Rental for the Stunning Xbox 360 !
The positives it that its something you might be familuar with, so this will help the gameplay and although their are lots of pirates games available on multiple formats and consoles, this shines through because of the sountrack, sound effects, and amazing graphics, which are crisp clear and well animated.
I don't over expect much from most games, because quite frankly a lot are pants, and especially PC games that crash half way through playing and the Xbox 360 reliability is the reason I now own one.
This game is definately a rental, and thats a negative, it would have been nice to have a fully multiplayer roleplay game for the Xbox 360 and it isn't that. Its good, its great but its simple not worth the money shelling out for a few weeks play at tops. I've been playing it two days, and I swear I'm half way through.
But if your sceptical about it, then push those fears away, and play it.