Should gamespot score Titanfall down for poor graphics?

(Can't make poll in official thread)

From the current visuals shown, Titanfalls visuals are... questionable.

Whenever I read comments on gaming forums regarding the source engine (Titanfall runs on it) I see the comments "oh it's so outdated, valve engine sucks" e.t.c.... (which I don't agree with btw)

So, when the title is released and assuming the visuals do not remain up to scratch (and it is shaping up that way) should Titanfall be called out on it?

For comparison, this is a high res Titanfall screenshot from eurogamer.

Click me

And this is a screenshot from Black Mesa, running on an old version of source.

Vote please. Thank you.