Gears of War: Judgement scored higher than God of War: Ascension?

  • 162 results
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4

This topic is locked from further discussion.

#1 Posted by SonyNintendoFan (527 posts) -

This is why reviews can't be trusted, and they are bought!

I have seen IGN littered with Judgement ads, so no wonder they scored it higher. I saw that coming a mile away.

Gears of war looks all the same, all you do is go in to an area with cover, cover and shoot. Rinse and repeat the whole game. God of War on the other hand, there is always scenery changes, the bosses are better, the enemies and combat is diverse and doesn't get dull. In gears, all you do i shoot. In God of war, you have different weapons and can pull off a lot of cool combos.

Do you believe Gears deserves a 9.2 from IGN compared to Ascension's getting 7.8?

#2 Posted by lundy86_4 (42875 posts) -

Don't cry.

#3 Posted by RyanShazam (6498 posts) -

U Mad?

#4 Posted by silversix_ (13912 posts) -
Who cares they're both a waste of development time. Gears need a 5 years break and GoW has to come on ps4 to be half impressive.
#5 Posted by PhazonBlazer (11516 posts) -

Oh noez! IGN gave a game a higher score than another game! :roll:

#6 Posted by timbers_WSU (5753 posts) -

I am sure Microsoft pays for all of their reviews. :roll:

#8 Posted by campzor (34932 posts) -
i think gow:A scored higher than Geow:J @ GT justice served.
#9 Posted by StrongDeadlift (5140 posts) -

:D

234.jpg

#10 Posted by darkspineslayer (19479 posts) -
Grow the fvck up, it's topics like these that make the other cows look foolish. It's a bloody score. BTW, speaking as a huge God of War fan, Ascension is not their best effort.
#11 Posted by Karpetburnz (544 posts) -

Why are going by IGN scores now? IGN is all over the place with their reviews. Ni No Kuni got a 9.4 from IGN anyway.

GoW:J has a 80 on Metacritic, which is exactly the same God of War Ascension. and even if one does score slightly higer than the other nobody gives a damn, people will still buy and enjoy both games.

#12 Posted by KarateeeChop (4590 posts) -

the media still has it out for my precious ps3!! :cry:

#13 Posted by StrongBlackVine (8418 posts) -

I have not played either game and probably never will. Both are getting stale.

#14 Posted by StrongDeadlift (5140 posts) -

the media still has it out for my precious ps3!! :cry:

KarateeeChop

:cool:This just goes to show why Cows need to start showing more restraint, like the other factions.  That way they wont constantly get "owned" like this. 

All of 2 people hyped this game (and said hype was within reasonable expectations), while God of War was supposed to be the end all be all.  

Cows, every game doesnt need to be hyped an AAAA world killer, "savior of the PS3", or singlehandedly pinning the PS3's entire year on this one game.  (same goes for The Last of Us, hint hint  )

#15 Posted by 001011000101101 (3949 posts) -
Both games are meh looking.
#16 Posted by shadiezz2012 (2567 posts) -
lol it got lower scores than ascension in alot more sites like GT,DS etc and also both have the same metascore and @StrongDeadlift you should stop talking now ...because you got owned soo bad with the metascore it's not even funny any more and lol xbox fanboys trust IGN now ?! what happend to "pro sony site" ?!
#17 Posted by StrongBlackVine (8418 posts) -

[QUOTE="KarateeeChop"]

the media still has it out for my precious ps3!! :cry:

StrongDeadlift

:cool:This just goes to show why Cows need to start showing more restraint, like the other factions.  That way they wont constantly get "owned" like this. 

All of 2 people hyped this game (and said hype was within reasonable expectations), while God of War was supposed to be the end all be all.  

Cows, every game doesnt need to be hyped an AAAA world killer, "savior of the PS3", or singlehandedly pinning the PS3's entire year on this one game.  (same goes for The Last of Us, hint hint  )

Pretty pathetic to sit around hoping games get bad reviews. You have issues.

#18 Posted by StrongDeadlift (5140 posts) -

@StrongDeadlift you should stop talking now ...because you got owned soo bad with the metascore it's not even funny any more shadiezz2012

Explain.

#19 Posted by shadiezz2012 (2567 posts) -

[QUOTE="KarateeeChop"]

the media still has it out for my precious ps3!! :cry:

StrongDeadlift

:cool:This just goes to show why Cows need to start showing more restraint, like the other factions.  That way they wont constantly get "owned" like this. 

All of 2 people hyped this game (and said hype was within reasonable expectations), while God of War was supposed to be the end all be all.  

Cows, every game doesnt need to be hyped an AAAA world killer, "savior of the PS3", or singlehandedly pinning the PS3's entire year on this one game.  (same goes for The Last of Us, hint hint  )

what ?! who the game was hyped as an 8 game all along and ps3 have alot more exclusives to play and Ni No Kuni 86% meta is one of them you are trying way too hard dude your obsession with sony is not right ...you might end up in asylum
#20 Posted by Wickerman777 (1132 posts) -

I haven't played them but it's probably just a case of fatigue with both of them. Is common for critics to give games in a given franchise lower and lower scores as new installments get released because after a while they take their quality for granted.

#21 Posted by Karpetburnz (544 posts) -

lol it got lower scores than ascension in alot more sites like GT,DS etc and also both have the same metascore and @StrongDeadlift you should stop talking now ...because you got owned soo bad with the metascore it's not even funny any more and lol xbox fanboys trust IGN now ?! what happend to "pro sony site" ?! shadiezz2012

True, And PS3 has still had more higher scoring exclusives this year.

PS3

1.MLB 13:the show = 87

2.Ni No Nuni = 86

3.God of War:Ascension = 80

Xbox360

1. Gears of War: Judgment = 80

#23 Posted by shadiezz2012 (2567 posts) -

[QUOTE="shadiezz2012"]@StrongDeadlift you should stop talking now ...because you got owned soo bad with the metascore it's not even funny any more StrongDeadlift

Explain.

lol you live in another world as it seem both those games have the same meta in another topic about gearsj IGN review every one is laughing at you if you don't know why you need help
#24 Posted by shadiezz2012 (2567 posts) -

[QUOTE="shadiezz2012"]lol it got lower scores than ascension in alot more sites like GT,DS etc and also both have the same metascore and @StrongDeadlift you should stop talking now ...because you got owned soo bad with the metascore it's not even funny any more and lol xbox fanboys trust IGN now ?! what happend to "pro sony site" ?! Karpetburnz

True, And PS3 has still had more higher scoring exclusives this year.

PS3

1.MLB 13:the show = 87

2.Ni No Nuni = 86

3.God of War:Ascension = 80

Xbox360

1. Gears of War: Judgment = 80

dude you gonna make StrongDeadlift kill him self :lol:
#25 Posted by Karpetburnz (544 posts) -

If Lemmings want to start using IGN for ownage, Ni No Kuni got a 9.4 on IGN this year, Uncharted 3 got a 10 and Metal Gear Solid 4 got a 10, Infact has any Xbox exclusive ever got a 10 from IGN?

#26 Posted by StrongDeadlift (5140 posts) -

[QUOTE="StrongDeadlift"]

[QUOTE="shadiezz2012"]@StrongDeadlift you should stop talking now ...because you got owned soo bad with the metascore it's not even funny any more shadiezz2012

Explain.

lol you live in another world as it seem both those games have the same meta in another topic about gearsj IGN review every one is laughing at you if you don't know why you need help

Thats not an answer to what I asked. Explain how I got "owned" :)

#27 Posted by shadiezz2012 (2567 posts) -

If Lemmings want to start using IGN for ownage, Ni No Kuni got a 9.4 on IGN this year, Uncharted 3 got a 10 and Metal Gear Solid 4 got a 10, Infact has any Xbox exclusive ever got a 10 from IGN?

Karpetburnz
i just found out that even uncharted wannabe (tomb raider) best version is on ps3 http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-tomb-raider-face-off lems can't get a break as it seems i will have to buy that game on pc though
#28 Posted by Giancar (19046 posts) -
Meh one site gave a higher score, deal with it. It is an opinion. From the looks of it, both games will end up getting similar scores across the internet. And both series really need to end. Hopefully we'll see new IP's next gen from the respective developers.
while God of War was supposed to be the end all be all. StrongDeadlift
It was hyped AA, with a hyped thread containing way less posts than the GoW 3 one.
#29 Posted by joel_c17 (2823 posts) -
Yes the review was a real eyebrow raiser - but I take every review with a grain of salt tho
#30 Posted by StrongDeadlift (5140 posts) -

[QUOTE="StrongDeadlift"]

[QUOTE="KarateeeChop"]

the media still has it out for my precious ps3!! :cry:

StrongBlackVine

:cool:This just goes to show why Cows need to start showing more restraint, like the other factions.  That way they wont constantly get "owned" like this. 

All of 2 people hyped this game (and said hype was within reasonable expectations), while God of War was supposed to be the end all be all.  

Cows, every game doesnt need to be hyped an AAAA world killer, "savior of the PS3", or singlehandedly pinning the PS3's entire year on this one game.  (same goes for The Last of Us, hint hint  )

Pretty pathetic to sit around hoping games get bad reviews. You have issues.

Who said im sitting around? :?

Ive made 7 posts on this forum in the past 48 hours.  5 of which were within the past 30 minutes.  

http://www.gamespot.com/users/StrongDeadlift/contributions?mode=forum

You, on the other hand, have made 100 posts in that same timeframe

http://www.gamespot.com/users/StrongBlackVine/contributions?mode=forum&page=4

But nice attempt to "son" me, tho ;)

#31 Posted by shadiezz2012 (2567 posts) -

[QUOTE="shadiezz2012"][QUOTE="StrongDeadlift"]

Explain.

StrongDeadlift

lol you live in another world as it seem both those games have the same meta in another topic about gearsj IGN review every one is laughing at you if you don't know why you need help

Thats not an answer to what I asked. Explain how I got "owned" :)

Wha ...?! 0_0 ?!

look at your sig and look at what gears got

you were laughing about GOWA 79% but you got owned with it being 80% now

and ...out of now where gears get the same metascore and you dare to talk here like it some kind of win for you ?!

 

#32 Posted by Karpetburnz (544 posts) -

[QUOTE="Karpetburnz"]

If Lemmings want to start using IGN for ownage, Ni No Kuni got a 9.4 on IGN this year, Uncharted 3 got a 10 and Metal Gear Solid 4 got a 10, Infact has any Xbox exclusive ever got a 10 from IGN?

shadiezz2012

i just found out that even uncharted wannabe (tomb raider) best version is on ps3 http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-tomb-raider-face-off lems can't get a break as it seems i will have to buy that game on pc though

This year has been rubbish for Lems, after GoW:J they have nothing left to look foward to, PS3 has still got The Last of Us and Beyond:Two Souls.

#33 Posted by shadiezz2012 (2567 posts) -

[QUOTE="shadiezz2012"][QUOTE="Karpetburnz"]

If Lemmings want to start using IGN for ownage, Ni No Kuni got a 9.4 on IGN this year, Uncharted 3 got a 10 and Metal Gear Solid 4 got a 10, Infact has any Xbox exclusive ever got a 10 from IGN?

Karpetburnz

i just found out that even uncharted wannabe (tomb raider) best version is on ps3 http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-tomb-raider-face-off lems can't get a break as it seems i will have to buy that game on pc though

This year has been rubbish for Lems, after GoW:J they have nothing left to look foward to, PS3 has still got The Last of Us and Beyond:Two Souls.

there is also alot more than just those two
#34 Posted by StrongDeadlift (5140 posts) -

 Wha ...?! 0_0 ?! look at your sig and look at what gears got shadiezz2012

And? :?

http://www.gamespot.com/forums/topic/29365386/secret-code-in-gow-a-teases-new-setting-new-hero?page=0

[QUOTE="Vatusus"]

oh man, I cant way for Gears: Judgement to come out and be trashed the same way as GoW:A because of franchise fatigue

StrongDeadlift

And I would care about that why exactly? :?


Now, I dare you, to find a post of me hyping Gears Judgement, Saying anything positive about it, or even talking about the game.  (as in actually talking about it).  

Actually, I dare you to find a post of me hyping or saying anything positive about the Gears of War franchise on this website EVER.  Ill wait ;)

#35 Posted by SonyNintendoFan (527 posts) -
Yes the review was a real eyebrow raiser - but I take every review with a grain of salt thojoel_c17
According to IGN, apparently the same ol' boring Gears multiplayer is better than Ascensions new multiplayer. Ascensions multiplauer introduces so many new things that it makes gear's multiplayer look redundant.
#36 Posted by Karpetburnz (544 posts) -

[QUOTE="Karpetburnz"]

[QUOTE="shadiezz2012"] i just found out that even uncharted wannabe (tomb raider) best version is on ps3 http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-tomb-raider-face-off lems can't get a break as it seems i will have to buy that game on pc though shadiezz2012

This year has been rubbish for Lems, after GoW:J they have nothing left to look foward to, PS3 has still got The Last of Us and Beyond:Two Souls.

there is also alot more than just those two

yeah, those are the ones im interested in the most, theres still a lot more I couldve listed.

#37 Posted by ShaineTheNerd (1345 posts) -
[QUOTE="Karpetburnz"]

If Lemmings want to start using IGN for ownage, Ni No Kuni got a 9.4 on IGN this year, Uncharted 3 got a 10 and Metal Gear Solid 4 got a 10, Infact has any Xbox exclusive ever got a 10 from IGN?

shadiezz2012
i just found out that even uncharted wannabe (tomb raider) best version is on ps3 http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-tomb-raider-face-off lems can't get a break as it seems i will have to buy that game on pc though

Hold on, hold on, hold on... Uncharted wannabe? You do know Tomb Raider came out in '96, correct?
#38 Posted by NathanDrakeSwag (5127 posts) -

Strongdeadlift will never get laid when he spends all his time calculating everyones posts per day and crying over Sony domination.

#39 Posted by shadiezz2012 (2567 posts) -

[QUOTE="shadiezz2012"]

And? :?

http://www.gamespot.com/forums/topic/29365386/secret-code-in-gow-a-teases-new-setting-new-hero?page=0

[QUOTE="StrongDeadlift"][QUOTE="Vatusus"]

oh man, I cant way for Gears: Judgement to come out and be trashed the same way as GoW:A because of franchise fatigue

StrongDeadlift

And I would care about that why exactly? :?


Now, I dare you, to find a post of me hyping Gears Judgement, Saying anything positive about it, or even talking about the game.  (as in actually talking about it).  

Actually, I dare you to find a post of me hyping or saying anything positive about the Gears of War franchise on this website EVER.  Ill wait ;)

it just enough for me that you got owned with your own sig are you going to make sig about lems too ??! and who said GOWA is the be all and end all ?! the hype was 8 and it got 8 you keep own your self every time you comment and every one here know that you hate sony like they raped you when you were child
#40 Posted by lamprey263 (22804 posts) -
from what I've seen of the campaign so far the gameplay looks very meaty, lots more enemies to contend with at any given time, way more shootery in that regard, I don't see why one would be in denial that this could turn out to actually be good
#41 Posted by shadiezz2012 (2567 posts) -
[QUOTE="shadiezz2012"][QUOTE="Karpetburnz"]

If Lemmings want to start using IGN for ownage, Ni No Kuni got a 9.4 on IGN this year, Uncharted 3 got a 10 and Metal Gear Solid 4 got a 10, Infact has any Xbox exclusive ever got a 10 from IGN?

ShaineTheNerd
i just found out that even uncharted wannabe (tomb raider) best version is on ps3 http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-tomb-raider-face-off lems can't get a break as it seems i will have to buy that game on pc though

Hold on, hold on, hold on... Uncharted wannabe? You do know Tomb Raider came out in '96, correct?

] plz point me to every thing uncharted took from old TR with videos and/or pics and if you think the new TR didn't take alot of uncharted than there is no point to talk
#42 Posted by StrongDeadlift (5140 posts) -

[QUOTE="StrongDeadlift"]

[QUOTE="shadiezz2012"] And I would care about that why exactly? :?shadiezz2012


Now, I dare you, to find a post of me hyping Gears Judgement, Saying anything positive about it, or even talking about the game.  (as in actually talking about it).  

Actually, I dare you to find a post of me hyping or saying anything positive about the Gears of War franchise on this website EVER.  Ill wait ;)

it just enough for me that you got owned with your own sig are you going to make sig about lems too ??! and who said GOWA is the be all and end all ?! the hype was 8 and it got 8 you keep own your self every time you comment and every one here know that you hate sony like they raped you when you were child

Why would I make a sig about lems?  Much less entertaining :D

They dont cry about every negative thing said about MS, like cows do ;)

#43 Posted by mems_1224 (46250 posts) -
Criticizes Gears for being more of the same then praises God of War. :lol: I never understood why people take reviews seriously and why they get upset when a game they like doesnt score as high as they want. Its really stupid.
#44 Posted by Jack-Burton (2303 posts) -
Eurogamer gave it an 8 to God of Wars 7 whats the problem?
#45 Posted by _Matt_ (8837 posts) -

Both GoW and GeoW are getting boring in my eyes; though for the record, they are both at 80 on metacritic, oh the drama!

#46 Posted by xhawk27 (7211 posts) -

Cows Butthurt much? :lol:

#47 Posted by shadiezz2012 (2567 posts) -

Eurogamer gave it an 8 to God of Wars 7 whats the problem?Jack-Burton
Digital spy give GOWA a 8/10 and give GearsJ a 6/10

GameTailers give GOWA higher score too

and  more site did that too

whats the problem?;)

 

both have the same metascore anyway:P

#48 Posted by xhawk27 (7211 posts) -

[QUOTE="shadiezz2012"]lol it got lower scores than ascension in alot more sites like GT,DS etc and also both have the same metascore and @StrongDeadlift you should stop talking now ...because you got owned soo bad with the metascore it's not even funny any more and lol xbox fanboys trust IGN now ?! what happend to "pro sony site" ?! Karpetburnz

True, And PS3 has still had more higher scoring exclusives this year.

PS3

1.MLB 13:the show = 87

2.Ni No Nuni = 86

3.God of War:Ascension = 80

Xbox360

1. Gears of War: Judgment = 80

Baseball is boring like the PS3 exclusives. :lol:

#49 Posted by xhawk27 (7211 posts) -

[QUOTE="Jack-Burton"]Eurogamer gave it an 8 to God of Wars 7 whats the problem?shadiezz2012
Digital spy give GOWA a 8/10 and give GearsJ a 6/10 GT give GOWA higher score too and lot more site did that too whats the problem?;)

Digital spy never heard of it. Must be a Sony fanboy site. ;)

#50 Posted by MstaPrimeMnista (1073 posts) -

I haven't played them but it's probably just a case of fatigue with both of them. Is common for critics to give games in a given franchise lower and lower scores as new installments get released because after a while they take their quality for granted.

Wickerman777
Mario has gotten crappier, yet the scores have gotten better.