Heavy Rain or Bioshock 2?

ive been seriously thinking about this for a week. I dont know which one to get. I really like heavy rain's deep story, but I love bioshock 1, and im sure bioshock 2 will be better. Which one are you getting?

the main problem i have with this is they both have really great stories, and Heavy Rain looks really intriguing. What really convinced my to getting bioshock 2 is that the designer of Fort Frolic is making the game, so im pretty confident of Bioshock 2

well im gonna get both games. i already know that. but if i were you i would get bioshock 2 cuz youre already familiar with it and sounds you know you liked the first so it shouldnt be too different. get heavy rain later when you can.

Bioshock 2. Not going to get Heavy Rain.

Buy Heavy Rain and support something different and rent Bioshock 2.

Can't wait for Heavy Rain. I wasn't going to buy a new game for awhile, but dammit Heavy Rain just sold me.

I'm not so sure about Bioshock 2. I loved the first, one of my favorites, but I'm not sold on this one. Looks like more of the same with slight improvements. And they got rid of the little "Circus of Values!" sound effects. :(

Buy Heavy Rain and support something different and rent Bioshock 2.

CMPunk13

Bioshock 2. I like the originality of Heavy Rain and want to support that artistic vision but Bioshock 2 is a safer choice and I enjoyed the first game. I am going to rent Heavy Rain though

Is it true bio2 isnt made by the same team? If this is true i doubt ill pay 60 bucks for it..Fightingfan

Yeah it's 2K Marin making this one. 2K Boston (Irrational Games) made Bioshock.

I'm much more excited for Irrational's new game.

Which am I getting? Both!

BioShock 2 CE (PC) on day one, and Heavy Rain CE (HMV import) on day one.

i'm more interested with Heavy Rain...

Bioshock 2. The videos for Heavy Rain have been horrible.edthetinker

I thought this too. I wasn't really hooked on to the videos either.

Just be Greedy and get them both case solve,

i'm definitely getting Bioshock 2 first. its already gotten great reviews & i have a feeling that Heavy Rain will do the floppy flop...Fantasticus

i'm definitely getting Bioshock 2 first. its already gotten great reviews & i have a feeling that Heavy Rain will do the floppy flop...Fantasticus

Bioshock 2 all the way. Heavy Rain looks short.

Bioshock 2 all the way. Heavy Rain looks short.

Velocity

I don't know, you can play each character's side of the story, and each playthrough is supposedly about 10 hours or so. 10 X 4 = 40 hours.

I could never really get into the original Bioshock...probably won't be picking up the second.

But if you enjoyed the first, i'd definately pick up B2.

just get both if you like both games i mean two different genre, there is no conflict there.

i already have 5 games on the horizon i will get in 3 months.

1. Dante's Inferno
2. Heavy Rain
3. Final Fantasy 13
4. God of War 3
5. Super Street Fighter 4

argg this first quarter is pretty good.

Bioshock 2 will be way better. Im renting Heavy Rain

Oh please... ! Both of course! It's like saying, next month,God Of War3 (an exclusive) or Final Fantasy13? People say they are both great games so if you need to kill off a game, kill another!

just get both if you like both games i mean two different genre, there is no conflict there.

i already have 5 games on the horizon i will get in 3 months.

1. Dante's Inferno
2. Heavy Rain
3. Final Fantasy 13
4. God of War 3
5. Super Street Fighter 4

argg this first quarter is pretty good.

hangeer

me too!

Heavy Rain, i'm still yet to complete the first Bioshock, it scares me to sh**

Can't wait for Heavy Rain. I wasn't going to buy a new game for awhile, but dammit Heavy Rain just sold me.

I'm not so sure about Bioshock 2. I loved the first, one of my favorites, but I'm not sold on this one. Looks like more of the same with slight improvements. And they got rid of the little "Circus of Values!" sound effects. :(

amsfm6

[QUOTE="Fantasticus"]i'm definitely getting Bioshock 2 first. its already gotten great reviews & i have a feeling that Heavy Rain will do the floppy flop...amsfm6

PC Gamer 90/100

PSM3 = 93/100

Official XBOX Magazine = 95/100

I'm getting Heavy Rain for this month, might wait for a price drop for Bioshock 2.

Guess you should wait to see the reviews, I'm going for Heavy Rain though

I have gone with Bioshock and my neighbor will diffently get heavy rain. so i will play it then