do you guys think Metal Gear Solid V will be able to compete with Uncharted 4 for GOTY 2015?
This topic is locked from further discussion.
Able to compete? Yes, but only if Uncharted 4 actually manages to end up in that particular competition.
I doubt Uncharted 4 will even be in the running in 2015.
Especially considering the recent gameplay video they released. It's just a higher-resolution Uncharted 2/3 with a few gameplay features brought over from The Last of Us. I'm sure fanboys will be all over it for a few months, but critics will likely be concerning themselves with all the other great games coming out this year.
I think Metal Gear Solid V looks amazing, I can't wait for it (even if I don't understand the story and what's going on lol). Uncharted 4 should be great too, I think they both will be running for GOTY in 2015 without a doubt.
@foxhound_fox: what is the general consensus of the gameplay for the phantom pain
So far it seems highly positive. Everyone is lauding the freedom and saying that Ground Zeroes only scratches the surface.
Absolutely. I'd say it has a higher chance of winning more goty awards than uncharted 4. Uncharted 4 could easily be written off as more of the same, even though it is a brilliant series.
In this time we are living in intuitivity is something critics value high when giving scores so we might see other titles getting the GOTY this year, just like last year when Shadow Of Mordor got the GOTY on alot of sites. There are no guarantee that any of these titles will get the GOTY award even though both these games will most likely be a huge success.
Definitely. In fact I think that there'll probably be a sizable selection of games competing for Game of the Year this year.
I doubt Uncharted 4 will even be in the running in 2015.
Especially considering the recent gameplay video they released. It's just a higher-resolution Uncharted 2/3 with a few gameplay features brought over from The Last of Us. I'm sure fanboys will be all over it for a few months, but critics will likely be concerning themselves with all the other great games coming out this year.
The same argument can be made about MG5, the core gameplay mechanics have slightly involved! The addition of an open world seems to be the only real significant change.
No, because Arkham Knight will claim GotY.
YEAH !
Agreed!
I doubt Uncharted 4 will even be in the running in 2015.
Especially considering the recent gameplay video they released. It's just a higher-resolution Uncharted 2/3 with a few gameplay features brought over from The Last of Us. I'm sure fanboys will be all over it for a few months, but critics will likely be concerning themselves with all the other great games coming out this year.
The same argument can be made about MG5, the core gameplay mechanics have slightly involved! The addition of an open world seems to be the only real significant change.
I'm not sure what videos you've watched, but while I have very little interest in playing it, I can admit that it's come a very long way since MGS4. The addition of the open world opens up tons of opportunities for evolving the MGS gameplay. And they've only shown a small slice of it. The movement model alone has gone from very "gamey" to almost a stealth simulation.
The question is will uncharted be able to compete with mgs?
the anwer: no, mgs main games always obliterate any other games in that year, and i do mean everything.
Well considering the Engine works almost flawlessly on even old pc hardware, I'd say it's far more likely to be game of the year as it's on more platforms and ,from a AAA developer that seems to have actually put the work in to have their game work right on all platforms and card models. I honestly don't even see Uncharted coming close to competing, MGS is just to big a hit series and Kojima all ways pulls out all the stops.
Well it probably will, as far as i'm concerned, be Mgas, as MGS is always great, and an open world MGS is a dream coming to reality, but I still think Uncharted 4 will be a great game as well
do you guys think Metal Gear Solid V will be able to compete with Uncharted 4 for GOTY 2015?
this thread serious? i seriously doubt uncharted will be able to compete with mgs5. i enjoy the uncharted games but there standard 3rd person adventure games that dont bring much to the table, and even if mgs5 were to flop, it at least tried to change up the formula and bring something fun and new to the table. aside from being a solid game i doubt uncharted 4 will be any better than uncharted 3, which was great, but hardly game of the year.
I doubt Uncharted 4 will even be in the running in 2015.
Especially considering the recent gameplay video they released. It's just a higher-resolution Uncharted 2/3 with a few gameplay features brought over from The Last of Us. I'm sure fanboys will be all over it for a few months, but critics will likely be concerning themselves with all the other great games coming out this year.
The same argument can be made about MG5, the core gameplay mechanics have slightly involved! The addition of an open world seems to be the only real significant change.r
even though your wrong and that isnt the only significant change made. your acting like that isnt a huge change. im sure its not as big a change of uncharted 4's new guns are whatever its going to bring to the table, i can say without a doubt that mgs5 changes more of its mechanics then uncharted
I doubt Uncharted 4 will even be in the running in 2015.
Especially considering the recent gameplay video they released. It's just a higher-resolution Uncharted 2/3 with a few gameplay features brought over from The Last of Us. I'm sure fanboys will be all over it for a few months, but critics will likely be concerning themselves with all the other great games coming out this year.
The same argument can be made about MG5, the core gameplay mechanics have slightly involved! The addition of an open world seems to be the only real significant change.r
even though your wrong and that isnt the only significant change made. your acting like that isnt a huge change. im sure its not as big a change of uncharted 4's new guns are whatever its going to bring to the table, i can say without a doubt that mgs5 changes more of its mechanics then uncharted
Oh goodness,there is no right or wrong in this situation, it's all a matter of OPINION..... we can agree to disagree! Besides, I'm not impressed with either games and I have no plans on buying them.
I doubt Uncharted 4 will even be in the running in 2015.
Especially considering the recent gameplay video they released. It's just a higher-resolution Uncharted 2/3 with a few gameplay features brought over from The Last of Us. I'm sure fanboys will be all over it for a few months, but critics will likely be concerning themselves with all the other great games coming out this year.
The same argument can be made about MG5, the core gameplay mechanics have slightly involved! The addition of an open world seems to be the only real significant change.r
even though your wrong and that isnt the only significant change made. your acting like that isnt a huge change. im sure its not as big a change of uncharted 4's new guns are whatever its going to bring to the table, i can say without a doubt that mgs5 changes more of its mechanics then uncharted
Oh goodness,there is no right or wrong in this situation, it's all a matter of OPINION..... we can agree to disagree! Besides, I'm not impressed with either games and I have no plans on buying them.
opinion based on ignorance, and thats a pretty enlightened way of thinking as you try and shit on mgs5.
I honestly don't see how MGS will fare well in an open world setting.
Sure, the stealth will work in specific hub areas, but the rest of the world is probably going to compromise MGS's gameplay nature. My guess is that people will most likely end up playing it as a third person shooter for most of the game. If Konami can (hopefully) pull it off though, it might very well be the best game of the year. They haven't really proven how they will approach the open world. Everything they've shown has been basic hub gameplay or has been heavily choreographed (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jCDQsJrZWUs)
If there's one AAA game I would blindly place as a GOTY winner, it will probably end up being Witcher 3. However, I think a little game called "Torment, tides of Numenera" is probably going to surprise a lot of people if they successfully release it this year. The same way Divinity: Original Sin came out of no where and stole a lot of accolades.
@verbalfilth: You made a good and fair point about the open world. There will of course be small enemy outposts and probably bases, but we do not know what else willl be in the open world. But eh, I have no worries. But I doubt most are going to play as a TPS. You have those who do not really care for stealth, but it has the fanbase it has, due to being a stealth game with its on style
I doubt Uncharted 4 will even be in the running in 2015.
Especially considering the recent gameplay video they released. It's just a higher-resolution Uncharted 2/3 with a few gameplay features brought over from The Last of Us. I'm sure fanboys will be all over it for a few months, but critics will likely be concerning themselves with all the other great games coming out this year.
The same argument can be made about MG5, the core gameplay mechanics have slightly involved! The addition of an open world seems to be the only real significant change.r
even though your wrong and that isnt the only significant change made. your acting like that isnt a huge change. im sure its not as big a change of uncharted 4's new guns are whatever its going to bring to the table, i can say without a doubt that mgs5 changes more of its mechanics then uncharted
Oh goodness,there is no right or wrong in this situation, it's all a matter of OPINION..... we can agree to disagree! Besides, I'm not impressed with either games and I have no plans on buying them.
opinion based on ignorance, and thats a pretty enlightened way of thinking as you try and shit on mgs5.
Well, you show your obvious ignorance and immaturity by name calling just because I don't share you view of MG5!
Most adults can handle disagreements without resorting to childish rants, which obviously means you are not an adult, so I'm not wasting anymore time discussing this with you! But if you feel a need to have the last word, then by all means....knock yourself out! :)
I doubt Uncharted 4 will even be in the running in 2015.
Especially considering the recent gameplay video they released. It's just a higher-resolution Uncharted 2/3 with a few gameplay features brought over from The Last of Us. I'm sure fanboys will be all over it for a few months, but critics will likely be concerning themselves with all the other great games coming out this year.
The same argument can be made about MG5, the core gameplay mechanics have slightly involved! The addition of an open world seems to be the only real significant change.r
even though your wrong and that isnt the only significant change made. your acting like that isnt a huge change. im sure its not as big a change of uncharted 4's new guns are whatever its going to bring to the table, i can say without a doubt that mgs5 changes more of its mechanics then uncharted
Oh goodness,there is no right or wrong in this situation, it's all a matter of OPINION..... we can agree to disagree! Besides, I'm not impressed with either games and I have no plans on buying them.
opinion based on ignorance, and thats a pretty enlightened way of thinking as you try and shit on mgs5.
Well, you show your obvious ignorance and immaturity by name calling just because I don't share you view of MG5!
Most adults can handle disagreements without resorting to childish rants, which obviously means you are not an adult, so I'm not wasting anymore time discussing this with you! But if you feel a need to have the last word, then by all means....knock yourself out! :)
i guess only you can name call and not be childish right ;)
oh and i didnt call you a name, if you were an adult who could read youd know that, showing you own ignorance in spades.
the only one childish here is you :)
your feeble minded attempts at trying to gain the upper hand in our little debate is adorable, im sure yourll be the bigger man and keep ur ignorant mouth shut. like you would have if you were truly an adult like you tried to imply.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment