When you get right down to it, the ESPN-flavored look is what really sets ESPN Major League Baseball apart from other baseball games.
Visual Concepts used to call its baseball franchise World Series Baseball--that is, until the company started calling itself ESPN Videogames to play up its marketing agreement with ESPN. This explains why the follow-up to World Series Baseball 2K3 is called ESPN Major League Baseball, and it's why ESPN MLB does a much better job of duplicating the sights and sounds of an actual ESPN broadcast than WSB 2K3 did. Aside from the ESPN-inspired makeover, this year's game also includes five new play modes, competitive online play, and a handful of new optional interface settings that increase the amount of control you have over players on the field. These upgrades aren't nearly as impressive as some of the things that other companies have put into their games--most notably EA Sports and its MVP Baseball 2004 (with its controlled slides, actual minor league teams, and pen-and-paper-style manager's mode)--but they do bring a little something extra to what was already a great baseball game.
It's worth mentioning from the outset that the PS2 version of ESPN Major League Baseball came out a month after the Xbox version did. Visual Concepts, the game's developer, used that time to iron out some of the bugs that were evident in the Xbox release. These bugs included such things as errors being ruled on slow throws to first, runs being awarded when runners crossed the plate during a two-out force play, and balls hitting fielders on the back and then bouncing into their gloves. These glitches don't occur in the PS2 game. The situation mode has been fixed as well. Now, when you set up a scenario in late innings, the CPU won't give out intentional walks by the handful or suddenly switch fielders on you while you're fielding the ball. Bottom line: If you have the choice, pick up the PS2 version. There are precious few reasons not to. The biggest among these is 720p high definition support. The Xbox game has it, but the PS2 game doesn't. However, the PS2 does, at least, have a 480p option. Otherwise, the graphics in the PS2 version are just as sharp, and the player animations are just as smooth as those found in the Xbox game. As for other nitpicks specific to the PS2 game, there are significant load times during bullpen changes and player replacements, and, for some bizarre reason, the option to enable automatic fielding was left out of this version.
The first thing you'll notice once you start a game is that games really do look and sound like actual ESPN TV broadcasts. The menus, pregame screens, and replay transitions all use authentic ESPN typefaces, logos, and special effects. Strike out on a particularly nasty pitch and the ESPN K-Zone display will appear showing the trajectory of the ball from a variety of different angles. When the camera focuses in for a close-up on a particular player--usually when he comes to the plate or reaches base on a close play--ESPN infographics appear that provide unique statistical information about the player or his team's recent performance. For instance, if a hitter steps up to the plate with a man on second, the infographic will show how that particular hitter performs with runners in scoring position. Pause the game and the ESPN SportsTicker will appear at the bottom of the screen to update you with scores from around the rest of the league. The ESPN branding also extends to the game's audio. Karl Ravech, the host of ESPN's Baseball Tonight, introduces the teams and discusses pitching matchups before each game, while Rex Hudler and ESPN's play-by-play man, Jon Miller, contribute color commentary and playcalling during the game. The play-by-play doesn't always keep pace with the action, but the variety of things that Hud and Miller say makes up for that. If a pitcher gives up three straight hits or if a hitter is having a particularly good day at the plate, they'll mention it in a manner that makes you feel like you're participating in an interactive version of an ESPN baseball telecast.
There are various, other not-so-ESPN-specific improvements evident in the visuals and audio of this year's game as well. The instant replays have been fixed so that they now show the entire play and not just a snippet of it. The stadiums look nicer, mainly because the grass and dirt on the fields actually kicks up now whenever a play is made. The player animation is better too. Batting stances and plays on the field look smoother, and there are just a lot more plays, in general, to see. As for the audio, the developers have livened up the crowd for this release. Fans cheer when the home team puts a runner on base, when a run is scored, and when outs are made against the opposing team. If the game is close during late innings, the volume level of the crowd rises accordingly. The amount of heckling has been increased as well. When visiting players come up to bat, the fans let loose with comments like, "Your commercials stink, Jeter!" or "Hey, Pokey! You're an easy out!"
The people at Visual Concepts should have gone farther with the graphical upgrades, partly because other baseball video games have had time to catch up but also because the flaws that were merely irksome last year are downright glaring this year. Player faces are hit or miss. For every player--like Nomar Garciaparra, Pedro Martinez, and Alex Rodriguez--that looks perfect, there are players--like Hideki Matsui and Sammy Sosa--that look absolutely disfigured. While the number of different play animations has increased since last year, the same two or three diving stops and put-outs still seem to happen between first and second base. MVP Baseball 2004 has at least 40 different play animations for the second baseman alone.
These shortcomings, while they have to be mentioned, should be taken with a grain of salt. ESPN Major League Baseball is a beautiful game in many other equally relevant ways. The visuals are extremely sharp, and the level of detail is exceptional. First basemen lean out to make off-balance catches. Second basemen and shortstops cut a line in the dirt whenever they make catches from their knees. In many stadiums, scoreboards update to reflect the current score and scores from around the league. Hit a ball into the outfield and you'll be able to see the plaques in Monument Park at Yankee Stadium. Or the boats sitting in McCovey Cove outside SBC Park in San Francisco. Or the cars driving along the bridges that span the Ohio River outside Great American Ballpark in Cincinnati.