Great game, great story, lots of blood.
Presentation: A quite interesting story that will have you wondering what's going on from start to finish. There's quite a bit of racism in the story but that's how the old wild west was.
Gameplay: It's gritty, violent, and surprisingly fast paced for a game where the firearm hammers are slower than a turtle, unless you tell your character to fire a pistol with two hands.
Graphics: They look great for its year and there's blood everywhere. There's no framerate drops from what I've played and it all looks quite good.
Sound: The firearms sound very powerful and the whip really has the satisfying snap. The voice acting is great, but the most annoying part is when you accidentally whip out the bible and pull the trigger, Ray recites verses and you fire with your pistol until the screaming is over.
Lasting Appeal: No one plays the multiplayer anymore but it was fairly fun while it lasted. If you don't mind dying in campaign a lot more, you can always play the campaign again because of how fun it is when you aren't dying.