Carr or Delhomme???

Who should start for the Panthers this season??  I personally think Carr should start.  He is more mobile than Jake and has a way better arm. Please share your thoughts. Thanks!!!!

No need to pick now, just have theme compete for the job.  If I had to pick I'd go with Carr.duxup

your right competition does bring out the best thanks for the thoughts

i got carr. hopefully its a real competition. but i never thought delhomme was that great but the players around him made him look good. and imo panthers are sort of overrated. there a defensive playmaker and a real qb away from a series sb run. i dont think delhomme can get the job done. foster and williams, johnson and smith, and if they get that te are all good pieces on the offensive. but besides peppers i cant think of anyone on defensive except maybe nail diggs i think. (sorry about spelling)xbox360isgr8t

Actually, the Panther's do have that 2nd defensive playmaker, but he just never seems to stay healthy a whole season. Dan Morgan (when healthy), is one of the best LB's in the NFL. However, with his injuries over the last few seasons have really hurt our overall defense.

Two other players to look for to have breakout seasons next year are Richard Marshall and Thomas Davis. Marshall had some good games last year and covered his man pretty well for his 1st season and Davis did a nice job, especially when you consider the fact that he had to adapt to a new position moving from safety to linebacker.

As for who I think is the better QB, I agree it's Carr. However, Delhomme knows the Panther's system of offense a lot more than Carr so I think it is Jake's job to lose. If the Panther's do go offense in the 1st round of the draft, I hope they do draft Olsen or Jarrett. 

David Carr. He had a terrible line in Texas. I'm anxious to see what he does in Carolina. I have a feeling he will be the new starter. JDW_games

Who should start for the Panthers this season?? I personally think Carr should start. He is more mobile than Jake and has a way better arm. Please share your thoughts. Thanks!!!!

ronniemoisture

Many experts have picked the Panthers to win the NFC for the past 3 years, and they havent come close. 

[QUOTE="JDW_games"]David Carr. He had a terrible line in Texas. I'm anxious to see what he does in Carolina. I have a feeling he will be the new starter. Sportsnut101

your right. but the Panthers are now implementing a new zone blocking scheme that benefits smaller more athletic linemen.

we should see more strectch runs and cutbacks to better utilize Foster and Williams.

If Delhomme struggles go for Carr.. Plus Delhomme is really starting to look like a one year wonder IMO after having that one superbowl season..xyoojguy

A one year wonder because hes not as good as Brady or Manning? Hes a solid QB, you really have no idea what you're talking about.

[QUOTE="xyoojguy"]If Delhomme struggles go for Carr.. Plus Delhomme is really starting to look like a one year wonder IMO after having that one superbowl season..jimmygrace

A one year wonder because hes not as good as Brady or Manning? Hes a solid QB, you really have no idea what you're talking about.

I didn't say he was a bad QB..

But after they went to a superbowl that one year people expect him to lead them his team to a superbowl every single season for the past few years now.. Let just say he ever lived up to what some people excepted.. Jake is a ok QB but not great.. If he was Great QB then people wouldn't talk about Carr replacing him so much..

[QUOTE="jimmygrace"]

[QUOTE="xyoojguy"]If Delhomme struggles go for Carr.. Plus Delhomme is really starting to look like a one year wonder IMO after having that one superbowl season..xyoojguy

A one year wonder because hes not as good as Brady or Manning? Hes a solid QB, you really have no idea what you're talking about.

I didn't say he was a bad QB..

But after they went to a superbowl that one year people expect him to lead them his team to a superbowl every single season for the past few years now.. Let just say he ever lived up to what some people excepted.. Jake is a ok QB but not great.. If he was Great QB then people wouldn't talk about Carr replacing him so much..

The year after he went to the Super Bowl Steve Smith was out the entire season and he still came within 3 points of getting them in the playoffs, after that he got them back to the NFC championship game, and last season he struggled at times but every QB has a "off year".

I'd take Carr... He has the ability to be a star QB in this league, thats why he was drafted 1st overall.. It's all about the situation and I think this is the right one for Carr, he is FAR more mobile than Delhomme so when that line breaks down atleast he can avoid the rush a little bit, he didnt even have the line to do that in Houston... He has a MONSTER arm and will be able to throw downfield to Steve Smith and Drew Carter, but he has the accuracy to hit Kewshawn across the middle... If they add Greg Olson and pass the ball a little bit more this offense will be MONSTER! Deangelo and Deshaun create a good 1-2 punch in the running game as does Keyshawn and Steve, physical and then speed... This defense needs a little bit of work, maybe they can add Brandon Meriweather, the safety out of Miami in the 3rd round or so... Brian Leonard in the 2nd round wouldn't be a bad guy to take in the draft either, line him up at TE, FB, H-back, Tail back, and slot reciever... If the O-Line gives Carr time to throw then he will have a break out season....bhsxfactor

i would like for them to take olsen but patrick willis in first and leonard in the second or third would be great. Leonard is a poor mans olson and has added value because of his running ability