Halo 5 or Uncharted 4?

  • 100 results
  • 1
  • 2

This topic is locked from further discussion.

#-49 Posted by Lucianu (9443 posts) -

I think Halo 5 will sell more units. I also think Halo 10 will definitely sell more units in the 9th generation compared to Uncharted 7.

#-48 Posted by silversix_ (14790 posts) -
tired of both.
#-47 Posted by Thefatness16 (4672 posts) -

I've given up on the Halo frachise after 4.

#-46 Posted by cainetao11 (17707 posts) -
Can you define this "research" you did please? I don't personally, any halo fans that were let down by 4. I get it. Really, I do. You don't like the Xbox brand and want the Sony brand to always be on top. It's called being a fanboy, here. Let it go dude.
#-45 Posted by hippiesanta (9890 posts) -
Uncharted 4 .... make it a as a prequel for TLOU pre apocalyspe
#-44 Posted by TheDidact (3981 posts) -
Both of the previous entries in each franchise were well made but dissapointing. That being said, I spend a lot more time with Halo games and 343 can easily win me over as long as they do these things with the Halo 5 multiplayer: 1) Have a Beta 2) Seperated playlists based on Ranked and Social 3) Have skill based ranking systems in ranked 4) If Ordinance isn't going away, keep it in social. 5) Fix CTF 6) Bring back removed game modes and game types 7) Make more and better maps 8) Fix Customs 9) Have a working File Share 10) Manage playlists better
#-43 Posted by speedfog (3224 posts) -

Halo 5 would sell more. But to be honest I would buy UC4.

#-42 Posted by Newhopes (4582 posts) -

Halo 5 would probably out sell UC4 3/4 to 1.

#-41 Posted by onewiththegame (4248 posts) -
U2 is still one of the best games this gen but I enjoyed Halo4 more than U3 so it's a hard call for me
#-40 Posted by seanmcloughlin (38216 posts) -

I would say I want new stuff from both but we already know Halo 5 is happening and Uncharted 4 is most likely to happen. Which is a shame, I ould love to see ND branch away from that now, it's getting terribly stale. I'm glad they took up TLOU though.

#-39 Posted by jun_aka_pekto (16332 posts) -

[QUOTE="LittleMac19"]If you knew anything about ND and Playstation then you would obviously know that Uncharted is pretty much done and they're going to move on to something else after the PS4 launches, duh.SonyNintendoFan
There's no way they would retire uncharted.

ND should at least make one for the PS4. I'm curious to see UC4 on 1080p.

#-38 Posted by Nengo_Flow (9827 posts) -
Why do people think there will be an Uncharted 4? And why do they think it will be a launch tittle at that?
#-37 Posted by jun_aka_pekto (16332 posts) -

Why do people think there will be an Uncharted 4? And why do they think it will be a launch tittle at that?Nengo_Flow

Why not?

#-36 Posted by Joedgabe (5115 posts) -

I think ND would make a new game.. they usually only make games up to a Part 3. I'm hoping they make a Castlevania/metroid type game or maybe a more fantasy like game (:

#-35 Posted by Heirren (17321 posts) -
Both. More excited for Halo 5 because it brought new life and reinvigorated my interest in the series. If there is an Uncharted 4 coming I'm sure it will be mind blowingly good.
#-34 Posted by ebrezzy1 (1403 posts) -

Well lets go to the facts ...

Uncharted 2 sold better then Uncharted 3 meaning the fanbase didn't gravitate toward another Uncharted ... Uncharted launched on the Vita with naughty dog overseeing the project and failed to sell people on the Vita proving Uncharted is not a system seller ... as great as people wanna make naughty dog to be there games don't have longevity ... Uncharted 3 didn't have the same effect as Uncharted 2 and the recent Vita game didn't make people go run out the door for a vita ... there games loose appeal fast

Halo all the while is a system seller for the Xbox 360 console ... Halo 4 sold faster then any halo game yet proving fans still love the series and stamping 343 with approval that halo is in good hands ... its one of the top 3 or 4 games played on xbox live ... Halo 4 pretty much made Sony skip 2012 as they have nothing in there game arsenal to battle a halo

There is no question that Halo 5 will be the game everyone wants ... Sony games are fillers until the next halo comes out nothing more nothing less ............ cry more !

#-33 Posted by Heirren (17321 posts) -

Well lets go to the facts ...

Uncharted 2 sold better then Uncharted 3 meaning the fanbase didn't gravitate toward another Uncharted ... Uncharted launched on the Vita with naughty dog overseeing the project and failed to sell people on the Vita proving Uncharted is not a system seller ... as great as people wanna make naughty dog to be there games don't have longevity ... Uncharted 3 didn't have the same effect as Uncharted 2 and the recent Vita game didn't make people go run out the door for a vita ... there games loose appeal fast

Halo all the while is a system seller for the Xbox 360 console ... Halo 4 sold faster then any halo game yet proving fans still love the series and stamping 343 with approval that halo is in good hands ... its one of the top 3 or 4 games played on xbox live ... Halo 4 pretty much made Sony skip 2012 as they have nothing in there game arsenal to battle a halo

There is no question that Halo 5 will be the game everyone wants ... Sony games are fillers until the next halo comes out nothing more nothing less ............ cry more !

ebrezzy1
That is not completely true. There was next to no marketing for uncharted3 outside of the gamers venue. Uncharted 2 had a massive television push. Considering Uncharted is also one of the most sought after franchises for film, I can't completely agree with you.
#-32 Posted by CaseyWegner (70104 posts) -

After doing some research, i found out Halo 4 was a letdown to fans of the series.

SonyNintendoFan

like most sequels?

#-31 Posted by ebrezzy1 (1403 posts) -

[QUOTE="ebrezzy1"]

Well lets go to the facts ...

Uncharted 2 sold better then Uncharted 3 meaning the fanbase didn't gravitate toward another Uncharted ... Uncharted launched on the Vita with naughty dog overseeing the project and failed to sell people on the Vita proving Uncharted is not a system seller ... as great as people wanna make naughty dog to be there games don't have longevity ... Uncharted 3 didn't have the same effect as Uncharted 2 and the recent Vita game didn't make people go run out the door for a vita ... there games loose appeal fast

Halo all the while is a system seller for the Xbox 360 console ... Halo 4 sold faster then any halo game yet proving fans still love the series and stamping 343 with approval that halo is in good hands ... its one of the top 3 or 4 games played on xbox live ... Halo 4 pretty much made Sony skip 2012 as they have nothing in there game arsenal to battle a halo

There is no question that Halo 5 will be the game everyone wants ... Sony games are fillers until the next halo comes out nothing more nothing less ............ cry more !

Heirren

That is not completely true. There was next to no marketing for uncharted3 outside of the gamers venue. Uncharted 2 had a massive television push. Considering Uncharted is also one of the most sought after franchises for film, I can't completely agree with you.

The power of the marketing campaign was made up of four major elements: Announcing with authority, Sampling through the Public Beta, Road to launch, and critical acclaim. We put emphasis on a strong announcement of the game, as we know thats when you capture the interest of gaming evangelists. We leveraged the spotlight of the Spike Video Game Awards, where we unveiled our announce trailer, and boldly announced our street date of 11-1-11. We also held a press event to share first gameplay. The next big campaign beat was the Public Beta. Although a traditional tool used by development to kick the tires on multiplayer, we see the Public Beta as an important marketing tool to get the game in the hands of our core gaming community. We supported the Beta with a combination of digital advertising and retail point of purchase. We ended up with over 1.6 Million players far exceeding our expectations. The 6 weeks prior to launch was our next critical marketing beat, as this is when we start converting purchase intent to actual pre-orders. For the Uncharted 3 campaign, we used a combination of broadcast advertising, a multi-million dollar national campaign with Subway and traditional PR. The perfect storm of unveiling new exciting game content, sampling through Subway, and :30 spots on key NFL games, generated the excitement and retail pre-orders.

http://gamer.blorge.com/2011/10/16/uncharted-3-to-have-the-biggest-marketing-push-ever-by-sony-uk/

marketing was there ... the fanbase wasn't

#-30 Posted by mems_1224 (47249 posts) -
Halo 5, easily. Uncharted has run its course. After the craptacular UC3, I don't think they'll ever be able to top or match UC2. Halo has consistently put out great games though.
#-29 Posted by Puckhog04 (22606 posts) -

Halo 5 would sell much more than Uncharted. Uncharted is not the system seller that Halo is. Anyone denying this is delusional.

#-28 Posted by biggest_loser (24057 posts) -
I think UC should stay as a trilogy. It would be extremely difficulty to expand upon it without spoiling it. Is there something wrong with just leaving a beautiful thing? The pressure on ND by Sony must be enormous.
#-27 Posted by MercenaryMafia (2917 posts) -
Halo
#-26 Posted by caseypayne69 (5390 posts) -

ND will probably make a new IP series for PS4. They did crash bandicoot for PS1, Jak and Daxter for PS2, and uncharted for PS3.

SonySoldier-_-
Exactly. There won't be another Uncharted. At least by ND unless on the PS3.
#-25 Posted by lundy86_4 (43526 posts) -

Halo. That franchise is just ridicuously big.

#-24 Posted by DarkLink77 (31697 posts) -

Halo. That franchise is just ridicuously big.

lundy86_4

^This.

343 will have to seriously f*ck up Halo 5 to kill the brand's selling power. But they messed up Halo 4 pretty hard, so...

#-23 Posted by Yoshi9000 (396 posts) -

Halo 4 was dissapointing. Well made, but too similar, formula needs to change. I dont think any of these sequels would bring much excitement, they are games that are over staying their welcome in the game industry with too many sequels. I havent played uncharted, but I don't think a fourth would do any good.

#-22 Posted by Minishdriveby (10015 posts) -
Neither I'm kinda done with both franchises they should move on.
#-21 Posted by ShadowsDemon (10138 posts) -
Halo 5 for me. I'm done with Uncharted.
#-20 Posted by True_Chaos_UK (2570 posts) -

Viva Pinata 3 for me, followed by Halo and Uncharted respectively.

#-19 Posted by sukraj (23040 posts) -

Halo

#-18 Posted by DiceofSpades (98 posts) -

[QUOTE="SonySoldier-_-"]

ND will probably make a new IP series for PS4. They did crash bandicoot for PS1, Jak and Daxter for PS2, and uncharted for PS3.

RageQuitter69

Unkarted

I really hope Naughty Dog follows their old patternts with with Crash Bandicoot and Jak and Daxter.

There isn't really a pattern, ND had no control over Crash, Crash WAS going to leave no matter what, it was inevitable. There was a Jak game 7th gen as well, LF released after the 360 and PS3 came out on the PSP which was part of 7th gen.
#-17 Posted by Douevenlift_bro (5222 posts) -

Playstation 4. Oh wait what was the question?

#-16 Posted by Primordialous (1276 posts) -

Pretty sure Halo 5 would sell much more than Uncharted 4.

PhazonBlazer

#-15 Posted by DivineSword (15759 posts) -

If Naughty Dog continues it pattern with new IP every generation we won't be seeing Uncharted 4, though that is a BIG if.

#-14 Posted by vashkey (33750 posts) -
Halo, obviously
#-13 Posted by ItsEvolution (2593 posts) -

Halo would sell more, but it would be a crappy rush job, since Halo 4 just came out. Uncharted would have two years of development time.

#-12 Posted by tonitorsi (8481 posts) -

Halo will sell higher, Uncharted will score higher.

Same case applies with Forza and Gran Turismo.

#-11 Posted by -Karmum- (3774 posts) -
Neither, new IP please, please. Drop both of these series like a bad habit.
#-10 Posted by Heil68 (45145 posts) -
Uncharted 4 all the way, every day. Halo4 was my last Halo game.
#-9 Posted by StrongBlackVine (8418 posts) -

This is why im more PC gamer. Consoles just repeat the same games over and over again.

PCgameruk

How long has World of Warcraft dominated PC gaming?

#-8 Posted by DarkLink77 (31697 posts) -

[QUOTE="PCgameruk"]

This is why im more PC gamer. Consoles just repeat the same games over and over again.

StrongBlackVine

How long has World of Warcraft dominated PC gaming?

Define "dominate."
#-7 Posted by StrongBlackVine (8418 posts) -

Uncharted 4 all the way, every day. Halo4 was my last Halo game.Heil68

Halo sucks, but will sell more because of dumb Americans. Give me Uncharted 4, with co-op!

#-6 Posted by HaloPimp978 (7295 posts) -
I'm getting both so its a win win for me.
#-5 Posted by Lotus-Edge (50439 posts) -

There are few series that can match the level of hype Halo can reach with Microsoft's rather massive marketing might behind it....

#-4 Posted by AvengedSixfold (75 posts) -

Uncharted 4

#-3 Posted by StrongBlackVine (8418 posts) -

Halo and Call of Duty have ruined gaming to a certain extent.

#-2 Posted by nutcrackr (12632 posts) -
uncharted 4 if it's like uncharted 2
#-1 Posted by BadNewsBen (1493 posts) -
Halo would sell more consoles, I'm not sure there is any arguing that. Uncharted may be the better series, but I'm not sure how many consoles it actually sells.
#0 Posted by lloveLamp (2890 posts) -

ND will probably make a new IP series for PS4. They did crash bandicoot for PS1, Jak and Daxter for PS2, and uncharted for PS3.

SonySoldier-_-
nonono, uncharted will continue