Half and Half
So to cut to the goods and bads:
Good:
-Decent graphics, Source Engine is not the best but definitely not the worst.
-Somewhat decent replay value (multiple endings; however could be improved)
-Death/Killing, overall combat system is okay but could use improvements: I absolutely love sneaking behind goblins/orcs and backstabbing them. The spells are pretty fun to use as well. Can get boring though.
-Xana, my favorite character of the game, hah
Bad:
-Bugs, lots of them:
-Placing two ropes next to each other and climbing them caused me to get stuck and forced me to reload to my last save.
-Loading times are ridiculous;was able to get a snack from the kitchen and back and it still wasn't complete. The loading sequences ruins the atmosphere of a large world.
-Stupid AI; while cloaking, I've walked in front of an orc in broad daylight and was able to walk to his back to backstab.
-Sometimes my camera would get bugged and my hands would stay behind me unless I turn around, or the camera would be shaky.
-The difficulty seemed to be inconsistent for me, sometimes the same monsters would be ridiculously hard to kill and others a Sunday walk through a park.
Other:
-The rope bow seems kind of rigged since you can climb onto an unreachable area and use it to kill all the monsters since it has infinite shots