Eli Manning is the Best Quarterback in the NFL

And it really isn't even close, no quarterback in the NFL has the ability to consistently bring back a team in the 4th quarter like Eli can. He works with guys like Ramses Barden and Martellus Bennett and turns them into phenominal WR/TEs, there is no doubt that if NYG finds its way back in the playoffs Eli will certainly get a 3rd ring.

No. Looking forward to seeing him get spanked this weekend.

No. Just no. He's a very good QB, but if you just take a quick look at the last few years, he isn't even close to the top in QB Rating. And if you go by Super Bowls and making nobodies into sombodies, you put Tom Brady at the top. So although he's good, he's not the best QB in the NFL.

Barden and Bennett? Yeah? Really? You couldn't name Nicks or Cruz? Oh poor Eli.

The best quarterbacks don't suck so much through the first 3 quarters, and don't have to do so much in the 4th.

And it really isn't even close, no quarterback in the NFL has the ability to consistently bring back a team in the 4th quarter like Eli can. He works with guys like Ramses Barden and Martellus Bennett and turns them into phenominal WR/TEs, there is no doubt that if NYG finds its way back in the playoffs Eli will certainly get a 3rd ring.

halo1399

Very well said....

This sums it up pretty well. More often than not he and the offense seem clueless until the 4th quarter. If you said he was the best 4th Quarter QB in the NFL you could definitely make a case for it. Best overall QB though? I still say no.

Nah.. Discount Double Check, The Mole, Uggz are all better.

Eh, no.

He'll get more TDs compared to the last 2 teams that faced the 49ers. Also, the 49ers want revenge so they'll slow him down.GameboyTroy

He's very good, not the best though. I'd give that title to someone like Brady/Rodgers.

The best quarterbacks don't suck so much through the first 3 quarters, and don't have to do so much in the 4th.

Oleg_Huzwog

Manning is good, certainly elite. But the best in the league? No. Rodgers is having an uncharacteristic start, but he is still the league's best.monkeytoes61

I think Eli is definitely an elite QB in the NFL no doubt. But the crown goes to Aaron Rodgers. The guy can make any throw, throw on the run, powerful arm, and he's mobile. Rodgers is the complete package athletic wise if you ask me for a QB.

[QUOTE="monkeytoes61"]Manning is good, certainly elite. But the best in the league? No. Rodgers is having an uncharacteristic start, but he is still the league's best.The-Apostle

[QUOTE="The-Apostle"][QUOTE="monkeytoes61"]Manning is good, certainly elite. But the best in the league? No. Rodgers is having an uncharacteristic start, but he is still the league's best.monkeytoes61

[QUOTE="The-Apostle"][QUOTE="monkeytoes61"]Manning is good, certainly elite. But the best in the league? No. Rodgers is having an uncharacteristic start, but he is still the league's best.monkeytoes61

. The guy can make any throw,

mjf249

. But the bad calls went both ways in that game. monkeytoes61

[QUOTE="monkeytoes61"]. But the bad calls went both ways in that game. jg4xchamp

[QUOTE="monkeytoes61"]. But the bad calls went both ways in that game. jg4xchamp

Aaron Rodgers is the best QB in the NFL. This isnt even debatable.

Aaron Rodgers is the best QB in the NFL. This isnt even debatable.

Fizzman

It's debatable. However I would not tell you that you are wrong. Rodgers, Eli, Brady, Brees all have cases imo.

[QUOTE="monkeytoes61"]Manning is good, certainly elite. But the best in the league? No. Rodgers is having an uncharacteristic start, but he is still the league's best.The-Apostle

As i recall Micheal Vick beat him therefore Micheal Vick is the Best Quarterback in the NFL. He has had a rough start but it's not like Eli hasn't.

[QUOTE="jg4xchamp"]

[QUOTE="monkeytoes61"]. But the bad calls went both ways in that game. jeffster85

[QUOTE="monkeytoes61"]. But the bad calls went both ways in that game. jg4xchamp

[QUOTE="jeffster85"][QUOTE="jg4xchamp"] STFU

There is a difference between a bad call, and a screw job. That's a screw job.

Besides it's not like he was b1tching, as much as he said post screw job(because that's what that sh1t is, and saying otherwise is some grade A spin) Aaron Rodgers has been on fire. Which he has been. jg4xchamp

Rodgers is seriously the only one better, imo.-Halftime-

[QUOTE="-Halftime-"]Rodgers is seriously the only one better, imo.Silverbond

[QUOTE="jg4xchamp"]

[QUOTE="monkeytoes61"]. But the bad calls went both ways in that game. monkeytoes61

bad calls happen all the time. don't act like they don't. yes, even the real refs. the replacement refs weren't as bad as everyone made them out to be. people just acted that way because they knew they weren't the best.jeffster85

[QUOTE="Silverbond"][QUOTE="-Halftime-"]Rodgers is seriously the only one better, imo.-Halftime-

Eh I like Eli and I know how much Brady has handed to him, but Im still not gonna go as far as to say Eli>Brady. I'd take Brees and Peyton over Eli also. If Eli played every quarter like it was the 4th on the other hand...

gimmick offense -Halftime-