Kingdoms of Amalur has superior combat compared to TW2; the former has a good combat system reminiscent of DMC/God of War and it requires a small degree of skill, especially when compared to the mindless hacking and slashing of Two Worlds 2, which in addition is pretty clunky
Both games feature a lot of side quests, and they are fun and varied to a degree. The main drawback from KoA is that it's highly generic and very uninspired, it all looks like it was taken from prior games, and many of it's world and art design in general derives from Fable and World of Warcraft. Add in boring story and forgettable lore and the lack of soul and heart becomes apparent
Two Worlds 2 doesn't deviate too much from standard RPG design either, but the aforementioned charm is what carried it for me; the game doesn't take itself too seriously. Two Worlds 2 has a sense of humor and is lighthearted to an extent. The writing and voice acting is cheesy, sure, but that's a part of the charm; TW2 has a sense of humor and is mostly lighthearted compared to the standard fantasy fare of KoA. There is a feeling of pure, sincere Fantasy RPG about it, similar to the Divinity games, hard to describe on my part.
There is an over-encompassing artificial feel about KoA, contrasting to TW 2 which felt to me like a project of passion. This directly affected everything else in my experience; TW 2's characters felt more memorable and legitimate, the world more believable and immersive. This comes to play in the cutscenes you mentioned as well; TW 2 has over-the-top cutscenes like a dark knight figthing an orc swordsman with extreme choreography, while KoA's are reserved for boring dialogues, introductions etc.
That's not to say Amalur isn't polished; the animations are fluid, graphics vibrant and colorful and the combat is fun and precise; all miles ahead of TW 2.
So, to conclude, I'd personally recommend Two Worlds over KoA, but then again I have a very specific taste when it comes to RPGs. If you prefer better combat and Fable + WoW sounds like a good mix, by all means buy KoA: Reckoning. If you ask me, you can't go wrong with either.
Log in to comment