In your honest opinion, who is the best video game reviewer?

Whose better to you, Greg Miller or Tom McShea? Or do you not care or do you like both?

(My fanboy versions call them God Miller and God McPerfect.

Tom McShea.

He pisses off a lot of people.Cool dude.

Myself.

Cl4ssic game room. No scores = win.

Chuck Norrisdracolich55

Yep and he'll roundhouse kick both Gamespot and IGN literally.

EDGE.

Myself.

vtoshkatur

Tom McShea.

He pisses off a lot of people.Cool dude.

freedomfreak

So are you going to call him God McPerfect?

Michael Lowell, Stephen Bray.

I'm surprised that no one voted Greg Miller. I thought cows would vote for him because he gave Uncharted 3 a perfect 10. I guess no one likes fanboy reviewers.

[QUOTE="freedomfreak"]

Tom McShea.

He pisses off a lot of people.Cool dude.

sonic1564

So are you going to call him God McPerfect?

Metacritic. An aggregate of opinions is the only way to approximate the objective quality of a game.DarthBilf

The worst kind of reviewers are those who claim/aim to be unbiased. You belong in a new category of stupid.

[spoiler] I do hope you are kidding [/spoiler]

[QUOTE="DarthBilf"]Metacritic. An aggregate of opinions is the only way to approximate the objective quality of a game.Socijalisticka

The worst kind of reviewers are those who claim/aim to be unbiased. You belong in a new category of stupid.

I just explained Greg Miller. He is a fanboy in denial.

For me the best reviewer is myself. For you. it should be yourself and ad narcotics.Vortexshadowray

It is, but I want to know who is the better reviewer since fanboys care for it to defend their "exclusives" (those don't even exist to us manticores).

honestly, i tend to agree with most game informer reviewsmems_1224

I do too as well as mine and my dogs...and Hermione's (don't ask).

Whover calls CoD as a pile of regurgitated crap.

He doesn't review many games, but Angry Joe's reviews have been the most accurate in my opinion.

He doesn't review many games, but Angry Joe's reviews have been the most accurate in my opinion.

Tezcatlipoca666

Which one?

Cl4ssic game room. No scores = win.

LordQuorthon

His reviews are more for the sake of entertainment though, I don't find them to be that informative and neutral. They are still great and his opinions are respectable.

Kevin VanOrd. He's a great reviewer.

[QUOTE="Tezcatlipoca666"]

He doesn't review many games, but Angry Joe's reviews have been the most accurate in my opinion.

sonic1564

Which one?

Basically.. neither. I was referring to some other guy.

Alex NavarroOreoMilkshake

Myself.

I also like the guy from classic game room, whatever his name is.

Mark from Classic Game Room. No scores or any BS, just tells you if the game is fun or not.

Morgan Webb

Morgan Webb

AussieePet

Not sure if serious

Myself.

In terms of GameSpot reviewers. Greg Kasavin.

In terms of IGN reviewers. That Charles...guy...thing...person...whatever.

Myself.

In terms of GameSpot reviewers. Greg Kasavin.

In terms of IGN reviewers. That Charles...guy...thing...person...whatever.

Goyoshi12

Don't like IGNorant do ya?

[QUOTE="Goyoshi12"]

Myself.

In terms of GameSpot reviewers. Greg Kasavin.

In terms of IGN reviewers. That Charles...guy...thing...person...whatever.

sonic1564

Don't like IGNorant do ya?

Meh...they're OK. They do better articles than reviews, tbh. Except for when there is passion behind the reviews. That is ALWAYS an etnertaining read. :P

Myself.

vtoshkatur

This. There is no reviewer that I believe critiques a game in a way that best reflects my thoughts than myself.

Vinny at giantbomb.

It's a shame he hardly ever writes actual reviews, have to get his opinions from the bombcasts.

I'm the best reviewer because the only review I can trust 100% is that of my own opinion.

These two guys were the best reviewers out of any reviewers PERIOD!!! Victor Lucas and Tommy Tallarico

and

This was the epic review show that they hosted. Judgment Day on G4 (Back when G4 was respectable and actually worthy of watching)

Me. Because in the end, it is I that decides what games I like and don't like.

The gaintbomb crew

Tom McShea and the people at GiantBomb,

That 7.5 on SS was spot-on, really showed Tom as a reviewer that doesn't live up to the hype.