I guess since this has become a sort of debate about whether offline co-op or online play is more fun, I'd like to weigh in a bit.
Personally, I think both can be enjoyable. But I think I've had negative experiences with both as well, and much of the time I'd just rather play a single-player game.
With online gaming, I think some of you raised good points about it being easier to play games with people and not having to go to their house to play a game. If you have like two hours in the evening to sit down and play a game with a buddy, you can call them up and get a game going and jump right into things. You don't have to share an Internet connection or hardware, you have your own screen, and you can chat over a mic or keyboard.
With couch co-op, I especially prefer it when both players share the screen and don't have to play split-screen, and it's more fun when you're playing a co-op game with your spouse or friend right there. Couch co-op can be more spontaneous - you usually don't have to plan it out, and both of you just decide to play some games sometime during a visit. And a lot of the time, you don't even need to go online to play couch co-op.
I think playing games online with friends is more fun than playing with strangers. However, there may be some debate to this, since some of my best online gaming experiences were had when I played Halo 3 campaign and Halo 3 ODST firefight online with groups of complete strangers, who were surprisingly polite I might add. By contrast, I usually had a really difficult time gathering around all of my friends and convincing them to play games with me. WOW is a good example - usually there would only be like one other friend around at a time and they'd hang out with me, but nobody else would want to play in a group with us. We also had trouble finding polite strangers to play in groups with on WOW. I think good teamwork is much harder to achieve with more than two players.
I guess I've always been really partial to handheld game systems like the 3DS because you have your own game system, controller and screen in one device, and you can do offline co-op much more efficiently. Having your own screen is nice, but being right there near the people you're playing a game with is also really nice. I remember on Advance Wars you could play a multiplayer match with one game system and one game card, and take turns commanding your units with your friend and the CPU. That was really cool. It reminds me of the days back on the NES, Genesis and SNES when player 1 and player 2 would take turns in games - also a really nice alternative to split-screen sometimes. It gave games a more 'arcade-like' feel. And that works out alright when you're hanging out with a pal and shooting the breeze, and taking turns to get through a really tough game on a day off.
Log in to comment