Sign on Options
Theme: [Light Selected] To Dark»

Best Role-Playing Game

Few genres have benefited more from faster processors and improved graphics hardware than role-playing games. Fantasy worlds now rival the scale of small cities and feature the artistry to bring these environments to life like never before. Although RPGs have featured complex, intertwined storylines for some time, hardware improvements have enriched the storytelling. Narrative (and even interactive) cutscenes now feature detailed character emotion and body language to make the experience all the more lifelike. The role-playing game of the year takes this concept to the next level by not telling a story; instead, the game makes you feel as if you are writing the story as you go.

Voting Results:

Best Role-Playing Game
Crisis Core: Final Fantasy VII
12%
 
2,202
Fable II
15%
 
2,826
The World Ends With You
7%
 
1,251
Fallout 3
58%
 
10,883
Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 4
8%
 
1,534

Readers' Choice Winner

Fallout 3

Fallout 3 GameSpot's Best Games of 2008 Readers' Choice Winner

Vault-Tec engineers have worked around the clock on an interactive reproduction of Wasteland life for you to enjoy from the comfort of your own vault. Included is an expansive world, unique combat, shockingly realistic visuals, tons of player choice, and an incredible cast of dynamic characters. Every minute is a fight for survival against the terrors of the outside world - radiation, Super Mutants, and hostile mutated creatures. From Vault-Tec, America's First Choice in Post Nuclear Simulation. Vault 101 - Jewel of the Wastes. For 200 years, Vault 101 has faithfully served the surviving residents of Washington DC and its environs, now known as the Capital Wasteland. Though the global atomic war of 2077 left the US all but destroyed, the residents of Vault 101 enjoy a life free from the constant stress of the outside world. Giant Insects, Raiders, Slavers, and yes, even Super Mutants are all no match for superior Vault-Tec engineering. Yet one fateful morning, you awake to find that your father has defied the Overseer and left the comfort and security afforded by Vault 101 for reasons unknown. Leaving the only home you've ever known, you emerge from the Vault into the harsh Wasteland sun to search for your father, and the truth.

Best Role-Playing Game
602 comments
Razz9999
Razz9999

FALLOUT 3 ALL THE WAY!!!!!!!!!!

Darnasian
Darnasian

i will choose fable 2 and fallout 3 because i'm a fan of the both games!!!

shadowchronicle
shadowchronicle ranger

to amny xbox fans around.. no one likes japanese rpgs anymore.:| they should be separated fallout 3 shouldn't be with persona 4 and the others also fable. what kind of list is this.

doompc
doompc

woot fallout 3! yay

Rizer
Rizer like.author.displayName 1 Like

Persona 4! Sure, Fallout 3 was good but...PERSONA 4!

Vivi2010
Vivi2010

I went with Persona 4 myself. I'll have to agree with Zakedestiny and others here; while Fallout 3 is an awesome game - I played around 60 hours of it and beat it - Persona 4 had an incredible story and deep characters. It's been awhile since I've played a RPG that hit me as much as P4. While Fallout 3 does deserve every inch of hype and praise it got, it's really a shame that P4 didn't get the same recognition. Hopefully more people will play it and see what a great game it is.

Timbydude
Timbydude

That being said, I do think Neku was one of the best RPG characters in a while, though.

Timbydude
Timbydude

@calvinsora- I too have played both, but each is good in its own way. I'd say that Fallout does get a slight edge, though, just because of how absolutely massive it is.

calvinsora
calvinsora ranger

The fact that TWEWY is at the bottom shows how few have actually played it. I've played and finished Fallout 3 and TWEWY, and even though Fallout 3 is a nice game, TWEWY is the dominant one. It's awesome.

IchigoNobody
IchigoNobody

why is persona so underappreciated? still fallout 3 deserved the award

spiralhedgehog
spiralhedgehog

Fallout 3 was a good choice, even though I voted a little too late before this realization, but IMO, Persona 4 is the best RPG. Tales of Vesperia really should have been nominated, at least. (My original vote was Fallout though)

sensfanVone
sensfanVone

Fallout 3 is cool, but that and Fable don't really fit with the other nominees.

Timbydude
Timbydude

[This message was deleted at the request of the original poster]

Timbydude
Timbydude

@Hector530- Zelda isn't an RPG. If that's an RPG, then what keeps, say, Grand Theft Auto from also being classified as an RPG? Mass Effect is most definitely an RPG because the focus of the game is on strategically customizing your squad for battle as they level up. In Zelda, you're solving logic puzzles and acquiring a few (usually required) upgrades. That's not an RPG; that's an action-adventure game.

renato1988
renato1988

Well i wouldn't put Fallout 3 here its more FPS or third FPS but very well

AnelZukic
AnelZukic

I'm really disaponted that not enough peoples had played TWEWY it's by far the best RPG game of the previous year :D. Persona 4 is also awesome and showed that PS2 is still alive :D Crisis Core is a new story to world famous story about Shinra, Spehiroth and Cloud, but Fable II and Fallout 3 attracted alot people who never played RPG's and just because they aren't JRPG which I preffer :(

SoulPsychadelic
SoulPsychadelic

I have to disagree with no clue on this one Fallout 3 > Oblivion for me atleast. Oh and I hate jrpgs so it was ony between fallout 3 and fable for me. I guess I'm a little bias

noclue_27
noclue_27

I would honestly vote for The World Ends With You on this one. P.S. Oblivion>Fallout3

pinkyfoo
pinkyfoo

Tales of Vesperia should have been nominated

Shibiroiba
Shibiroiba

Well no complainments here since I did like Fallout 3 a lot and would play it many times after that just to see Megaton exploding =D, however I did like Crysis Core (very graphics movies, of course it's Final Fantasy) and TWEWY has an interesting story and gameplay.

hector530
hector530

i like JRPG nerds who say action RPGs are not really RPGs so every ZELDA game isnt an RPG right? mass effect too(RPG of the year winner also)! so if it isnt a turn based game its not a RPG yeah sure. well if you think that you'll be missing some of the best RPGs ever made.

rennik_l
rennik_l

Fallout 3 is the rightful owner of this title for 08, the choices, the world, the quests, even if the main quest story end is dissapointing (from what I've heard, still doing side quests :P) it's an incredible RPG that really lets you put yourself in the world and act how you want.

The_Iron_Ace
The_Iron_Ace

Meh. Persona 4 felt more like an RPG then Fallout 3 did...way more.

thesameer94
thesameer94

totally agree, crisis core was also an incredible RPG

Goomba_Lord37
Goomba_Lord37

Fallout 3 is a very fun game. This award was well deserved.

SSBFan12
SSBFan12

I agree Fallout 3 was a great role playing game.

egolgeli
egolgeli

yeah, i agree them.. fallout 3 deserves that award..

Miles47
Miles47

Fallout 3 rightfully deserves this, but fable 2 shouldnt be up there, and where is Vesperia?

theholyrevenger
theholyrevenger

Why only 8% vote for Persona 4 !!!!! It's a greatest game

evratto
evratto

"FALLOUT3 and FABLEII" both are the best rpgs I have ever played, the difference is that Fallout3 is something serious and FableII is a fabulous fun.

SopranosFan
SopranosFan

Fallout 3 even though it definitely took a couple of shooter elements wouldn't qualify as a shooter at all. It is most certainly a RPG and 1 of the best I have played in the current gen systems. I kind of wish I would have spent the extra money for a PS3 that was backward compatible to play games like P4 though.

eric_neo3
eric_neo3

Fallout 3 a semi rpg beating Persona 4? I smell a gametrailers like screw-up.

Twilight_King85
Twilight_King85

Fallout is the best i thought fallout and fable 2 were equal

feslpsp
feslpsp

Fallout 3 is better gameplay but the winner story is Crisis Core

drsleo
drsleo

Fallout is good but i love FF...

ibanez187
ibanez187

obvious win for fallout 3; theres no way a DS game is gonna win.

longinus_525
longinus_525

What in the hell people ? O f course fallout 3 is a Rpg, Bethesda is only famous because they do Rpg's (tes series anybody ?) Hell even the game engine was made for rpg's... they are currently making one fps and for that they will use unreal 3 engine.... so no doubts here please I get really pissed when anybody says this is 1 fps... for starters i could get by most off the game without killing anyone...

-admiralcrunch-
-admiralcrunch-

Shoulda been Persona, but this is expected since it's on a last-gen system =P

AWESOME_GAME
AWESOME_GAME

Nah... Twewy deserves it... Fallout 3 is more to the shooter side than RPG. It doesn't have much Level-up, which is the mosqt important thing in an RPG (imo). Of course. it has it's traces... But still it's more of a shooter.

Night-kitsune
Night-kitsune

fallout?if thats an RPG dad wont be happy,sad TWEWY didnt win

roxn_104
roxn_104

great.. exactly what i expected. n who says fallout3 isnt RPG

Stabby
Stabby

Fallout 3 is an RPG... an RPG isn't just what Japan churns out IE turn based, hence why many critics like to use the term western RPG.

Conversation powered by Livefyre