I enjoyed it for the most part but to me season 4 has been weird and really never felt like it's own season at all.
Pretty much the whole first half of this season was really just and extension of Season 3, all to lead up to the amazing mid-season finale that was "Too Far Gone". The problem was that "Too Far Gone" WASN'T a mid-season finale, it was the real Season 3 finale, it had everything, the death of the Governor, the loss of Hershel and the Prison, but also left us questions like where is everyone, where do they go now, did Judith survive? Good questions for a Finale.
The problem was though, because "Too Far Gone" had all this, "A" couldn't. To me, "A" was the exact opposite as it felt more like a mid-season finale than an actual finale, yeah it resolved the dispute with Joe's group, but they really only served the purpose of getting Daryl back with Rick, they where fodder from the start. Now thought they've given us a ton of questions, Who are Terminus and why are they trapping people (probably the Hunters from the comics, but it's still not technically confirmed), who took Beth and is she alive, and where are Ty, Carol and Judith in all this, three big questions and yet no answers, which is, IMO, better for a mid-season finale because you only have to wait a month or two so the questions are still somewhat fresh in your mind, where as the gap between actual seasons is much larger.
On the whole, as an episode by itself I think it was great, it even would have worked well as a mid-season finale, but as the actual finale for the season, when you compare it to say the season 2 finale, with the Walkers swarming the Farm, or even the season 3 finale with the Governor's attack on the prison and Andrea's death it's not up there on either an action or emotional scale, and for me personally, aside from Rick biting Joe's neck, the best parts of this episode where the flashbacks to the time between seasons 3 and 4.
Log in to comment