What was the best overall Sonic the Hedgehog game?

This topic is locked from further discussion.

#1 Posted by EmeraId_Warrior (25 posts) -
I would give it to Sonic Adventure 2, Sonic had lost a ton of relevance on the Saturn, and people were thinking twice about those high ratings Sonic Adventure 1 got with all its many problems. The solid quick gameplay, Shadow, and the sense of speed in Sonic Adventure 2 saved Sonic and it got it back on the map even increasing sales for Adventure 1. It was and still is an amazing game. As a runner-up, Sonic CD, you need to own both the U.S. and the EU/JP version for the music, the time traveling awarding speed, and tons of content and hours of play. Last of the top 2 would be Shadow the Hedgehog, it was a good game, and people saying it was not a good Sonic game but a good game need to realize it's not a Sonic game in the first place. It was pretty well made and much better than other Sonic games at the time after Sonic Adventure 2, including the horrific Sonic Advance games, and the Sonic Riders spin-off.
#2 Posted by Jakandsigz (6341 posts) -
I almost fell for it. :lol:
#3 Posted by Seabas989 (11308 posts) -

:lol:

#4 Posted by Eikichi-Onizuka (8201 posts) -
Aww you used an uppercase"i" instead of a lowercase "L" to copy someone's name. Clever.
#5 Posted by Dudersaper (32950 posts) -
Seriously?
#6 Posted by AcidSoldner (7051 posts) -
The amount of trolls on Legacy Platforms has been increasing at an alarming rate these past couple of years.
#7 Posted by Seabas989 (11308 posts) -

The amount of trolls on Legacy Platforms has been increasing at an alarming rate these past couple of years.AcidSoldner

It's sad really because I think it's two-three people at most out of all the alt accounts.

#8 Posted by EmeraId_Warrior (25 posts) -
I don't understand what is going on. The name was taken, I had no other way and spaces are not allowed. I am a big sonic fans, so Emerald_warrior should be an obvious name choice. But if it's against the rules maybe a mod can change my username?
#9 Posted by drekula2 (3242 posts) -

Top Tier - Sonic 2 , Sonic 1, Sonic 3

High Tier - Sonic Adventure 1-2 , Colors, Generations

Mid Tier - Secret Rings, Heroes , Unleashed , Sonic Rush , Sonic 4

Low Tier - Shadow

Fail Tier - Sonic 06, Sonic R

#10 Posted by Spinnerweb (2957 posts) -

It's not nice of you to steal a long-time member's username.

If you really aren't trying to troll, then I'm sure you're creative enough to think of another one.

#11 Posted by Darkman2007 (17929 posts) -

[QUOTE="AcidSoldner"]The amount of trolls on Legacy Platforms has been increasing at an alarming rate these past couple of years.Seabas989

It's sad really because I think it's two-three people at most out of all the alt accounts.

we should be proud, the guy likes us enough to constantly go back here to talk to us.
#12 Posted by Spinnerweb (2957 posts) -
[QUOTE="Seabas989"]

[QUOTE="AcidSoldner"]The amount of trolls on Legacy Platforms has been increasing at an alarming rate these past couple of years.Darkman2007

It's sad really because I think it's two-three people at most out of all the alt accounts.

we should be proud, the guy likes us enough to constantly go back here to talk to us.

No, he's just stupid and he wants attention. I hope he gets permanently banned by his IP Address and I hope he cries and he goes home. I always wanted to say something as harsh as that. I finally got my wish :D