Destiny Beta PS4 vs Xbox One Screenshot Comparison

  • 126 results
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
Posted by FreedomFreeLife (2454 posts) 4 months, 4 days ago

Poll: Destiny Beta PS4 vs Xbox One Screenshot Comparison (101 votes)

Playstation 4 - BEST 67%
Xbox One - BEST 33%

Round 1:

Round 2:

Round 3:

To see differences, click on image and see HD version.

#1 Edited by DEadliNE-Zero0 (2470 posts) -

They basically look the same. Besides the lighting difference in the last pic.

#2 Posted by Blabadon (26355 posts) -

Yeah, nothing worth arguing about here. They look the same.

#3 Posted by chikenfriedrice (10432 posts) -

Round 1 = Tie

Round 2 = X1

Round 3 = PS4

#4 Posted by sHaDyCuBe321 (4136 posts) -

Terrible poll. The both look identical minus the most minute differences and the poll doesn't give an option for that.

#5 Posted by faizan_faizan (7866 posts) -

Why does the Xbone version has a smear of Vaseline on the screen?

#6 Posted by clyde46 (46294 posts) -

Horrible crushed colours on the X1. I'm going to wait for DF.

#7 Posted by FastRobby (1803 posts) -

Normally PS4 should look better, Xbox One version is pre-June SDK, so I would think PS4 would win hands down... Bungie said that the build they are using are identical

#8 Posted by Suppaman100 (3916 posts) -

No OP, not going to work.

PS4 version is the superior one, some cherry-picked sreenshots won't change that fact.

#9 Edited by FreedomFreeLife (2454 posts) -

Guys. CLICK ON IMAGES TO SEE THE DIFFERENCES!!!

Looking at normal images not show differences.

Xbox One version is darker but textures and everything else is washed out(seems not to be true 1080p after all)

#10 Posted by FastRobby (1803 posts) -

@FreedomFreeLife said:

Guys. CLICK ON IMAGES TO SEE THE DIFFERENCES!!!

Looking at normal images not show differences.

Xbox One version is darker but textures and everything else is washed out(seems not to be true 1080p after all)

The beta was 900p... The game that will be shipped, will be 1080p

#11 Posted by MonsieurX (30269 posts) -
@FreedomFreeLife said:

Guys. CLICK ON IMAGES TO SEE THE DIFFERENCES!!!

Looking at normal images not show differences.

Xbox One version is darker but textures and everything else is washed out(seems not to be true 1080p after all)

It's not 1080p

#12 Edited by GrenadeLauncher (4918 posts) -

Xbone, that version has more weather effects such as fog.

Wait, that's 900p?

Oh.

#13 Edited by RoboCopISJesus (1408 posts) -

The difference is almost impossible to see, yet you guys still argue. There is a bigger difference in pc vs. console multiplats, yet you guys wash those aside as "not noticeable".

Hypocrites.

#14 Posted by chikenfriedrice (10432 posts) -

@MonsieurX said:
@FreedomFreeLife said:

Guys. CLICK ON IMAGES TO SEE THE DIFFERENCES!!!

Looking at normal images not show differences.

Xbox One version is darker but textures and everything else is washed out(seems not to be true 1080p after all)

It's not 1080p

Lolz...thought this was public knowledge

#15 Edited by DEadliNE-Zero0 (2470 posts) -

@clyde46 said:

Horrible crushed colours on the X1. I'm going to wait for DF.

Personally, if i have to wait for DF to tell where the differences are, i don't give a fuck.

WD and DS2 are the perfect examples of games where, specially on PC maxed out, look much better than their console counterparts even when compressed by YT. That's teh kind of difference i want in my ultra settings PC. Sadly, publishers, Sony and MS, want parity for those games.

#16 Posted by YearoftheSnake5 (7409 posts) -

The differences are marginal. The PS4 version looks a teeny bit sharper, and I like the shading better on the X1. The difference will likely be even smaller on release to the point where it's going to look identical for everyone who doesn't have a microscope held up to the screen.

#17 Posted by Telekill (4604 posts) -

I can't tell a difference other than the PS4 version appears to have more atmospheric conditions like fog. While some could argue that that could lead to more realism, the screen shot of the X1 version could be the system simply making it a more clear day.

Other than that, I see no difference. The clouds look pretty photo realistic which is pretty awesome.

#18 Posted by MonsieurX (30269 posts) -

@chikenfriedrice said:

@MonsieurX said:
@FreedomFreeLife said:

Guys. CLICK ON IMAGES TO SEE THE DIFFERENCES!!!

Looking at normal images not show differences.

Xbox One version is darker but textures and everything else is washed out(seems not to be true 1080p after all)

It's not 1080p

Lolz...thought this was public knowledge

You're expecting too much of him.

#19 Posted by BldgIrsh (2594 posts) -

1080p vs 900p.

#20 Edited by Animal-Mother (26962 posts) -

Man the XB1 version looks like ass.

#21 Posted by stereointegrity (10725 posts) -

still crushing blacks.......i thought this was fixed

#22 Edited by FreedomFreeLife (2454 posts) -

People still can´t see the differences??? People using PC res 720p???

You can see huge differences when you open both pictures, 1080p screen PC monitor. How people can be so blind? Look textures, look shape and blurry. People can´t see shape and blurry??? WOW JUST WOW.

CLICK ON IMAGE

#23 Posted by lostrib (37035 posts) -

The PS4 is definitely better, but it doesn't help that the X1 Beta is upscaled from 900p which I assume contributes to some of the blurriness and darker images

#24 Posted by ___gamemaster__ (2415 posts) -

this look like a last gen visually.

#25 Edited by Antwan3K (2341 posts) -

You should Photoshop out the "PS4" and "Xbox One" labels and mix up the order in which the pics are organized.. then ask people to name the console the screenshots came from in exact order within their post.. put your money where your mouth is.. That would be way more interesting than fanboys just blindly saying their console of choice looks better based on the fact that they can plainly see the labeling..

Even better, I wish a website would reverse the labeling for a few days only to reveal later that PS4 fanboys have been hyping up Xbox One screenshots as being clearly superior while saying the PS4 screenshots have crushed blacks.. that would be awesome too..

Other than that, anyone can clearly see that these screenshots look virtually identical and any minimal difference can be chalked up to the fact that one version is still at 900p..

#26 Posted by lostrib (37035 posts) -

@FreedomFreeLife said:

People still can´t see the differences??? People using PC res 720p???

You can see huge differences when you open both pictures, 1080p screen PC monitor. How people can be so blind? Look textures, look shape and blurry. People can´t see shape and blurry??? WOW JUST WOW.

wow

such question mark

much english

so wow

#27 Edited by MonsieurX (30269 posts) -
@lostrib said:

@FreedomFreeLife said:

People still can´t see the differences??? People using PC res 720p???

You can see huge differences when you open both pictures, 1080p screen PC monitor. How people can be so blind? Look textures, look shape and blurry. People can´t see shape and blurry??? WOW JUST WOW.

wow

such question mark

much english

so wow

#28 Edited by RoboCopISJesus (1408 posts) -

@FreedomFreeLife said:

People still can´t see the differences???

Now you know how PC gamers feel when console fanboys lie about there being " no difference "

#29 Edited by ghostwarrior786 (4675 posts) -

not even a fair comparison, x1 looks like shit. i thought ms said they will stop crushing blacks

#30 Posted by FreedomFreeLife (2454 posts) -

@RoboCopISJesus said:

@FreedomFreeLife said:

People still can´t see the differences???

Now you know how PC gamers feel when console fanboys lie about there being " no difference "

Yeah.

#31 Edited by SambaLele (5424 posts) -

Well, from comparing those screens, the PS4 version seems to have a bit less jaggies, has a clearer picture (maybe a tiny difference in resolution? and a bit worse textures on X1?) and a more easy to notice better level of detail over distance (better AF?). Contrast and colors are also better on the PS4. Overall, it's a noticeable difference, but not huge. How do both versions run framerate-wise?

#32 Edited by ChronosChris (279 posts) -

Round 3 - PS4 looks a bit more detailed, whilst Xbone has washed out textures.

#33 Posted by StormyJoe (5387 posts) -

Who gives a crap - they are BETAS.

#34 Posted by scatteh316 (4927 posts) -

Xbone pics look blurier

#35 Posted by hoosier7 (3827 posts) -

Lol, some still think the X1 version looks better.

The blurriness on the X1 version should be gone come launch and that'll make the jaggies less harsh too but i've got concerns about the colours on the X1 version, it's losing detail again because of the darkness of the blacks.

#36 Posted by lostrib (37035 posts) -

@hoosier7 said:

Lol, some still think the X1 version looks better.

The blurriness on the X1 version should be gone come launch and that'll make the jaggies less harsh too but i've got concerns about the colours on the X1 version, it's losing detail again because of the darkness of the blacks.

aren't the crushed blacks a result of upscaling?

#37 Edited by Cloud_imperium (3352 posts) -

Very minor differences but pros and cons on both sides cancel out each other . Hard to pick .

However I'll choose PS4 just because textures in 2nd round are better on it . Look at mountains far away and scratches on steel .

Look at red circles .

#38 Edited by hoosier7 (3827 posts) -

@chikenfriedrice said:

Round 1 = Tie

Round 2 = X1

Round 3 = PS4

#39 Posted by I_can_haz (6551 posts) -

Thread backfire.

#40 Posted by hoosier7 (3827 posts) -

@lostrib said:

@hoosier7 said:

Lol, some still think the X1 version looks better.

The blurriness on the X1 version should be gone come launch and that'll make the jaggies less harsh too but i've got concerns about the colours on the X1 version, it's losing detail again because of the darkness of the blacks.

aren't the crushed blacks a result of upscaling?

Oh yeh forgot it was 900p, looks like we might actually see parity then as long as they don't have to cut anything from the X1 version to get it to hit 1080p since it seems to be struggling and whether it holds the framerate as well as the PS4 version.

#41 Posted by chikenfriedrice (10432 posts) -

@hoosier7 said:

@chikenfriedrice said:

Round 1 = Tie

Round 2 = X1

Round 3 = PS4

I see more detail in the X1 round 2 pic

regardless its lame to compare right now anyway...need to wait for the final product to pick apart the minute differences.

#42 Posted by lostrib (37035 posts) -

@I_can_haz said:

Thread backfire.

no, remember he's switched sides again

#43 Posted by Chutebox (37233 posts) -

PS4 looks bettter, but not by much. X1 is much darker (HATE this) and a tiny (can's stress tiny enough) blurrier.

Don't really care about second point, but I hate how dark it is on X1.

#44 Edited by DEadliNE-Zero0 (2470 posts) -

@Antwan3K said:

You should Photoshop out the "PS4" and "Xbox One" labels and mix up the order in which the pics are organized.. then ask people to name the console the screenshots came from in exact order within their post..

Trust me, even with real world game footage at a full 1080i tv, the majority would be guessing in almost every try without a side by side to point it out to them.

#45 Posted by hoosier7 (3827 posts) -

@chikenfriedrice said:

@hoosier7 said:

@chikenfriedrice said:

Round 1 = Tie

Round 2 = X1

Round 3 = PS4

I see more detail in the X1 round 2 pic

regardless its lame to compare right now anyway...need to wait for the final product to pick apart the minute differences.

Wait you're serious?

Where? The X1 version is really blurry and the steal hangar building looks terrible because of the colouring and crushed blacks on the X1 version. Seems there's a shadow missing too.

How did you get a tie out of the first one too, there's a loss of detail because of the blacks on the scafolding on the left and the engine's on the ship never mind that the X1 version is blurred to fuck.

#46 Posted by wolverine4262 (19334 posts) -

Obvious differences are contrast and resolution. At release, I imagine theyll be almost identical. Dont think we'll see the crushed blacks on the x1 once they get it to 1080p.

#47 Edited by kinectthedots (1941 posts) -

@ghostwarrior786 said:

not even a fair comparison, x1 looks like shit. i thought ms said they will stop crushing blacks

Jay'von never even saw it coming..

#48 Edited by chikenfriedrice (10432 posts) -

@hoosier7: I understand the resolution difference that's why its stupid to compare right now....but I see more detail on the building....maybe it's just the lighting, who knows.

And the first pic doesn't look that much different to me....maybe I don't have the skill that it takes to see such small differences

The resolution is the biggest difference and that will be the same at retail.

#49 Posted by silversix_ (14636 posts) -

Blurrier if you look at full screen but in general it looks good i guess.

#50 Posted by Heil68 (44645 posts) -

SW's has spoken and PS$ wins again.