Even though I haven't played the first Condemned. condemned 2 is a creepy and brutal sensation with a great storyline.

User Rating: 8.5 | Condemned 2 PS3
I wouldn't have thought of it being as good but condemned 2 is just totally awesome with a scary atomsphere through most of the game and kick ass gameplay where you can use almost everything around you as a weapon these include sticks,pipes,crowbars,toilet seats,bowling balls,baseball bats,guns,dolls,crutches etc. And also you get to carry out investigations for evidence where you will have to identify murder victims and find out how they died bu using a UV light, spectrometer, camera and a GPS.
Besides all that you get a lot of scares from tramps or Ho-bos, dolls,black tar like monsters and a hoodie looking guy with vampire teeth. Not including online where one of you is a cop and the other a murder victim and the cop has to find the evidence against you but you have to stop him by hiding it from him or something like that anyway.
So if you want to get scared from a nutter with a baseball bat then this is the game for you.
My overall rating is 8.5/10 because its pure creepy and a brutal game.