[QUOTE="1080pOnly"][QUOTE="Cranler"]
I recently played Halo 4 and the faces and objects werent blurry at all. You do realize that most use of 1080p tv's is non 1080p content right? I watch and play 720p content all the time and it look great, no blurrienss. TV scalers are VERY good.
You dont understand my question on Avatar, let me be more detailed. The general consensus here is that 720p isnt enough to render the all details of current gen games, if that was true then why do graphics that are WAY beyond games look great in sd?
Cranler
Why does Avatar, a movie shot and rendered by movie cameras with 3 x 2.2mp CCD's per camera (at 48fps) and then processed on a supercomputer, look better downscaled to SD than games running on a home computer at 1080p?
Why do TV programs filmed in 1080p, shown at native 1080p, carry so much more detail than those filmed at 720p and shown at 720p?
Even after I exlained my question you dont seem to undertsand. Peope say 720p isnt enough res to handle graphical evolution yet cgi looks great even below 720p. I understand it completely, it's you that have missed the point. Avatar was pre-rendered, games do not have that luxury. If you render at 540p then play it back on a 1080p screen it will look bad, no matter how good your upscaler is.
720p is fine when rendered at native 720p on screens that are built for it. HDTV's have reached a size/cost ratio where they need to render at 1080p as a minimum or they lose detail during the upscale. 720p content on a 1080p screen does not look anything like as good as 1080p content on the same screen, no matter how good the scaler technology gets.
Avatar looks bad on an SD set compared to an HDTV. I'm not arguing that graphics can't improve on where they are at 720p just that the same level of graphics rendered at 1080p always looks better.
*Edit* Basically, LOD and resolution go hand in hand. You can't completely seperate them and the next-gen leap in tech won't render photo-realism at 720p, it will just add a few small bells and whistles (and they are small). Better to render at 1080 using this gens LOD imo.
Log in to comment