[QUOTE="kuraimen"]Incredible how biased GS is. They act all harsh all year and then go and get all light on 360 exclusives. Tom McFail.senses_fail_06In all honesty, we have to look at standards. This is probably a great game for the kinect. I mean the menus are functional so that probably makes it an automatic 7.0. Seems Tom likes the horsey too, so that probably what makes it an AA game. Same thing goes with cell phone games as far as standards.
actually, i had a conversation with tom mcshea in september of 2011 about this issue when gunstringer released. his statements were as follows...
"There are universal standards that all games are judged against. The Gunslinger is a Great game. There's no need to qualify that statement by saying "it's great... for Kinect." Granted, this doesn't mean you should say, "oh, that means its the same as Alan Wake because they both got the same score" since those two games are vastly different. But you can use that score as an indicator of quality just like every other review we publish."
"The Kinect is not a seperate platform. Though comparisons in regards to controls will most likely reference other Kinect games (since those have the most similar controls), the overall quality is judged just like any other game."