Halo 4 vs Uncharted 3 (which is the console graphics king)

This topic is locked from further discussion.

#51 Posted by PSP107 (12131 posts) -

UC3 MP graphics are lacking. SP it beats Halo 4's SP, MP is a slight edge in Halo 4's favor, Split screen UC3 wins just for the sake that Halo 4's split screen is piss poor.uncharted-3-creepy-crawler-kickback.jpg

Maneil99
UC2 multiplayer is better looking than both. Dont know why they downgraded UC3's MP graphics.
#52 Posted by ispeakfactOwns (91 posts) -
Uncharted 3 no question. Halo 4 has some nice looking levels (like the ones in the OP) but it falls apart with terrible textures on many maps and it seems like they concentrated on a few levels to promote the game. U3 is just another level, like the waves dynamically crashing around drake mixed with the rain....unreal.
#53 Posted by percech (5237 posts) -
Halo 4.
#54 Posted by OldSnakePS3 (306 posts) -

The Last of Us

#55 Posted by worknow222 (1411 posts) -

The Last of Us

OldSnakePS3
even though its not out
#56 Posted by freedomfreak (42364 posts) -
Uncharted. Because of the artstyle. I only like Halo for its outdoor environments. Eveyrthing looks the same the moment you go indoors.
#57 Posted by Samus3D (1788 posts) -

The last picture for Halo 4 looks impressive, this is what im expecting with Metroid Prime 4

#58 Posted by BlbecekBobecek (2713 posts) -

Uncharted 3 easily. Halo 4 uses excess of blooming lights and those wax-like surfaces are terrible.

#59 Posted by worknow222 (1411 posts) -

The last picture for Halo 4 looks impressive, this is what im expecting with Metroid Prime 4

Samus3D
dont get my hopes up
#60 Posted by walkingdream (4883 posts) -
Halo 4....but then again i'm a Halo fan Uncharted 3 looks unbelievable though i felt Uncharted 2 looked better in some places.
#61 Posted by aroxx_ab (10625 posts) -

ZombiU destroys those games :lol:

#62 Posted by CTR360 (7318 posts) -
UC3
#63 Posted by Innovazero2000 (3144 posts) -

Personally due to scale, it's Halo 4 for me. This is apples and oranges though as they are two different games.

Even if UC had a slight edge, Halo is just a much bigger game being a sandbox.

#64 Posted by PAL360 (27162 posts) -

Both look fantastic considering the old hardware. Halo 4, due to scale.

#65 Posted by Floppy_Jim (25834 posts) -

Crysis 2 and Killzone 2/3 still look better than Halo 4.

/non-answer

#66 Posted by sukraj (23670 posts) -

Halo 4 looks so much better.

#67 Posted by gpuking (3046 posts) -
UC3>GOW3>KZ3>Halo 4. If people wanna go with scale then Far Cry 3 kills Halo 4.
#68 Posted by WiiMan21 (8189 posts) -

I've played, and beaten both of the games.

I think Uncharted visually looks a lot better.

#69 Posted by gpuking (3046 posts) -
Why create such a thread when you can't use decent shots of UC3? Also the cutscene in Halo 4 is subHD as you can see the black bars.
#70 Posted by themajormayor (24077 posts) -

Killzone 3

#71 Posted by worknow222 (1411 posts) -
UC3>GOW3>KZ3>Halo 4. If people wanna go with scale then Far Cry 3 kills Halo 4.gpuking
Graphics threads always become interesting when you here, now All we need is loosingends
#72 Posted by greensand24 (412 posts) -
On the visual/technical front Halo 4 all day every day.
#73 Posted by Malta_1980 (11475 posts) -

Both look great imo... I give the slight edge to UC3 but for mp I think H4 looks better..

#74 Posted by ronvalencia (15414 posts) -
[QUOTE="ShadowMoses900"]

It is subjective but I would take Uncharted 3 any day of the week, but I'm also a HUGE Uncharted fan.

In terms of graphics Uncharted wins but that is to be expected because it's a PS3 only game, and therfore the devs can take full advantage of the PS3's extra power.

FLOPs means nothing when a custom graphic operation can done in 1 cycle throughput e.g. Xenos's 3DC+ texture decompression.
#75 Posted by Heil68 (46421 posts) -
Uncharted 3 by miles.
#76 Posted by tenaka2 (17040 posts) -

My eyes are bleeding, please put a warning tag on the thread title.

#77 Posted by SecretPolice (22955 posts) -

Land & air vehicles, large scale, 4 player co-op through the entire SP campaign, Forge World etc.

Game-play & graphics Queen ( King Crysis ) confirmed .... Halo 4 Baby !! :P

#78 Posted by themajormayor (24077 posts) -
Oh lol look how detailed the textures are on U3 compared to Halo
#79 Posted by oddballrulez (1642 posts) -
[QUOTE="campzor"]why the bad uncharted pics? :/worknow222
there not bad there from real gamers who have taken the pictures of the games they play no bullshots at all there all in game and can be trusted to an extent, I linked to the threads the pictures are from if you wish to find more and post them then go a head

There are a thousand stunning moments in uncharted 3 and you grabbed screens from the blandest? There's nothing going on! Go play Uncharted 2 (The train level/city levels in particular) and then try to support Halo 4. Halo 4 is just another Halo. The engine at last looks up to par with most modern games, but it's still not that great looking :S Its the bland art style with a serious lack of attention to detail that ruins it for me. Naughty Dogs talent in the art/animation department make uncharted look better than the very vast majority of games today - coming from a PC gamer. (Though of course there's far better from a technical standpoint; consoles are old as hell.) So Uncharted by a country mile for me.
#80 Posted by oddballrulez (1642 posts) -
http://www.abload.de/img/11uke12tojdf.jpg <---- this show's that aside from lighting, Halo looks like a muddy puddle thanks to it's rather weak art style.
#81 Posted by greensand24 (412 posts) -

Crysis 2 and Killzone 2/3 still look better than Halo 4.

/non-answer

Floppy_Jim
In all honesty you might have an argument with crysis 2 because I constantly flip flop back and forth between that and Halo 4. They are definitely the two best looking games on consoles right now. The Killzone games look good but fall short. Low res textures and low poly structures all over the place at times make it look like ps2 games. As far as the Vaseline game blurzone 2 not even close.
#82 Posted by themajormayor (24077 posts) -
[QUOTE="Floppy_Jim"]

Crysis 2 and Killzone 2/3 still look better than Halo 4.

/non-answer

greensand24
In all honesty you might have an argument with crysis 2 because I constantly flip flop back and forth between that and Halo 4. They are definitely the two best looking games on consoles right now. The Killzone games look good but fall short. Low res textures and low poly structures all over the place at times make it look like ps2 games. As far as the Vaseline game blurzone 2 not even close.

lol what are you doing you clown
#83 Posted by greensand24 (412 posts) -
[QUOTE="greensand24"][QUOTE="Floppy_Jim"]

Crysis 2 and Killzone 2/3 still look better than Halo 4.

/non-answer

themajormayor
In all honesty you might have an argument with crysis 2 because I constantly flip flop back and forth between that and Halo 4. They are definitely the two best looking games on consoles right now. The Killzone games look good but fall short. Low res textures and low poly structures all over the place at times make it look like ps2 games. As far as the Vaseline game blurzone 2 not even close.

lol what are you doing you clown

Nothing but giving my opinion like the rest of us here.
#84 Posted by Floppy_Jim (25834 posts) -

[QUOTE="Floppy_Jim"]

Crysis 2 and Killzone 2/3 still look better than Halo 4.

/non-answer

greensand24

In all honesty you might have an argument with crysis 2 because I constantly flip flop back and forth between that and Halo 4. They are definitely the two best looking games on consoles right now. The Killzone games look good but fall short. Low res textures and low poly structures all over the place at times make it look like ps2 games. As far as the Vaseline game blurzone 2 not even close.

Yeah, I've heard those criticisms before but they impressed me a hell of a lot more than Halo 4 which just looks like a better looking Halo. It's partly to do with the dragging on of the 7th gen, no console graphics have blown me away in the last couple of years.

#85 Posted by worknow222 (1411 posts) -
[QUOTE="worknow222"][QUOTE="campzor"]why the bad uncharted pics? :/oddballrulez
there not bad there from real gamers who have taken the pictures of the games they play no bullshots at all there all in game and can be trusted to an extent, I linked to the threads the pictures are from if you wish to find more and post them then go a head

There are a thousand stunning moments in uncharted 3 and you grabbed screens from the blandest? There's nothing going on! Go play Uncharted 2 (The train level/city levels in particular) and then try to support Halo 4. Halo 4 is just another Halo. The engine at last looks up to par with most modern games, but it's still not that great looking :S Its the bland art style with a serious lack of attention to detail that ruins it for me. Naughty Dogs talent in the art/animation department make uncharted look better than the very vast majority of games today - coming from a PC gamer. (Though of course there's far better from a technical standpoint; consoles are old as hell.) So Uncharted by a country mile for me.

What halo 4 has great epic, levels, Trench run, mammoth run, mantis runs, halo 4 has many great pieces,
#86 Posted by timmy00 (15360 posts) -

Halo 4. Uncharted 3 was so disappointing in a lot of ways for me.

[QUOTE="ShadowsDemon"][QUOTE="Riadon2"]

Both of them make me want to vomit.

Riadon2

Why would that be?

Low-res flat textures, jaggies galore, horrible LOD and pop-in, very low AF, 720p, massive bloom overuse, crawling shadows, etc.

Sucks to be you. You don't have much of a stomach.

#87 Posted by PinnacleGamingP (5120 posts) -
this is a new low, even for lemmings
#88 Posted by PAL360 (27162 posts) -

http://www.abload.de/img/11uke12tojdf.jpg <---- this show's that aside from lighting, Halo looks like a muddy puddle thanks to it's rather weak art style. oddballrulez

Halo 4 in game and in engine:

halo-4-gif-12.gif

Then again, the best looking console game is a matter of opinion, but it is obvious that 360 can push the same graphical level as PS3, if not more. This wouldn't be a surprise if cows didn't pay so much attention to Sony lies, though.

#89 Posted by PinnacleGamingP (5120 posts) -
why cant lemmings just accept the 360 for what it is? crap hardware which produces mediocor graphics, there is no need to keep trying to make look as good as the ps3...
#90 Posted by PAL360 (27162 posts) -

this is a new low, even for lemmingsPinnacleGamingP

Of course it is! 3 exclusives as 2012 genre winners, two of them killing the myth about PS3 being more capable that 360. Poor lems :lol:

#91 Posted by greensand24 (412 posts) -
Haaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaalllllllloooooooooooooooooooooooooo 4 you moo-moo biaytches :) MMMOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOoOOOooooooooOooooo :)
#92 Posted by sts106mat (20378 posts) -

[QUOTE="PinnacleGamingP"]this is a new low, even for lemmingsPAL360

Of course it is! 3 exclusives as 2012 genre winners, two of them killing the myth about PS3 being more capable that 360. Poor lems :lol:

boom headshot.
#93 Posted by PinnacleGamingP (5120 posts) -

[QUOTE="PinnacleGamingP"]this is a new low, even for lemmingsPAL360

Of course it is! 3 exclusives as 2012 genre winners, two of them killing the myth about PS3 being more capable that 360. Poor lems :lol:

your gloating about 1 exclusive for the past 5 years?
#94 Posted by greensand24 (412 posts) -
[QUOTE="PAL360"]

[QUOTE="PinnacleGamingP"]this is a new low, even for lemmingsPinnacleGamingP

Of course it is! 3 exclusives as 2012 genre winners, two of them killing the myth about PS3 being more capable that 360. Poor lems :lol:

your gloating about 1 exclusive for the past 5 years?

MMOOOOOOOOOOOOOooooooooOOOOOooOoOOOooooOo :)
#95 Posted by PAL360 (27162 posts) -

[QUOTE="PAL360"]

[QUOTE="PinnacleGamingP"]this is a new low, even for lemmingsPinnacleGamingP

Of course it is! 3 exclusives as 2012 genre winners, two of them killing the myth about PS3 being more capable that 360. Poor lems :lol:

your gloating about 1 exclusive for the past 5 years?

Hmm....i'm pretty sure Gears 3, Forza 4, Bastion, Halo reach, won many awards in their respective genres. And let's not forget some amazing multiplats, like Skyrim: The Playable Version, Red Dead Redemption: The HD Version, etc :P

#96 Posted by themajormayor (24077 posts) -

[QUOTE="PinnacleGamingP"]this is a new low, even for lemmingsPAL360

two of them killing the myth about PS3 being more capable that 360.

How so?

#97 Posted by themajormayor (24077 posts) -

[QUOTE="PinnacleGamingP"][QUOTE="PAL360"]

Of course it is! 3 exclusives as 2012 genre winners, two of them killing the myth about PS3 being more capable that 360. Poor lems :lol:

PAL360

your gloating about 1 exclusive for the past 5 years?

Skyrim: The Playable Version

That's a PS3/PC multiplat

#98 Posted by sts106mat (20378 posts) -
[QUOTE="PAL360"]

[QUOTE="PinnacleGamingP"] your gloating about 1 exclusive for the past 5 years?themajormayor

Skyrim: The Playable Version

That's a PS3/PC multiplat

how are the PS3 versions of dawnguard and hearthfire?
#99 Posted by PinnacleGamingP (5120 posts) -
[QUOTE="PAL360"]

[QUOTE="PinnacleGamingP"][QUOTE="PAL360"]

Of course it is! 3 exclusives as 2012 genre winners, two of them killing the myth about PS3 being more capable that 360. Poor lems :lol:

your gloating about 1 exclusive for the past 5 years?

Hmm....i'm pretty sure Gears 3, Forza 4, Bastion, Halo reach, won many awards in their respective genres. And let's not forget some amazing multiplats, like Skyrim: The Playable Version, Red Dead Redemption: The HD Version, etc :P

typical lemmings, listing multiplats
#100 Posted by PAL360 (27162 posts) -

typical lemmings, listing multiplatsPinnacleGamingP

You should thank me for giving multiplats some credit. It's all you cows have to play this year, after all :P