Most Overrated? Most Underrated?

Most overrated: Halo 3, Mass Effect, GTAIV, Resistance: FOM

Most underrated: Ratchet and Clank Future: Quest for Booty, Monster Hunter Freedom 2

Most overrated: MGS4

Most underrated: Fable 2, Lost Odyssey, Siren: Blood Curse, Mass Effect, Silent Hill: Homecoming, Spore

most overrated: thps3

most underrated: mario kart 64

Most Overrated: Any AAA+ game

Most Underrated: Any game which was not a AAA game

Overrated: Oblivion

Underrated: Dead Rising

Overrated: Oblivion

Underrated: Dead Rising

Jodan77

Overrated: Oblivion

Underrated: Oblivion with Mods.

lol, i mean that but seriously i'll do another, and im saying by other gamers, not what reviews say.

Overrated: MGS4 without a doubt.

Underrated: All Total War games.

Most Overrated: GTA IV , MGS4, obivion

Most Underrated: mass effect , fable 2, kameo

Over: Tetris

Under: Dr. Mario

Most Overrated: Any AAA+ game

Most Underrated: Any game which was not a AAA game

HarlockJC

Overrated: MGS4, Oblivion

Underrated: Fire Emblem

Going by forumite opinions, not actual ratings.

Overrated: Call of Duty 4's Multiplayer, Resident Evil 4 and MGS3

Underrated: Kameo and Halo 3

Halo 3 gets hated on only because it's Halo and because it has kids on it, two extremely stupid reasons, especially the latter. How can you say a game is bad because of its community? That's like saying Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time is garbage because CliffyB and Soulja Boy played it.

Overrated: Halo 3, Oblivion, Gears of War, GTA4, Super Mario Galaxy, Ninja Gaiden

Underrated: Uncharted, Ratchet & Clank: ToD, Motorstor, Warioland: Shake it!

Overrated: GTAIV, Zelda Phantom Hourglass

Underrated: Mass Effect, Fable II (going by what reviewers say), Mario Sunshine, Fire Emblem Radiance Dawn

Most Overrated: Too Human, GeoW, Mario Galaxy, Gran Turismo

Most underrated: Siren

Overrated - All Halo titles, Newer R6Vegas titles (coming from an original Rainbow Six PC player), GTAIV, and Resistance (can't thnk of any others atm).

Underrated - The Witcher, Hellgate London (Enjoyed this game alot), Stalker, Spore, and MoH: Airborne.

Overrated: GTA IV, Call of Duty 4

Underrated: Star Wars: The Force Unleashed, Ratchet and Clank: ToD, Uncharted, Assassin's Creed.

Overrated - Halo 3, Gears of War, Super Mario Galaxy, GTA IV.

Underrated - Persona 3 (Soon Persona 4), Lost Odyssey, Yakuza 1 + 2.

Underrated: Uncharted

Overrated : Gears 1, Oblivion, CoD 4, Bioshock, Assasin's Creed, Mass Effect

Underrated : NWN 2: MotB , HoMM V : ToE

overrated- World of Warcraft

underrated- Halo 3

Most overrated: MGS4 and Burnout Paradise

Most underrated: Mass Effect and PGR4

Overrated- Gears of War 1, GTA 4, Far Cry 2.

Underrated- Ratchet & Clank, Crackdown, Uncharted, Lost Odyssey, Warhawk.

Overrated: COD4, GTAIV, Oblivion

Underrated: R&C: TOD, Uncharted, Siren: Blood Curse

Most Overrated: Tom Clacny Series and Halo 3

Most Underatted: Mass Effect and Disgea Series

Overatted- MGS4, GTA4 andCOD4's MP

overrated: every game that got a high score

underrated: every game that got a low score 

most overrated-GTA IV, brawl, halo 3

just right-MGS4, GeOW, SMG, crysis

most underrated-RB2, GeOW2, warhawk, GTA SA(needs 10.0)

Overrated - SSBM, Super Mario Galaxy, Metroid Prime, Gta4, World of Warcraft, Spore, Sims, Link tp

Just right - MGS4, Crysis, Gears of war, god of war, mass effect, dead space,

Underrated - Shenmue 1,2, Mgs2, Chris Barker's Jericho, zone of the enders 2, Onimusha series, Devil may cry series, ff8

Console wise

Overrated - wii
Just right - 360
Underrated - ps3
and pc alternates

Overrated: Gears, Halo, Oblivion, Mass Effect, MGS4, Gta4, Brawl,Twilight Princess

Underrated: Okami,  Paper Mario 2, Diddy Kong Racing DS, Phoenix Wright, Custom Robo Arena

Favorite Games this Gen:

Wii- Super Mario Galaxy
360- Nhl 09
Ps3- Uncharted