This topic is locked from further discussion.
The USA is certainly not going to be able to retain its hegemon status given that India and China exist. However, it's highly unlikely that it will fall below 3rd place for the forseeable future.
decline in power - yes, no empire whether literal or mataphorical has ever been able to withstand forever.
but i do believe it will remain a great power among many.
I have a hard time seeing the US becoming a third world type nation, or seeing the country be torn in two or more pieces.
Lol, I don't think the US has been number one for AWHILE. China is the new world power.Jonwh18Is this a joke or are you stupid?
Wars today are not about nation versus nation anymore. I don't think any nation will fall in the future.
You can argue that the US isn't no 1 anymore in certain areas. Certainly we're down the list on education, health care, general civility.
I don't think the US will fail for some time, but every country will fall in time.
Isn't it already in decline? I mean, the US economy doesn't seem to be booming, their political system appears to be completely dysfunctional, and it doesn't look like China is about to slow down in its race to become the leading world superpower.PlaneforgerCHINA? china is a bubble waiting to burst
well it's a country so no it won't "fall" people fall, buildings fall, but countries are part of the land so no it won't fall.
Will it always be number 1 in GDP? No. Given China and India both have populations 3-4 times our own, if their income per capita reaches even miniscule levels (like $12k per year small), then their GDP will equal ours... And if it ever equalled ours, their economies would be worth 3-4 times our own...
So as they develop it is likely we will move to third, but not because we are declining, only because they are catching up to us and have billions of people...
Also, highly unlikely, but if the EU ever became autonomous with member nations becoming member states and having an over arching EU government... That too would be larger than the US... Highly unlikely though even in the distant future...
Also, the world is too globalized for the US to fall... If we fall at this point, the entire planet is coming with us as the US is the financial, social, and cultural center of the planet...
The US has only been a great power for 60 years give or take, and you're asking if it is ever going to fall ? :lol: There's no reason to think that the US is going to stay on top, especially not since China is right behind it's back. jointedyou really think china has a chance?
[QUOTE="tenaka2"]I was with you hereif the U.S. religions factions get their way
Seraphy-
and you lost me heresucceed in creationism getting thought in science class is would be the beginning of the end. They nearly managed with bush and intelligent design.
tenaka2
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/8792302/ns/politics/t/bush-schools-should-teach-intelligent-design/
Bush: Schools should teach intelligent design
I think that part of education is to expose people to different schools of thought, Bush said. Youre asking me whether or not people ought to be exposed to different ideas, the answer is yes.
The theory of intelligent design says life on earth is too complex to have developed through evolution, implying that a higher power must have had a hand in creation.
Christian conservatives a substantial part of Bushs voting base have been pushing for the teaching of intelligent design in public schools. Scientists have rejected the theory as an attempt to force religion into science education.
Sure, mention all the downsides to the U.S. and then say that China is better? Is this a joke? How is getting cancer just for living in Shanghai or Beijing and walking outside a good living condition? The fact that it is ridiculously over populated? That female children are almost worthless and discarded? How about the whole communism deal, huh? China is inferior to the U.S. in almost every way. They have a much larger military, but the United States is superior in training, discipline and technology. The age of "empires" is over. But the U.S. will always be the force to be reckoned with, and the place where people want to live.
the USA will always be among the most powerful nations, probably among the top 2 for the forseeble future.
But I have an easier time to imagining US continue falling behind in development measures, and ending up more and more resembling a developing nation.
[QUOTE="jointed"]The US has only been a great power for 60 years give or take, and you're asking if it is ever going to fall ? :lol: There's no reason to think that the US is going to stay on top, especially not since China is right behind it's back. Jandurinyou really think china has a chance? China has many, many problems, but they're creating actual wealth for their people. I don't know who the next superpower will be, but China will definitely be one of the contenders.
I doubt it will remain "No. 1" - whatever that means. But I also doubt the nation would ever fall. I dont see any of the major powers in the world ever being taken over by someone else.
China has many, many problems, but they're creating actual wealth for their people. Rhazakna
And a well thought-out strategy when it comes to foreign affairs to secure that wealth; one that isn't based on carrying a "+3 against them evil commies" stick around and calling everyone a terrorist.
I'm guessing no one has looked into China's economy? They are not fairing much better.shadowkiller11Indeed. China's economic growth is closely linked to the United States'. Keep in mind the United States feeds their population, they're arguably behind some third-world nations in terms of human rights, and that they have a lot of other economic issues that the United States does not have. Their status as a world power is only apparent from a military standpoint and if you look at direct growth trends, not the reasons behind those trends.
Maybe, we hardly fund science and research whether it be NASA or medical but because of our military I doubt we'll ever fall. But we could easily become irrevelant seeing as a large portion of our scientist and engineers are foreign born. Once they decide that coming to the U.S isn't that big a deal anymore and stop coming we could fall behind.
I doubt it. I mean, the USA is not #1 in everything. It just is generally a good place to live among all the countries in the world. Poverty in America is super low in comparison to other places. America will remain a 1st world, modern nation, but other countries could surpass it, who knows.
[QUOTE="shadowkiller11"]I'm guessing no one has looked into China's economy? They are not fairing much better.Saturos3091Indeed. China's economic growth is closely linked to the United States'. Keep in mind the United States feeds their population, they're arguably behind some third-world nations in terms of human rights, and that they have a lot of other economic issues that the United States does not have. Their status as a world power is only apparent from a military standpoint and if you look at direct growth trends, not the reasons behind those trends. China is creating actual wealth for the Chinese. Millions are being pulled out of poverty. Hong Kong is arguably the best economy in the world relative to size, and the freest market on the planet. The rest of China is moving away from central planning and toward a much more market based economy. You're right that China is dependant on the US to a large degree, but the US is now becoming perhaps even more dependent on China. "We" need them more than they need us in many unsettling ways. There are many economic issues with China, but you're kidding yourself if you think that the massive economic boom they've been experiencing is some temporary flash in the pan.
[QUOTE="Saturos3091"][QUOTE="shadowkiller11"]I'm guessing no one has looked into China's economy? They are not fairing much better.RhazaknaIndeed. China's economic growth is closely linked to the United States'. Keep in mind the United States feeds their population, they're arguably behind some third-world nations in terms of human rights, and that they have a lot of other economic issues that the United States does not have. Their status as a world power is only apparent from a military standpoint and if you look at direct growth trends, not the reasons behind those trends. China is creating actual wealth for the Chinese. Millions are being pulled out of poverty. Hong Kong is arguably the best economy in the world relative to size, and the freest market on the planet. The rest of China is moving away from central planning and toward a much more market based economy. You're right that China is dependant on the US to a large degree, but the US is now becoming perhaps even more dependent on China. "We" need them more than they need us in many unsettling ways. There are many economic issues with China, but you're kidding yourself if you think that the massive economic boom they've been experiencing is some temporary flash in the pan.
The world might not be able to support China adopting the mass consumerism found in the West. China raising more and more of it's population into the middle class could be catastrophic for the world and it's resources. I would be hypocritical to blame China, We are all to blame but either way, The world's population is far exceeding our capability to sustain, The effects are already evident, China and India rising out of poverty may be what breaks the camels back so to speak.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment