The evidence may never lie but Ubisoft did when they said this was good..
The stories and plots are just as riveting as the pc versions,but the port from pc to console is terrible there are very annoying glitches in the game,which could be forgiven(as there are a few on pc) if there were not issues with the sound and voice overs,aswell as the control systems.
The graphics are also very sloppy but add the long loading times and you have a great story hidden under piles of annoyance.
It is really annoying given the power of the xbox and the amazing games that can be developed if the developers spend alot of time and money....
Overall fans of the shows should get the pc version....if no pc then get this game as long as you can be patient with the port issues you will enjoy.