After the hype dies down, it looks like her review was right.
1. GTA V is not a 10/10.
2. The game does treat women like crap (yes she did make that a big part of her review, but the game has problems beyond that)
3. The characters do behave inconsistently (and it does cripple the narrative, which struggles between silly and serious)
4. It is politically muddled (it's a game that tries to be political every single minute but still has no specific message it wants to send)