Gamers like a great story over flashy graphics. I see that gamespot didn't care too much for the old point and click but I think maybe they missed the charm about this game. Come on now, who hasn't pulled out their old Diablo II and played that. Point and click, crappy graphics but still addictive right. I am not a fan either but one thing I do enjoy is a good story with a great adventure. I truly enjoyed this title, and I've placed it right next to Syberia as one of my favorite Point and Click adventures. Sometimes the subtle charm and feel of an old school build is just sweat. More companies should concentrate on story and content and less on trying to have ground breaking graphics and all the fluff.