Halo series is declining

  • 166 results
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4

This topic is locked from further discussion.

#1 Posted by me2002 (1307 posts) -

Using Metacritic

Halo 1 - 97

Halo 2 - 95

Halo 3 - 94

Halo Reach - 91

Halo 4 -87

Halo - 5 ?????

#2 Posted by Meeeper282 (1602 posts) -

you can only get away with the same formula for so long

#3 Posted by ithilgore2006 (10482 posts) -

Oh no, an 87 on METACRITIC! Why, that's how I determine how much I enjoy games, and an 87 might as well be a zero!

#4 Posted by DJ-Lafleur (34159 posts) -

More like MEHtacritic.

Because meh, Who knows how many of the reviews for any of the games are legit. I could see each game getting more troll reviews or fanboy reviews than the last.

#5 Posted by TheShadowLord07 (22141 posts) -

well its not as big as it was last gen thats for sure. guess critics want to see some big changes to it.

#6 Posted by bobbetybob (19291 posts) -
I can't think of many highly rated series that haven't slowly gotten lower and lower ratings without having a serious mix up (i.e Resident Evil 4).
#7 Posted by Plagueless (2569 posts) -

well its not as big as it was last gen thats for sure. guess critics want to see some big changes to it.

TheShadowLord07
Yep, that moron at EGM who gave it a 7 said it should have had iron sights and big setpieces like Call of Duty.
#8 Posted by Tommyjeeb (75 posts) -
Halo 4 is sitting at 87 on metacritic because its a massive franchise, its simply a victim of fanboys, jealousy, and trollage. A victim of its own success you could say.
#9 Posted by khoofia_pika (13517 posts) -
This thread is bad, and you should feel bad.
#10 Posted by RR360DD (11992 posts) -
Halo 5 will score higher than 4 ;)
#11 Posted by Stinger78 (5826 posts) -
From what I've played so far of Halo 4, it's as fun as 1, better than 3, and better than 2. I have not played ODST or Reach, however. Metacritic is the "Wikipedia" of game score reliability. Play the games and decide for yourself if you enjoy them.
#12 Posted by me2002 (1307 posts) -
Halo 5 will score higher than 4 ;)RR360DD
can't imagine lower anyways
#13 Posted by Rocker6 (13358 posts) -

Nice argument you got there! :lol:

#14 Posted by TrueAmerican007 (700 posts) -
Halo 5 will score higher than 4 ;)RR360DD
Agreed.
#15 Posted by LittleMac19 (1638 posts) -

you can only get away with the same formula for so long

Meeeper282
After finishing Pokemon White 2, you're right.
#16 Posted by mems_1224 (47282 posts) -
a couple reviews on metacritic are really questionable.
#17 Posted by kuraimen (28078 posts) -
It has always been an overhyped but mediocre series. The only thing keeping it alive now is Doritos and Mountain Dew. It's even copying COD now.
#18 Posted by Another-World (810 posts) -
metacritic sucks, and so does halo
#19 Posted by caseypayne69 (5390 posts) -
I'll feed the troll. It's in a more saturated market. We the consumers have more options now which pull its score down I'm sure; however, it is still an amazing game and series.
#20 Posted by Zeviander (9503 posts) -
lol, aggregated scores If you understood how Metacritic works, you'd know exactly why it is "declining" in score. In 2001 there were far less review outlets, and a lot less of them were trying to be "critical". But I say again... lol, aggregated scores
#21 Posted by Fizzman (9882 posts) -

I remember when troll's were actually good at rustling jimmie's.

#22 Posted by platniumgamer (4087 posts) -

Metacritic is a joke.

#23 Posted by kozzy1234 (35266 posts) -

Nope, reviews I could care less about.

Halo 4 >> Halo 3 and Halo ODST without a doubt

#24 Posted by PAL360 (26939 posts) -

Not to me, Halo 4 is my favourite Halo game since CE. Also a 8.7 is pretty good, especially considerig it got a few troll scores....like a 2.0? :o

#25 Posted by Another-World (810 posts) -

Nope, reviews I could care less about.

Halo 4 >> Halo 3 and Halo ODST without a doubt

kozzy1234

couldn't

[spoiler] sorry, couldn't resist.:D [/spoiler]

#26 Posted by dommeus (9377 posts) -
a couple reviews on metacritic are really questionable.mems_1224
Quarter to Three(?!) gave it 2/10, lol. I haven't played it, but 2/10 is pretty hilariously low considering the average.
#27 Posted by mems_1224 (47282 posts) -
[QUOTE="mems_1224"]a couple reviews on metacritic are really questionable.dommeus
Quarter to Three(?!) gave it 2/10, lol. I haven't played it, but 2/10 is pretty hilariously low considering the average.

Yea, seems like a desperate attempt to just get views
#28 Posted by kuraimen (28078 posts) -
[QUOTE="mems_1224"]a couple reviews on metacritic are really questionable.dommeus
Quarter to Three(?!) gave it 2/10, lol. I haven't played it, but 2/10 is pretty hilariously low considering the average.

It gets canceled by several other reviews which overrate the game and give it 10/10. The beauty of Metacritic is that fanboy reviews from either side cancel each other.
#29 Posted by VendettaRed07 (14012 posts) -

if they didn't release ODST, Reach, a Halo CE: remake so close together inbetween Halo 3 and 4 it would have reviewed much better

#30 Posted by themajormayor (25854 posts) -
And the first Halo sucked
#31 Posted by CanYouDiglt (7487 posts) -
Halo 4 is my favorite Halo so whatever they are doing I hope they keep it up.
#32 Posted by Gue1 (10214 posts) -

the way I see it all the series are declining. FF is worse, Ninja Gaiden is worse, etc.

#33 Posted by TheDidact (3981 posts) -
Every series is "declining" if you go by MC. Look at Killzone, CoD, Uncharted, Resistance, LBP, Gears, Infamous, Final Fantasy, GT, Forza, Zelda, Mario. If you only buy games based on MC average you are missing out on 95% of good games.
#34 Posted by -RocBoys9489- (6273 posts) -
Still butthurt the game got a 9.0 here and the PS3 has no games this year?
#35 Posted by VideoCasuals (42 posts) -
Halo 4 is my favorite Halo so whatever they are doing I hope they keep it up.CanYouDiglt
masterchief cant even change his own ringtone and get's pulled along a rail at the f8ckin haunted mansion ride at disneyland.
#36 Posted by RoslindaleOne (7566 posts) -
Yeah, it's declining in metacritic but I don't let it effect my enjoyment I get from the games.
Halo 4 is my favorite Halo so whatever they are doing I hope they keep it up.CanYouDiglt
Same here.
#37 Posted by TheDidact (3981 posts) -
It has always been an overhyped but mediocre series. The only thing keeping it alive now is Doritos and Mountain Dew. It's even copying COD now.kuraimen
The sad thing is, Halo 4 added the same exact things Uncharted 3 did (Sprint button, Loadouts, Perks, Kickbacks/Ordinance). So does that mean Uncharted 3 is copying CoD? I doubt you've ever even played it. :lol:
#38 Posted by VideoCasuals (42 posts) -
Best part ''rejoice halo fans your stale pretentious franchise of 12 years olds has had just enough embalming fluid injected to keep it riding high on stagnant opposed to dead''.
#39 Posted by TheEpicGoat (2006 posts) -

Lol Tom no Chicks gave it a 1/5 and he didn't even beat the game. Also, the same can be said about the God of War series.

#40 Posted by -RocBoys9489- (6273 posts) -
Still butthurt the game got a 9.0 here and the PS3 has no games this year?-RocBoys9489-
#41 Posted by idill23 (1100 posts) -
[QUOTE="CanYouDiglt"]Halo 4 is my favorite Halo so whatever they are doing I hope they keep it up.[/QUOTE I feel the same way.
#42 Posted by me2002 (1307 posts) -
[QUOTE="-RocBoys9489-"]Still butthurt the game got a 9.0 here and the PS3 has no games this year?-RocBoys9489-

If you like GS scores so much then Halo 4 = Resistance 2
#43 Posted by PS360Wii4eva (297 posts) -
Most games got low scores this year.
#44 Posted by -RocBoys9489- (6273 posts) -
[QUOTE="-RocBoys9489-"][QUOTE="-RocBoys9489-"]Still butthurt the game got a 9.0 here and the PS3 has no games this year?me2002

If you like GS scores so much then Halo 4 = Resistance 2

9.0 in 2012 standards>>>>9.0 in 2009 standards. I guess PDZ is also as good as both those games too, right?! Still butthurt?
#45 Posted by FireSpirit117 (1981 posts) -
Declining? Sh*t, most game franchises WISH they had scores like that over a decade. You people are spoiled.
#46 Posted by MBirdy88 (8330 posts) -
So is CoD then, and so is world of warcraft. about time. old games are old.... rehashed and boring.
#47 Posted by Mozelleple112 (6695 posts) -

Lol metacritc. Every Halo game is a AAA, except halo Wars which was a MASSIVE flop, and only a B game.

#48 Posted by Mozelleple112 (6695 posts) -
[QUOTE="me2002"][QUOTE="-RocBoys9489-"]-RocBoys9489-
If you like GS scores so much then Halo 4 = Resistance 2

9.0 in 2012 standards>>>>9.0 in 2009 standards. I guess PDZ is also as good as both those games too, right?! Still butthurt?

Just because you had 3 bad years in a row gives you no right to discredit Twisted Metal, Journey ( GOTY contender) Ratchet& Clank etc..
#49 Posted by vashkey (33750 posts) -
What happened to gamespot scores being the only one that matters around here? Regardless, even if Halo is declining it's doing it awfully slowly. It took ll years to get to an 87 and thats still a great score.
#50 Posted by MBirdy88 (8330 posts) -
[QUOTE="vashkey"]What happened to gamespot scores being the only one that matters around here? Regardless, even if Halo is declining it's doing it awfully slowly. It took ll years to get to an 87 and thats still a great score.

The trolls dominate this website now.