It may not reinvent the genre but thats just fine.
Doom started FPS gameing and it's been a bg part of the genre ever since. Doom 3 is the logical step from doom 2 offering the sam style of run and survival horror, though it doesn't anything new or exciting like Half life 2,or Call of duty, instead it sticks to the tried and true doom formula.
Graphics 10/10
Really the graphics engine is fuel for the doom 3 fire.Even now in 08 doom 3 looks amazing with great looking demons and lots of blood and guts.The game also has awesome weopons that bot look and function smooth.
Sound 8/10
Basic sound effects and voice acting dominate the sound. But story was never played a big role in doom so it's easy to oerlook.
Value 8/10
A 20 hour storyline is all your going to get in doom 3 since online is dead and even if you can manage to find a game it's very bare bones stuff with zero depth.
The good
Intence singe player brings back the classic doom,Amazing graphics that look great even 4 years later.
The bad
Its extremely straightforward,Story is little more then an excuse to put a marine in hells way,Online is dead and boring.