I was trying to refrain from saying "underrated" since I am not (necessarily) asking you which games you love that didn't get 9's and higher :P. I am asking for games you really enjoyed (be it an 8, 9, or 10 in your eyes) but went largely unnoticed. I thought of this cause I was remembering some games from last gen that I know had some issues, but had interesting ideas and I really enjoyed.
This might be a nice way to let others know of good games they should look into playing, that they otherwise may have not considered.
For me, it is going to be NIntendo systems, since that is where I played the majority of my games, though in recent years I have played many PS titles and such as well.
TRY TO ADD PICS :)
SNES / PC
One Must Fall: 2097
MIckey's Magical Quest
Micro Machines 64
Mystical Ninja: Starring Goemon
Baten Kaitos Origins
Some of these games may have been more popular than I realize.
I am not sure if all of them would be enjoyable to me today (Lost Kingdoms and Flying Dragon), but some are definitely still awesome (Baten Kaitos and Goof Troop).