Europe is believed to be way more socialist than the US and in some ways that is true, but why is this not true when it comes to the professional sporting leagues? For example, here are some policies that the 4 major leagues in the US have:
- Salary cap
- Player unions
- NBA/NFL/NHL/MLB have a strong hold over their respective leagues
- No relegation or promotion (all teams stay in the highest divisions)
- Parity between large and small market teams isn't a big problem
- Expensive to create a new team or "franchise"
- Worst team gets a chance to have the best pick in a draft consisting of the most promising young athletes, thus "tanking" is a legit strategy
- TV revenue is more evenly split
- No team ever goes into bankrupt or administration due to franchise security
Now compare this to something like the top Soccer leagues in Europe whose leagues are based around the very capitalist policies:
- Salary caps don't exist
- No drafts
- Clubs sign whoever they want when they want (as long as it's during the transfer period)
- Players regularly get bought and sold for $ instead of traded for another player
- The gap between rich clubs and smaller ones is getting bigger
- No player unions
- Promotion and relegation are very important (worst teams get relegated to a lower league, best teams from a lower league move up)
- TV deals vary between clubs - For example, Real Madrid and Barcelona take about 50% of all the TV revenue in the Spanish league
- The best teams play in a second league outside of their country's league (Champions League or Europa League) and get extra revenue from that
- Opening a new club is cheap (obviously operating it isn't though)
- It's not uncommon to see a club dissolve because of financial issues
Some external links
A Short Animation About How the NFL Is Like Socialism
European Soccer Needs a Dose of American-Style Socialism
Nate Silver: "American sports are socialist"
So basically what I want to know is why do you think the league structures are so different? Do you prefer one or the other?
Log in to comment