:O. The fighting system is more to my liking. I really can't make a true decision until I play through both though.

Mask of the Betrayer.