which tennis game is better? top spin 4 or virtua tennis 4?

which one is more real for a tennis fan.

thanks

I Have played both and I think Top Spin 4 is a much better game. I have played Virtua Tenis 4 with the move and it is terrible and virtually unplayable.

I Have played both and I think Top Spin 4 is a much better game. I have played Virtua Tenis 4 with the move and it is terrible and virtually unplayable.

Mintymatti017

I'm afraid I don't have a 3D TV so cannot comment on that. In the Move mode the camera is more right behind the player instead of the high up whole court position it usually is. The move itself feels really limited and its really difficult to play a variety of shots. You seem to only win by donig a backhand to the baseline. If you try and hit it straight up in the air it just doesnt register it and hits it back regularly. Its probably worse than the Wii tennis to be honest.

Basically it seems to register a swing rather than your actuall movement.

thanks for the replies guys. though i think i will skip both of them..maybe next year a better one will come out

Top spin 4 is the best by far. However, don't expect too much from the move, the controls aren't good enough and after few days, I've switched back to the old fashion, I was missing 1 ball on four and truly, I don't know if someone can win online with the move on, but I know I can't...Even agains't the computer, my move controller was about to visit the wall...