When it comes to the most durable of the two then mariano would win that easily but when it comes to the best "stuff", the best natural ability, then Papelbon would win that one.
 Papelbon is truly remarkable in what he has accomplished so far in his young career but his durability is questionable and he is liable to shoulder problems throughout his career, closers come and go and that is why rivera is the best ever, papelbon unfortunately has a limit to his potential because of his less then stellar makeup of his shoulder, its weak and will be tested again and again with or without a shoulder strengthening program.
Papelbon has two or three good years left, maybe, it doesn't matter starter or closer, its the sad truth. I think papelbon could very easily win a cy young or two in those two or three years, as closer, and thats one hell of an accomplishment that he is more then likely able to achieve.
Log in to comment