Microsoft has more 9.5 rated games than Sony

Microsoft:

Gears of War - 9.6

Halo 3 - 9.5

Forza 3 - 9.5

Halo Reach - 9.5

Sony:

Uncharted 2 - 9.5

Sony has more AAAA games than microsoft

Not sure where this is going, PC has no AAAA this generation and still better than both

Sony sells more than everyone when you combine ps2, ps3, and psp. See I can do it too.

1. Is this like a list of exclusives or something? Cause if it isn't, you are missing quite a bit. If it is, then MS only has 3 games that are 9.5.

2. What was the point of this thread?

Sony has more AAAA games than microsoftDiviniuz

Yup.

Arbitrary limitations are fun TC!

Sony has more AAAA games than microsoftDiviniuz

ehhh 1 game thats .5 more

Sony has more AAAA games than microsoft

Diviniuz

[QUOTE="Diviniuz"]Sony has more AAAA games than microsoftlundy86_4

Yup.

Arbitrary limitations are fun TC!

[QUOTE="Diviniuz"]Sony has more AAAA games than microsoftjohnnyblazed88

ehhh 1 game thats .5 more

ehhh numerous games that are .5 less... Arbitrary limitations by the TC don't mean too much.

[QUOTE="Diviniuz"]Sony has more AAAA games than microsoftlundy86_4

Yup.

Arbitrary limitations are fun TC!

[QUOTE="lundy86_4"]

[QUOTE="Diviniuz"]Sony has more AAAA games than microsoftspacesheikh

Yup.

Arbitrary limitations are fun TC!

Nope, those categories are set out by GS and is a system ingrained into System Wars. You just further limited it for no point that I can see :?

Why not just stick with AAA? Or does that not serve the same purpose as they're fairly even? Why not limit it to AAAA?

Sony is leading in AAAA games.UpJTBoogie

[QUOTE="lundy86_4"]

[QUOTE="Diviniuz"]Sony has more AAAA games than microsoftDiviniuz

Yup.

Arbitrary limitations are fun TC!

Completely agree. Just go off total counts for exclusives and be done with it, because at the end of the yda, who cares? They're so close it's just boring :P

[QUOTE="UpJTBoogie"]Sony is leading in AAAA games.spacesheikh

And this is me not caring about minuscule game scores. :|

[QUOTE="spacesheikh"][QUOTE="UpJTBoogie"]Sony is leading in AAAA games.siLVURcross

Microsoft:

Gears of War - 9.6

Halo 3 - 9.5

Forza 3 - 9.5

Halo Reach - 9.5

Sony:

Uncharted 2 - 9.5

spacesheikh

[QUOTE="Diviniuz"][QUOTE="lundy86_4"]

Yup.

Arbitrary limitations are fun TC!

lundy86_4

Completely agree. Just go off total counts for exclusives and be done with it, because at the end of the yda, who cares? They're so close it's just boring :P

And 3 of those are highly overrated.kuraimen

Not that I agree with the TC's limitations, but the matter of a game being overrated is simply on a person by person basis. You feel they are, many obviously don't.

[QUOTE="spacesheikh"]

Microsoft:

Gears of War - 9.6

Halo 3 - 9.5

Forza 3 - 9.5

Halo Reach - 9.5

Sony:

Uncharted 2 - 9.5

kuraimen

PS3 has more Demon's Souls than 360.Nerd_Man

its almost like both consoles have an amazing library of games and neither is terrible, but that can't be true! everyone in system wars tells me other wise!Diviniuz

Well I guess if it wasn't this way, then System Wars would be General Games Discussion 2... A whole lot of boring :P

Still, some posters over do it, hence this thread.

Your debate is based on scores by GS only. The same site that gave HV a 8.5, which should have gotten around 9.0-9.5.

So GTA4 is better than RDR? I can't see the difference to be honest.spacesheikh

[QUOTE="Diviniuz"]Sony has more AAAA games than microsoftlundy86_4

Yup.

Arbitrary limitations are fun TC!

Though it's not really thread worthy TBH.

what is the point of this thread? tc u got owned pretty hard and fast.lol try harder next time

[QUOTE="kuraimen"]And 3 of those are highly overrated.lundy86_4

Not that I agree with the TC's limitations, but the matter of a game being overrated is simply on a person by person basis. You feel they are, many obviously don't.

[QUOTE="lundy86_4"]

[QUOTE="Diviniuz"]Sony has more AAAA games than microsoftblackace

Yup.

Arbitrary limitations are fun TC!

So 2 is more than 1. The point was that both limitations were nonsensical and pointless.

GS may make some mistakes on reviews IYO, but regardless, those are the review scores they both received.

[QUOTE="lundy86_4"]

[QUOTE="kuraimen"]And 3 of those are highly overrated.spacesheikh

Not that I agree with the TC's limitations, but the matter of a game being overrated is simply on a person by person basis. You feel they are, many obviously don't.

It works on a thread by thread basis, yet I saw no reason as for your limitation. Limiting to exclusives makes sense, as they are not available for the other systems (and PC/360 and/or PC/PS3 games can be brought up in most cases).

[QUOTE="blackace"][QUOTE="lundy86_4"]

Yup.

Arbitrary limitations are fun TC!

lundy86_4

So 2 is more than 1. The point was that both limitations were nonsensical and pointless.

GS may make some mistakes on reviews IYO, but regardless, those are the review scores they both received.

[QUOTE="lundy86_4"]

[QUOTE="kuraimen"]And 3 of those are highly overrated.spacesheikh

Not that I agree with the TC's limitations, but the matter of a game being overrated is simply on a person by person basis. You feel they are, many obviously don't.

That is not an arbitrary exclusion considering the PC is also a platform. It seems more that you are on the making up arbitrary exclusions by leaving out the PC.

Welcome to System Wars, where we make arbitrary exclusions. If you haven't noticed, we don't compare libraries on system wars, we compare scores.spacesheikh

Certain exclusions make sense, I haven't seen you make sense or explain your reasoning yet. Why not stick to AAA which is a category as set forth by GS?

[QUOTE="spacesheikh"]Welcome to System Wars, where we make arbitrary exclusions. If you haven't noticed, we don't compare libraries on system wars, we compare scores.lundy86_4

Certain exclusions make sense, I haven't seen you make sense or explain your reasoning yet. Why not stick to AAA which is a category as set forth by GS?

Don't try to change the mind of a delusional fanboy, no good can come forth of it.

[QUOTE="spacesheikh"]Welcome to System Wars, where we make arbitrary exclusions. If you haven't noticed, we don't compare libraries on system wars, we compare scores.lundy86_4

Certain exclusions make sense, I haven't seen you make sense or explain your reasoning yet. Why not stick to AAA which is a category as set forth by GS?

Give me the reason Gamespot grouped together AAA, AA..etc.

[spoiler] It's all arbitrary [/spoiler]

Give me the reason Gamespot grouped together AAA, AA..etc.

It's all arbitrary

spacesheikh

That arbitrary limitation has become a standard. It's not really arbitrary when it was a rule set forth to be used by the posters here.

So why not answer the question that I just asked you? Why not just use AAA?

Thats nice.

That's cause Sony has more 10's :)

Microsoft:

Gears of War - 9.6

Halo 3 - 9.5

Forza 3 - 9.5

Halo Reach - 9.5

Sony:

Uncharted 2 - 9.5

spacesheikh