best madden on ps2?

This topic is locked from further discussion.

#1 Posted by sebs09 (475 posts) -

In your opinion, what was the best madden to grace the ps2? I think it was madden 2004 all because of the new playmaker controls. I think those changed the game for the better. But then again, 2005 had the defensive playmaker controls added, so that also improved the game immensely.

#2 Posted by infamous_27 (857 posts) -

Well doesn't every new Madden on PS2 have everything from the previous Maddens on PS2? Wouldn't that make Madden 09 the best Madden on PS2?

#3 Posted by sebs09 (475 posts) -

Well doesn't every new Madden on PS2 have everything from the previous Maddens on PS2? Wouldn't that make Madden 09 the best Madden on PS2?

infamous_27
not really though, it seemed like each year they added a feature they took one out from the previous year.
#4 Posted by Toxic8 (1653 posts) -

I would say 2005 if you took out the newer games. It was a good madden game.

#5 Posted by chadwick1343 (935 posts) -
My favorite year was 3003, I think that was the year they made the biggest improvement
#6 Posted by sebs09 (475 posts) -

I would say 2005 if you took out the newer games. It was a good madden game.

Toxic8
that's the one i was looking towards, for it had the playmaker controls on offense and defense, so it kinda balanced out the game a bit.
#7 Posted by magnax1 (4605 posts) -

On the Cube it was 03, because they left it fairly simple and the gameplay was just plain fun.

#8 Posted by psufootball (151 posts) -

'06. McNabb was on the cover so it was automatically became the best.