If Madden 2008...

APF 2K8 is just 2K5 with legends and no depth, sadly. I would get Madden just because I prefer the NFL over College Football.

APF 2K8 is just 2K5 with legends and no depth, sadly. I would get Madden just because I prefer the NFL over College Football.

goodlay

Same here... Besides I've yet to buy a "next gen" Madden so if this one fixes the problems of 06 and 07 I'm good.

Madden is usually better than NCAA.

As far as NCAA VS APF, GS is impressed more with the extra features than the actual gameplay. Me personally I think Madden 06 for the PS2 is the best football game I've played. But the EA games released on the next-gens' gameplay sucks. It got abit better this year, but it still sucks.

So I don't plan on buying the Madden 08 for the PS3. Ill but the PS2 version. Thank God for the fall-back playability.

I'll never buy another Madden football again.When I saw 2k selling a better football game for 20 bucks, that let me know EA was only in it for the money.

Based on what alot of gaming site said about madden 08 it will be the best football game.EPaul

Yea, but they also hyped hell out of NCAA08, n it didn't turn out that much better.

I never liked football games because I don't like Football. So because I don't understand the plays I never wanted to play any. But there is part of thenew WiiMadden that makes it where you do not need to know the plays, I may end getting it because of that.HarlockJC

You know, you just sounded like a true casual gamer?

I never liked football games because I don't like Football. So because I don't understand the plays I never wanted to play any. But there is part of thenew WiiMadden that makes it where you do not need to know the plays, I may end getting it because of that.HarlockJC

How is that even possible? You HAVE to know the plays in order to play football.

[QUOTE="HarlockJC"]I never liked football games because I don't like Football. So because I don't understand the plays I never wanted to play any. But there is part of thenew WiiMadden that makes it where you do not need to know the plays, I may end getting it because of that.GKinnel

How is that even possible? You HAVE to know the plays in order to play football.

It's because it's on the wii... next question.

I already got ncaa and all pro.

and will be getting madden thanks to a revamped superstar mode and franchise mode.

and owner mode.....

and the weapons thing.

Madden is usually better than NCAA.

As far as NCAA VS APF, GS is impressed more with the extra features than the actual gameplay. Me personally I think Madden 06 for the PS2 is the best football game I've played. But the EA games released on the next-gens' gameplay sucks. It got abit better this year, but it still sucks.

So I don't plan on buying the Madden 08 for the PS3. Ill but the PS2 version. Thank God for the fall-back playability.

GKinnel

I think Madden 2004 was the best of the madden bunch...... or at least madden 2002-2004....

as far as best football game ever.....one of the best if not the best was Gameday 98(psone).......for me at least

But what if Madden for the Wii scores highest....again?

I would be thrilled.

But what if Madden for the Wii scores highest....again?

I would be thrilled.

gromit007

it wont

the graphics look horrible and family mode is a gimick.

I fogot who said this but on Madden 08' some guy here said "Why don't we just call it Roster Update 08'?" I laughed because it was too true. I don't buy football games anymore. DA_B0MB

[QUOTE="gromit007"]

But what if Madden for the Wii scores highest....again?

I would be thrilled.

ginglejangle

it wont

the graphics look horrible and family mode is a gimick.

Gameplay>>>>>>>>>>graphics in sports games.

Family mode is quite innovative. Maybe you should read on it before bashing it.

[QUOTE="HarlockJC"]I never liked football games because I don't like Football. So because I don't understand the plays I never wanted to play any. But there is part of thenew WiiMadden that makes it where you do not need to know the plays, I may end getting it because of that.IbukiNinja

You know, you just sounded like a true casual gamer?

Maybe I own all 4 last gen systems. But have never bought a madden game.

[QUOTE="ginglejangle"][QUOTE="gromit007"]

But what if Madden for the Wii scores highest....again?

I would be thrilled.

gromit007

it wont

the graphics look horrible and family mode is a gimick.

Gameplay>>>>>>>>>>graphics in sports games.

Family mode is quite innovative. Maybe you should read on it before bashing it.

yea ive read evry info of evry madden version and will be getting it on my ps3.

the wii will have the worst madden.

[QUOTE="HarlockJC"]I never liked football games because I don't like Football. So because I don't understand the plays I never wanted to play any. But there is part of thenew WiiMadden that makes it where you do not need to know the plays, I may end getting it because of that.GKinnel

How is that even possible? You HAVE to know the plays in order to play football.

They are making a family verison that makes it a lot easier to understand what going on. I use to enjoy football games on the NES where is was throw the ball and avoid the guy comming towards you. But now when I play a football game, I keep hitting the button that gets me to playing guickly rather than pick from the plays.

[QUOTE="gromit007"][QUOTE="ginglejangle"][QUOTE="gromit007"]

But what if Madden for the Wii scores highest....again?

I would be thrilled.

ginglejangle

it wont

the graphics look horrible and family mode is a gimick.

Gameplay>>>>>>>>>>graphics in sports games.

Family mode is quite innovative. Maybe you should read on it before bashing it.

yea ive read evry info of evry madden version and will be getting it on my ps3.

the wii will have the worst madden.

What makes the '08 Maddens different from the '07s when the Wii version was best? If you say graphics, you lose all credibility.

[QUOTE="gromit007"]

But what if Madden for the Wii scores highest....again?

I would be thrilled.

ginglejangle

it wont

the graphics look horrible and family mode is a gimick.

The family mode is why I may buy the Wii verison. So even if it is a gimmick there is nothing wrong with that. Most gimmicks are great.

[QUOTE="HarlockJC"]I never liked football games because I don't like Football. So because I don't understand the plays I never wanted to play any. But there is part of thenew WiiMadden that makes it where you do not need to know the plays, I may end getting it because of that.IbukiNinja

You know, you just sounded like a true casual gamer?

There's nothing wrong with that, and maybe he doesn't really like football.

[QUOTE="ginglejangle"][QUOTE="gromit007"]

But what if Madden for the Wii scores highest....again?

I would be thrilled.

gromit007

it wont

the graphics look horrible and family mode is a gimick.

Gameplay>>>>>>>>>>graphics in sports games.

Family mode is quite innovative. Maybe you should read on it before bashing it.

[QUOTE="GKinnel"]

[QUOTE="HarlockJC"]I never liked football games because I don't like Football. So because I don't understand the plays I never wanted to play any. But there is part of thenew WiiMadden that makes it where you do not need to know the plays, I may end getting it because of that.HarlockJC

How is that even possible? You HAVE to know the plays in order to play football.

They are making a family verison that makes it a lot easier to understand what going on. I use to enjoy football games on the NES where is was throw the ball and avoid the guy comming towards you. But now when I play a football game, I keep hitting the button that gets me to playing guickly rather than pick from the plays.

You still hafta know the plays. And back in the day, you had to know the plays.

And since the Wii's doin' that, they're definately tryin 'to get this casual thing down pact. Madden has always had a Football 101 thing on the current-gens. It shows you the plays, breaks down whats going on, ect. Then lets you try it out.

[QUOTE="HarlockJC"][QUOTE="GKinnel"]

[QUOTE="HarlockJC"]I never liked football games because I don't like Football. So because I don't understand the plays I never wanted to play any. But there is part of thenew WiiMadden that makes it where you do not need to know the plays, I may end getting it because of that.GKinnel

How is that even possible? You HAVE to know the plays in order to play football.

They are making a family verison that makes it a lot easier to understand what going on. I use to enjoy football games on the NES where is was throw the ball and avoid the guy comming towards you. But now when I play a football game, I keep hitting the button that gets me to playing guickly rather than pick from the plays.

You still hafta know the plays. And back in the day, you had to know the plays.

And since the Wii's doin' that, they're definately tryin 'to get this casual thing down pact. Madden has always had a Football 101 thing on the current-gens. It shows you the plays, breaks down whats going on, ect. Then lets you try it out.

I know they had some kind of training mode but because I never cared about football I never wanted to learn. But I have been enjoying the number of minigames on the Wii with my family. I still may not even pick up Madden for the Wii. But I have to say the fact that there is going to be a faimly mode sounds like I may have fun playing Madden with my family. I am going to wait untill I hear more about the family mode before I pick it up if I do.

I just really like the idea that EA is opening up more to other gamers.

[QUOTE="IbukiNinja"]

[QUOTE="HarlockJC"]I never liked football games because I don't like Football. So because I don't understand the plays I never wanted to play any. But there is part of thenew WiiMadden that makes it where you do not need to know the plays, I may end getting it because of that.HarlockJC

You know, you just sounded like a true casual gamer?

Maybe I own all 4 last gen systems. But have never bought a madden game.

What does you owning all systems has to do with it? When it comes to football games, you are a casual.

[QUOTE="GKinnel"]

[QUOTE="HarlockJC"]I never liked football games because I don't like Football. So because I don't understand the plays I never wanted to play any. But there is part of thenew WiiMadden that makes it where you do not need to know the plays, I may end getting it because of that.HarlockJC

How is that even possible? You HAVE to know the plays in order to play football.

They are making a family verison that makes it a lot easier to understand what going on. I use to enjoy football games on the NES where is was throw the ball and avoid the guy comming towards you. But now when I play a football game, I keep hitting the button that gets me to playing guickly rather than pick from the plays.

Ah yes, family mode. In otherwords, it's dumbing downthe gamefor people who are unwilling to learn the game.

[QUOTE="HarlockJC"][QUOTE="GKinnel"]

[QUOTE="HarlockJC"]I never liked football games because I don't like Football. So because I don't understand the plays I never wanted to play any. But there is part of thenew WiiMadden that makes it where you do not need to know the plays, I may end getting it because of that.IbukiNinja

How is that even possible? You HAVE to know the plays in order to play football.

They are making a family verison that makes it a lot easier to understand what going on. I use to enjoy football games on the NES where is was throw the ball and avoid the guy comming towards you. But now when I play a football game, I keep hitting the button that gets me to playing guickly rather than pick from the plays.

Ah yes, family mode. In otherwords, it's dumbing downthe gamefor people who are unwilling to learn the game.

If that what you want to call it does not bother me any. Yes I am unwilling to spend the time to learn the game, I just want to play a simple football game with my family. Am I asking to much?

[QUOTE="HarlockJC"][QUOTE="IbukiNinja"]

[QUOTE="HarlockJC"]I never liked football games because I don't like Football. So because I don't understand the plays I never wanted to play any. But there is part of thenew WiiMadden that makes it where you do not need to know the plays, I may end getting it because of that.IbukiNinja

You know, you just sounded like a true casual gamer?

Maybe I own all 4 last gen systems. But have never bought a madden game.

What does you owning all systems has to do with it? When it comes to football games, you are a casual.

You did not say casual football player..Then I would disagree with you has it stands I am not a football game player at all. Madden for the Wii "may" turn me into a casual football player.

[QUOTE="HarlockJC"][QUOTE="GKinnel"]

[QUOTE="HarlockJC"]I never liked football games because I don't like Football. So because I don't understand the plays I never wanted to play any. But there is part of thenew WiiMadden that makes it where you do not need to know the plays, I may end getting it because of that.IbukiNinja

How is that even possible? You HAVE to know the plays in order to play football.

They are making a family verison that makes it a lot easier to understand what going on. I use to enjoy football games on the NES where is was throw the ball and avoid the guy comming towards you. But now when I play a football game, I keep hitting the button that gets me to playing guickly rather than pick from the plays.

Ah yes, family mode. In otherwords, it's dumbing downthe gamefor people who are unwilling to learn the game.

In other words, you are narrow-minded.

It makes it easier to play the game with your kids. Got any younger cousin, nieces, or nephews you would like to sit down and play with? I'm in my 30's and know my dad would love to sit down and play some Madden when he comes by if he doesnt have to learncomplex controls.

And besides, its all optional anyway. So many people seem to have forgotten that Wii Madden was the best last year.

In other words, you are narrow-minded.

It makes it easier to play the game with your kids. Got any younger cousin, nieces, or nephews you would like to sit down and play with? I'm in my 30's and know my dad would love to sit down and play some Madden when he comes by if he doesnt have to learncomplex controls.

And besides, its all optional anyway. So many people seem to have forgotten that Wii Madden was the best last year.

gromit007

It ok I understand a number of people are afraid by the change that the Wii may bring. Well others embrace it.

Either Madden or NCAA.