[QUOTE="thegerg"][QUOTE="Planeforger"]I do enjoy how your example of a pro-gun advocate was also one of the most famous gunshot victims of all time. I guess that makes my response "I'm fine with Americans keeping their guns, just as long as they're fine with being shot all the time".Planeforger
That's like saying "I'm fine with Americans keeping their cars, just as long as they're fine with being injured by them all the time". It's silly.Assuming that there's an anology there (and that's shakey at best - cars are used publicly/guns privately; cars' death-dealing capacity is incidental to their central purpose/guns' central purpose is to kill; cars aren't used in many intentional killings/guns are; cars are used worldwide/guns tend to be banned or restircted in most first world counties; etc.)...people tend to be totally fine with laws designed to reduce car deaths.
There are strict regulations concerning what cars may be produced/sold, what cars people may drive, where people may drive, who is qualified to drive, what state of mind they have to be in before they get behind the wheel, etc. The whole system is strongly licenced, scrutinised and enforced, and particularly dangerous cars are quickly purged from the market.
Stronger car regulations could prevent more deaths from occurring, but at the same time some concessions need to be made to weaker drivers/unsafe cars, given the near-necessity of private transport in everyone's daily lives. The same argument for under-regulation couldn't easily be used in defence of guns.
Also, the original picture would be like using an image of Princess Diana in an endorsement for reducing car regulations. It wouldn't be particularly convincing.
*edit* To put it another way: if ridiculously fast sportscars started crashing into schoolbuses on a weekly basis, killing children with regular ease, would there be much of an outcry if the government tried to regulate sportscars more strongly, or ban those types of unsafe sportscar entirely?
In any case...that wasn't my main point at all. I was merely saying that I don't honestly care whether or not the USA ends up keeping or banning their guns, just as long as they don't act surprised or outraged at the natural and probable consequences of widespread gun ownership.
What the gov't should do is ban those cubes. Those cars are too little and look unsafe.
Log in to comment